3 ms·
> leading developers of Stockfish have terminated their GPL license with ChessBase permanently. Does this wording seem extremely weird to anyone else? Accordi
by phendrenad2 5y ago
> leading developers of Stockfish have terminated their GPL license with ChessBase permanently.
Does this wording seem extremely weird to anyone else?
According to the GPL:
> You may not propagate or modify a covered work except
> as expressly provided under this License. Any attempt
> otherwise to propagate or modify it is void, and will
> AUTOMATICALLY TERMINATE your rights under this License
Capitalization added by me. Maybe it's a nitpick, but it seems to me that the "termination clause" as people are calling it, isn't something you "invoke" or a sword you use to slay people who violate the GPL. It's an automatic process which you, the copyright holder, don't really control in any way.
IANAL, obviously.
- cormacrelf 5y agoThere is little practical difference between asking a court to enforce an automatic termination clause and asking a court to enforce the exercise of an option to terminate. One will require showing the automatic termination clause is triggered, the other will require showing the right to terminate arose. In either case they’re trying to get ChessBase to cease any use of the software, and they want a court to order them to stop because the consequences of violating a court order are substantial. In a technical sense yes, the GPL avoided giving rights holders an option to terminate. There’s no such thing as automatic enforcement of these things though (well, not for GPL, music industry is a different story), so it is not a big difference. I’m pretty sure you could just send a violator a fresh copy of the code and establish a new license agreement with them, so it’s still up to the rights holder if they want to continue.