3 ms·
You're assuming good faith where it's very clear that none exists. if you want to work towards any resolution you must always assume good faith, otherwise why
by em-bee 5y ago
You're assuming good faith where it's very clear that none exists.
if you want to work towards any resolution you must always assume good faith, otherwise why even bother talking to them.
There's no name calling in there, only factually accurate descriptions.
scumbag is name calling. whether it's justified is irrelevant. again, you must always assume good faith, otherwise there is no point in interacting at all.
> you are closing the door to any sort of constructive resolution
No. Let's be honest here: Muse did that when they blocked me initially.
before that you accused them of including spyware. that's where you closed the door to a constructive response.
yes, you were asking the community if they agree with that interpretation. but you asked it in front of the core developers. not the right place for that question. and it wasn't clear enough that that was your question.
> i don't even know what you are asking there, and what kind of answer you expect from the developers.
I've addressed this in my other comments here.
yes, saw that. clear now. i wasn't able to see that from your initial message.
But I'd also point out that the reactions from the community are overwhelmingly in agreement with my assessment.
that doesn't excuse the tone. and that is not just addressed to you but to everyone who is just yelling at the developers instead of constructively pointing out the errors of their ways.
> if we want to resolve this we, as concerned users, need to voice our concerns in such a way that the developers actually have a chance to make the necessary corrections and regain our trust.
Again, you're assuming good faith where it's very clear that none exists. I'd argue that if we want to resolve this we, as concerned users, need to support an audacity fork ASAP.
then do that and be done with it. if there is no point in talking to the original developers then why do it? especially in that tone?
the civil thing would have been to just go with one of the forks and make statements like: "i supporting this fork because i disagree with the direction of development in audacity. the fork is removing any telemetry and related features because those are not welcome" there. end of story. nothing else is needed to add.
You have clearly not looked into this situation in enough depth. Muse have had and squandered multiple opportunities to regain our trust.
i am not disputing any of the accusations made against them. i take issue with the form and the tone in which those accusations are being made.
if you want the developers and owners of audacity to listen, then walk away from their project, and make it clear that they are loosing their userbase. but don't yell at them. that's not helping. i would not listen to that. and i don't expect them to listen to that either.
- antisol 5y agoI'm tired. Take the copypasta and lack of patience with a grain of salt and humour, please? :) >if you want to work towards any resolution you must always assume good faith, otherwise why even bother talking to them. I've covered this in other comments and I'm tired of repeating myself. If you're not just asking this rhetorically, you can find the answer easily. >scumbag is name calling. No. I don't accept that in this case. I maintain that it's purely descriptive. See my comments elsewhere. >before that you accused them of including spyware I did not. The question was a hypothetical. I opined that it sounded like that to me, and asked if this was the consensus or not. Further, even if you do read it as an accusation, the use of the term "spyware" is obviously hyperbolic and not intended to be taken literally. >that's where you closed the door to a constructive response Actually, they had previously closed the door to a constructive response when they failed to respond to a horde of other questions. Questions which still remain unanswered. I could go and do your research for you to show you the history and when this happened, but I can't be bothered. The history is all there if you care to be properly informed. >but you asked it in front of the core developers ...who should have the ability to accept public scrutiny if they're going to run a public project. >not the right place for that question What, pray tell, was the right place? And what "reasonable" response do you think would have been likely from the scumbags? >and it wasn't clear enough that that was your question. I have acknowledged elsewhere that this does indeed appear to be the case. >yes, saw that. clear now. i wasn't able to see that from your initial message. Cool. Yeah, I didn't initially elaborate on my motivations. Didn't occur to me. >that doesn't excuse the tone. and that is not just addressed to you but to everyone who is just yelling at the developers instead of constructively pointing out the errors of their ways. When you constructively point out the error of their ways, you get a bunch of reactions from the community agreeing with your post, and then you are are ignored without any comment from the maintainers... ...If you're lucky: Sometimes high level muse representatives chime in to sarcastically accuse you of posting copypasta. I could go and do your research for you to show you the history and when this happened, but I can't be bothered. The history is all there if you care to be properly informed. >then do that and be done with it. I've already done it. Did it before posting my github issue. >if there is no point in talking to the original developers then why do it? especially in that tone? I've covered this in other comments and I'm tired of repeating myself. If you're not just asking this rhetorically, you can find the answer easily. >the civil thing... (bla bla bla) That would not have achieved my goal. This did. To see what my goal was, go read my other comments. Covered elsewhere, tired of repeating myself, bla bla bla ;) >i take issue with the form and the tone in which those accusations are being made. You have clearly not looked into this situation in enough depth. >if you want the developers and owners of audacity to listen, then walk away from their project, and make it clear that they are loosing their userbase. but don't yell at them. that's not helping. i would not listen to that. and i don't expect them to listen to that either. Firstly, I hate to be the grammar nazi, but it's "losing". "loosing" is a pet peeve of mine and I simply. couldn't. resist. Sorry! if you want the developers and owners of audacity to listen That wasn't my goal. I knew there was no chance of that. Covered elsewhere, tired of repeating myself, bla bla. but don't yell at them. that's not helping It did. i would not listen to that. That wasn't my goal. Covered elsewhere, tired of repeating myself, bla bla. >and i don't expect them to listen to that either. Scumbags need to be called scumbags. But that's a whole philosophical debate that I really just can't even be bothered with. If you disagree, then that's nice and I commend your altruism. But you're wrong :P ;)