3 ms·
UK says it wants to substantially rewrite Northern Ireland Brexit protocol
- jfengel 5y agoWho could possibly have foreseen this?
- Normille 5y agoAlmost everyone. Apart from all the hardline Unionists in Northern Ireland who enthusiastically voted for Brexit and are now crying because they were too dumb to work out that the only place the customs border between the EU and UK could be placed, without breaking the Good Friday agreement, was between the British mainland and Northern Ireland. More popcorn, please!
- jfengel 5y agoThat's the one thing I genuinely don't understand. The DUP seemed to be working directly against their own interests -- though perhaps that's not surprising given that their interests are contradictory. They were ditched after the next election, and Brexit got done in a way that ran roughshod over them. But had they not partnered with the Tories previously, the entire thing would have gone completely different. So they seem to have engineered their own destruction, to absolutely no benefit to themselves. There was never a good solution to this: the UK has a land border with the EU and you can't wish that away, no matter how much you conceive of "the UK" as an island. But the one set of people who should have figured that out from the beginning were the DUP, and they were the ones who most conspicuously wished for something impossible. I don't get it.
- NotSwift 5y agoThe basic problem here is that the UK government decided that it definitely did not want to to follow EU regulations. That implies that there are at least two different regions of the world: those that follow UK regulations and those that follow EU regulations. So the places where these regions meet are a boundary. And both of these institutions have to decide how to handle trade across this boundary. You can either put this boundary between Northern Ireland and the rest of Ireland (ignoring some of the Good Friday accords) or put it between the NI and the rest of the UK. My modest proposal would be to simply to join NI to the Irish nation.
- jfengel 5y agoThat may well be the eventual solution. It seems to make sense along a lot of different dimensions. But there is a long-standing resentment between Irish interests and English ones, where the English conquered Ireland and set themselves up as the ruling class. A fair number of people in Northern Ireland still identify with that English past, and are afraid they'll be an oppressed minority in a united Ireland. It may not be impossible to solve that, especially since the demographics have changed since the Good Friday Accords. But there is a long history of bad blood there, and both sides are mistrustful. Uniting Ireland seems like the natural solution, and I suspect that if they do it, it'll be obvious to all in retrospect of, say, 25 years. But at the moment it's scarier than Brexit, and for good reason.