4 ms·
I totally agree that it is a very tricky subject, especially regarding depression. Having some experience with it myself, I would argue that irrational pessimis
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
I totally agree that it is a very tricky subject, especially regarding depression. Having some experience with it myself, I would argue that irrational pessimism is a major feature of depression. For example, people cannot accurately asses actions and activities that would in fact make them happier if they were to follow through.
In this way, I think they are clearly distinct from those with terminal illness or chronic pain.
I agree that people should have the right to choose death, independent of the rationality of their decision. Ultimately, people are the owner of their body and steward of their life, even if they are imperfect and irrational ones. Taking autonomy away turns individuals and their body into the property of someone else.
I think there is some room for temporary holds and crisis management, but all such activities should be finite in duration.
- aeturnum 5y ago> I agree that people should have the right to choose death, independent of the rationality of their decision I don't think that that there is an ethical imperative to allow people to carry out irrational decisions. I was trying to say that, if someone with depression or another chronic mental illness decides they would rather be dead than alive, then after we determine that decision doesn't come from a passing[1] delusion, then we should give that desire the same weight we give to people with other chronic conditions. We all have the right to choose, after a time, that we do not want to live this way. I also think that having a global standard for "rational" v.s. "irrational" is difficult enough that I think drawing strong lines tends to do more harm than good. So, in practice, I suppose I support people who "irrationally" wish to end their lives, but only due to the impossibility of determining what 'rational' means for each of our subjective perspectives. [1] Whatever "passing" means - it is not an easy question.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think we agree in principle. I think that defining rational vs irrational IS difficult, and therefore choose to draw the line such that it doesn't matter for a persons right to choose. This addresses the fact that a severely depressed person may not be able to make the same objective assessments of the world that the chronically I'll can. A severely and chronically depressed person might think "I have no chance at happiness" when in reality, they actually do. If they base their decision on this premise, they would be following faulty logic. My point is that they have a fundamental right to act based on their conclusions, even if they are wrong.
- aeturnum 5y ago> My point is that they have a fundamental right to act based on their conclusions, even if they are wrong. 100% agree!
- LorenPechtel 5y agoI think the fundamental issue comes down to whether the cause of the desire is fixable. If there's a fixable problem, fix it. If there isn't I think they should be allowed to (and even provided painless means to do so--say, a mask connected to a nitrogen tank.) Whether we agree with the reason or not I don't think enters into the picture.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAnd what if the person doesn't want to fix it? Do you force them?
- haswell 5y agoThis is the first question that comes to my mind. I’m on a long depression journey and when I was at my worst, I had absolutely no desire to fix things. I just wanted to stop hurting, or do things that helped me not feel the pain. Looking back on that version of me, I wouldn’t really trust myself to make decisions about life and death. But on the flip side, I know not all circumstances are equal, and so all I can conclude is that this is incredibly complicated and I don’t have the answer.