3 ms·
That's not right, the only "proprietary" connector is Tesla's, every other connector is completely open. Tesla claims theirs is open, but clearly not enough for
by epistasis 5y ago
That's not right, the only "proprietary" connector is Tesla's, every other connector is completely open. Tesla claims theirs is open, but clearly not enough for others to adopt it. The non-Tesla connectors, none of which are proprietary or unique to a manufacturer:
* J1772 "Level 2", the slower 240V AC that's common for home charging (this was incorrectly labeled as "type 2, thanks for the correction jsmith45)
* CCS - fast DC charging, the form factor is Type2 plus a bit of an extra shape.
* CHaDEMo - a separate fast DC charging connector
- MrRadar 5y agoAlso, CHaDEMo is only still being used on one or two new models in the US. Everyone else (except Tesla) has adopted CCS on vehicles that support fast charging.
- Robotbeat 5y agoDon’t underestimate the “Not Invented Here” syndrome for why other carmakers don’t use the vastly better Tesla adapter. This image shows the size difference: https://teslatap.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/connector_comparison.jpg https://teslatap.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/connector_co...
- Someone1234 5y agoThose same carmakers didn't invent CCS either. So by the same logic they'd be skipping the non-proprietary CCS standard just like the proprietary Tesla one.
- Robotbeat 5y agoNo, but they’d rather pick a 3rd party standard than acknowledging the value of their main competitor’s innovation.
- Someone1234 5y agoThat wasn't the argument you made above.
- Robotbeat 5y agoBeing reactionary to a competitor’s approach is absolutely part of NIH. Also, many carmakers were actually involved in the CCS standard. If you want to use a different phrase than "NIH" to more precisely describe this reactionary refusal to use a better technology because your competitor thought it up and you don’t want to look bad by adopting it, that’s okay by me.
- jeffbee 5y agoI'm struggling to see why anyone would give even the smallest fuck about the size of the plug.
- epistasis 5y agoUp to a certain size, it doesn't really matter. But anything larger than the tesla one does get increasingly unweildly.
- Robotbeat 5y agoYeah, if you haven’t ever used the alternatives (Chademo or US CCS) and compared to Tesla, it’s hard to grok why it’d be a usability issue.
- jeffbee 5y agoChademo is ridiculous but also dead and nobody ever has to use it. Most EV owners, most of the time, are charging from the smaller AC J1772 plug at home or at a public charger. Fast DC charging for long trips is now and will remain a minor use case that pretty much nobody cares about, and having to use a slightly larger plug on 1% of your trips is not going to be something people get worked up about.
- feifan 5y agoAesthetics matter to some people. I would be a little more sad if I had to plug in a chunky CCS charger rather than the relatively-small charger Teslas have now. (To be clear, standardizing on CCS is likely a good thing and I'd support it, but, y'know … I'd be a little sadder)
- jsmith45 5y agoExcept in the US Type 2 is not really a thing (there is a local standard based on it intended for semis and buses), and everybody is using type 1. Even the version of CCS used as the de-facto DC standard in the US is based on a type 1 plug instead of a type 2. In Europe, tesla uses the Type 2 CCS plug on Type 3. Older models ones used a seldom used part of the Type 2 specification that permitted DC charging without the extra pins from CCS.
- epistasis 5y agoOops, you are correct, I meant level 2 not type 2! It's still the J1772 connector in Europe, unless I'm mistaken. I have zero first hand EV experience on that continent.
- jsmith45 5y agoEurope uses the Type 2 "mennekes" Connector, which has been standardized as the SAE J3068 for use in big trucks/busses (think the kind of vehicle where only diesel is even an option for the ICE versions). The main advantage of the Type 2 is that for AC charging it allows for three phase power at up to 480v (50 kw max). (vs 250v single phase maximum for Type 1). Other than connector shape/size, type 1 is a strict subset of the Type 2 standard, to the point where a simple passive adapter can convert a type 1 charger to a type 2 vehicle just fine. A single phase type 2 charger of the right voltage range could potentially work with a type 1 vehicle with a simple passive adapter, but this direction is more risky, since it appears that voltage and phase counts are not a negotiated parameter, and that the control signals are not limited to 5v like in the Type 1 connector.