4 ms·
Everyone should pitch in to have one system. It will be the worst if 10 years from now every vehicle has a different ’usb’ port while your mileage count goes l
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
Everyone should pitch in to have one system.
It will be the worst if 10 years from now every vehicle has a different ’usb’ port while your mileage count goes lower.
Tesla moved first, and that deserves some reward because anyone could have started for decades prior to Tesla.
- melling 5y agoHave we developed the final charging standard? We’ll be using whatever we agree upon for decades.
- Faaak 5y agoYes, it's called CCS is EU/USA. For asia, it's still undecided between CCS and CHAdeMO
- emteycz 5y agoEvidence that's the best for next decades? Sorry but the word of EU bureaucracy is not enough.
- gambiting 5y agoWhat kind of evidence would you find sufficient? CCS supports 350kW charging speeds(as-is, it can support more with very minor changes to the cable/plug spec), higher than any car currently on the market. What exactly are your requirements to make a charging standard "best for the next decades"?
- tyho 5y agoThe Audi e-tron GT charges at 270KW. Pretty close already. A standard petrol/gas pump pushes 22MW, or ~7MW equivalent when taking into account ICE efficiency.
- gambiting 5y agoRight, but I think aiming for petrol pump equivalency isn't very helpful when planning a charging standard right now - this theoretical 7MW charging station would be absolutely insane in order to provide that much power through a single cable(I would love to see a calculation for how thick it would need to be to make that happen), second of all how do you cool down a battery charging at 7MW, and third of all how do you get that kind of power to the charging site(especially if we're talking about multiple charging points running at once). Even right now the new FastNED or Ionity charging stations that have the latest 300kW chargers are very difficult to install due to the huge power requirements, especially with several of them running in parallel. Tesla Superchargers do actually slow down when multiple cars are charging at once. So going back to the charging standard - the "default" CCS plug supporting "only" 350kW is going to be sufficient for a long time I think. And if it's not it can be made to support more with very minor changes to the design - after all it's literally just two prongs thar carry the power.
- Symbiote 5y ago7MW is about half a high speed train at maximum power, but that's using a 25kV supply. But running the cables is presumably easier when the railway has that convenient strip of land all across the country.
- gambiting 5y agoCorrect, I noticed that at a lot of newly built charging stations along motorways here in the UK it's just CCS - no more Type 2, no more CHADeMO(sucks for Leaf owners I guess).
- Retric 5y agoCCS is kind of a mess due to backwards compatibility. Tesla’s plug design is a better standard, but it’s unlikely for companies to abandon CCS.
- gambiting 5y agoHow come? CCS is fantastic, because it's backwards compatible with Type 2 connector by default, so you don't need to have both on a car, it literally works with any Type 2 charger OR any CCS charger, using one socket. The only thing it doesn't work with is Type 1, but the last car commercially released with a type 1 socket was the Outlander PHEV, like half a decade ago, at least over here in the UK. Type 1 just doesn't exist as a standard anymore, special order only.
- Retric 5y agoSure praise be to backwards compatibility today, just realize the added costs never go away. Tesla’s connector is lower weight among other advantages and a simple adaptor allows for Type 2 or CCS charging as well. We are very early into the EV transition to be worrying about backwards compatibility.
- sharpneli 5y agoIt’s not backwards compatible as in Type2 would be obsolete. Type2 is for AC charging (up to 22kW) and that what home chargers use. So it is not going away. CCS just adds two large pins under the Type2 for DC charging. No sense to have those heavy pins when you’re charging from small 3.7kW home wallbox.
- Retric 5y agoType2 is over engineered for home charging, and even ignoring that it’s not a great long term solution. I doubt wireless charging will ever be popular for 150kW fast charging, but it would be convent for daily trickle charging and electrified roads for truly unlimited range. IMO, some in road charging system is the long term future of EV’s and using whatever that is for at home charging is probably going to eventually take off. Anyway, using slightly larger pins in a home connection is trivial vs the overall advantages. It’s the heavy gage wiring and active cooling that makes fast chargers heavy and that’s where you notice the added bulk and weight of the backwards comparable connector.
- pyaamb 5y agohttps://teslatap.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/connector_comparison.jpg https://teslatap.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/connector_co...
- kozak 5y agoIf I were Asia, I would choose Type2 CCS in a combo with ChaoJi (the new version of Chademo). It's like the European CCS, but with its main flaw being resolved (namely, allowing you to plug upper and lower parts separately and not in one unwieldy piece). Here is a picture: https://www.chademo.com/wp2016/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/combined-example2.png https://www.chademo.com/wp2016/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/co...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- macinjosh 5y agoKing of the dongles, Apple, will make their next big foray into the EV charging dongles segment.
- sneak 5y agoYes, one system would be nice. Second-best is carrying a bunch of adapters in your frunk and having charging on different standards (that you can adapt) available widely. I think the latter is more likely, given that everyone these days wants to build/own their own platform. As long as you can adapt it and pay to charge, it's a step in the right direction.
- opencl 5y agoLiterally everybody other than Tesla is using the J1772 connector with CCS for fast charging. CHAdeMO was around for a while but nobody is using it on new vehicles anymore.
- shmoe 5y ago"everybody other than Tesla" doesn't count for much just yet. It certainly will in the future. Tesla's level 2 connector lines up electrically with J1772 anyways, hence the tiny adapter.
- CivBase 5y ago> Everyone should pitch in to have one system. Are there any financial incentives for this? Even if a technical solution exists, are there incentives for EV manufacturers to support it? This is one of the big things I'm looking for before committing to buying an EV as my next vehicle. Even if Tesla "opens" their charging network, that's not the same as having a single, universal charging standard which anyone can build out themselves. A "USB for cars" would be the ideal solution.
- bildung 5y agoThis actually seems to be mostly done already. EU mandated CCS and China GB 20234. So if Tesla has to support these anyway, it doesn't really make sense to maintain a Tesla-only charging network in these markets. As I doubt the US will adopt GB 20234, my bet would be on CCS.
- fy20 5y agoIn the EU the standard connector is IEC 62196 Type 2 aka CCS. All the public chargers I've seen have either the AC (aka Type 2) version, or the AC and DC (aka CCS) version plus CHAdeMO. Even Tesla uses that for their cars and superchargers in Europe.
- post_break 5y agoI mean it's not like they had a choice in the matter. Weren't they forced by law to use that connector? If not then it would have been market share I can only assume.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoI rented a Renault Zoe for a week, last May in Dordogne (a nice French southwest department). I charged the car wherever I spent the night. At a hotel, there was 2 Tesla Destination chargers: one had a small "for Tesla" plate and the other was "for EV". The "for EV" connector was identical to the one for Tesla (Type 2 I guess). Both worked with the Zoe and I managed to make a full charge (~400km) in about 2-3 hours. I didn't pay a dime. The experience was much better than with AC public charging stations where I paid 5€ for roughly the same energy and had to use a ChargeMap card (from the Zoe owner).
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoTesla sold in China have two plugs, too https://mashable.com/article/tesla-dual-gb-charge-port-china https://mashable.com/article/tesla-dual-gb-charge-port-china