4 ms·
I'm no accountant, but if you go bankrupt as a result of an activity then the activity likely doesn't count as profitable. Cash flow positive, yes. Profitable,
by roenxi 5y ago
I'm no accountant, but if you go bankrupt as a result of an activity then the activity likely doesn't count as profitable. Cash flow positive, yes. Profitable, no.
Profitability and bankruptcy sit in a mild opposition to each other.
- kelnos 5y agoPG&E is usually profitable; the cause of their bankruptcy is all the damages and fines levied as punishment for their part in starting wildfires.
- roenxi 5y agoIf they are found to be the cause of the fires, then this was probably a predictable outcome. If it is a predictable outcome, the accountants would probably do something like accrue a liability for causing forest fires. They might have made a mistake about how much they accrued in the past, but going forward they wouldn't be able to call the decision profitable. It clearly wasn't. If a business goes bankrupt, at least one of its past decisions was an unprofitable one. That is a difficult fact to escape from.
- galangalalgol 5y agoi think the fine was something like 15e9 USD. It is interesting to see what happens when financial penalties for bad corporate behavior are large relative to profits.
- MereInterest 5y agoDamages and fines levied are part of the "costs" side of a balance sheet. If those costs outweigh the revenue, then the business is unprofitable. I think I can see the point you're trying to make, with a distinction between the usual running mode, and abnormal circumstances imposed from an external source. I disagree with that point, as no company exists in a vacuum. The laws and regulations of their environment may impose costs, and those are part of the cost of doing business.
- mistrial9 5y agowhat you armchair accountant aces don't know is, years ago top PG&E management found a way to take out a lot of capital and capital gains from PG&E, even though PG&E is tightly regulated. New top-level holding companies were formed. They were using this top-level capital structure to purchase other financially performing assets, like power plants in other parts of the US. This was uncovered during the ENRON blackout response. I believe that many US companies have made distinct fortunes based just on capital asset valuations, along with some strategic sales and trades here and there. PG&E is in the center of that, being a massive landowner for its infrastructure. Second fun-fact, when California State regulators requested inventory details for things like transmission facilities, the response was "trade secret" or "homeland security" or "you will sell this info" .. basically deny, delay and deprive. So even the agencies tasked to regulate PG&E did not have complete asset inventories to refer to.. If anyone has info on the current court-ordered restructuring since the criminal negligence conviction, don't be shy !
- floatingatoll 5y agoThis is what I was hand waving at (the tendency to Enron-ify) but you have way more specifics than I do. Thanks!
- hadlock 5y agoDo you have any citations to back these claims up
- mistrial9 5y agohttps://www.sfchronicle.com/travel/article/PG-E-owns-land-across-California-What-will-14028654.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/travel/article/PG-E-owns-land-ac...
- michaelt 5y ago> if you go bankrupt as a result of an activity then the activity likely doesn't count as profitable Unprofitable for the shareholders, maybe. The CEO still gets to take home $6M+ [1] which sounds plenty profitable to me. [1] https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/04/08/pge-execs-pay-raises-2020-sec-docs-gas-electricty-wildfire/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/04/08/pge-execs-pay-raises-...