5 ms·
slashdot had this covered years ago. literally decades. 1. upvotes limited to +5. 2. votes categorized: funny, informative, insightful, etc. 3. number of vot
by baq 5y ago
slashdot had this covered years ago. literally decades.
1. upvotes limited to +5.
2. votes categorized: funny, informative, insightful, etc.
3. number of votes limited per time frame and user karma.
4. meta-moderation: your votes (up/down both) were subject to voting (correct/incorrect). good score == more upvotes to spend.
and yet, simple trumps good. i was very happy to see parts of this implemented in steam reviews.
- Mordisquitos 5y agoAnother alternative, which may be somewhat controversial, was introduced years ago in Menéame [0], a Spanish website which is somewhat of a cross between Slashdot and Reddit. In summary, they made the votes public. For every comment, you can see who gave it an upvote and who gave it a downvote. In my opinion the change was worth it. The positive effects are that it strongly discourages organised vote brigading, cheap "I disagree" downvotes, and shy upvotes supporting actual nasty comments. Of course, even if this were possible to implement on Reddit's backend, the sheer scale of votes in the thousands would probably make it unfeasible. However, it would be a very good way to tackle cross-subreddit vote brigading, and would for instance make /r/SubredditDrama's "Do not vote in linked threads" rule much easier to enforce, rather than relying on the honour system. [0] https://www.meneame.net https://www.meneame.net
- darkerside 5y agoThey should make it a lottery system and show a random 10 people. The threat/possibility may be enough discouragement.
- gruez 5y ago>4. meta-moderation: your votes (up/down both) were subject to voting (correct/incorrect). good score == more upvotes to spend. Doesn't this lead to a keynesian beauty contest situation where people are incentized to vote what they think other people would vote, rather than by their own honest assessment?
- wccrawford 5y agoIt's also another kind of echo chamber, where the majority can penalize you for going against the group-think both by downvoting your posts and by providing you with fewer votes.
- mariusor 5y agoYes, but in all fairness, slashdot, unlike reddit had a niche it was pursuing: "tech news". Granted there were meme posts during its heyday too (eg, micro$oft bad) but I think opposing opinions were given way more consideration than similar discussion garner on reddit (or even here, on HN) to this day.
- wccrawford 5y agoI think that was true at one point, but later I don't think it was true. Well, at least compared to HN. I think it was always better than Reddit, but I don't expect intelligent discussion there like I do on tech news sites.
- mariusor 5y agoI was thinking of the period before the exodus to digg and reddit happened. I'm not sure about the year... before 2006-2007, I guess.
- baq 5y agomaybe, but you don't know your meta-moderation karma, so you don't get beauty feedback. IIRC the karma was primarily impacted how often you'd get votes for meta-moderation. from what i recall from slashdot times, it worked really well.
- sumtechguy 5y agoThis style of moderation works to a point. But for larger conversations it falls apart. Unless you camp for new stories to show up, your posts will typically not be seen. They will get drowned out by the early voted on posts. Voting early and seeing things early is in many ways the way that particular voting system works. Also for 'older' conversations you will tend to see a lot of +5's and a lot of -1s. But rarely anything in-between. That means it is harder to tell what rank a comment has in relation to another. So if you miss a story popping up and have a good point your 0/1 default moderation will have a tough time even being seen by some. I have seen the same topic take on radically different styles just depending on who posts early. Many topics can have this quality but it seems to happen to me more often with systems that have voting to me. In practice most of these systems are agree/disagree systems. Trying to use that as some sort of barometer/filter of what the conversation is tough. It seems like it should work but in the end it is just 'internet points'.
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoIt was solved long ere that: no votes. There are many boards were ranking is simply decided by recent activity of replies. I find that DeviantArt has the ideal forum: a tree-based structure like Reddit, and H.N., and the top comment within a branch of the tree is simply the one which had the most recent reply to a child recursively, and any new replies always end up at the top. This achieves two important goals: 1) visibility is dictated by activity and nothing more: a good comment is a comment that generates discussion 2) visibility is statistical in nature: less active trees still sometimes end up in the most visible spot, simply less often than more active trees I dislike votes and the idea of “soft bans”: a comment is either against the rules, in which case it should be removed altogether and appropriate actions should be taken against the user, or it is within the rules and should not be “soft banned” by being faded out or something similar.
- baq 5y agono filtering rules only work when you can consume the whole feed in a reasonable time. note that reddit gives you the option to sort e.g. by controversial. since you can't not have a first comment (notable meme on slashdot - FP!), you need to sort somehow; the whole point of activity feeds, walls, scoring is to show the most valuable (to someone... not necessarily you - but sometimes, you) content first.
- intended 5y agoContent will always find a grey area that your rules don’t cover.
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoAnd votes stop that issue? If the grey area be popular enough with the voters, then it will simply be upvoted. The post you replied to is downvoted. It is not in any grey area of guidelines; it is simply a post that two more people disagreed with than agreed with.
- dfxm12 5y agoYou also couldn't take place in discussions if you chose to moderate, which I think is a +1 insightful way to handle things.
- spiralx 5y agoYou could, it would just undo your moderations in that article.
- spiralx 5y agoAlso: 5. most active users excluded from getting votes at all