4 ms·
"sale". We dont know who the buyer is, if any real money changed hands, or even something as basic as the number of Super Mario 64 boxes "graded" by Wata Games.
by rasz 5y ago
"sale". We dont know who the buyer is, if any real money changed hands, or even something as basic as the number of Super Mario 64 boxes "graded" by Wata Games.
Just a reminder, the previous record holder Mario sold at Heritage Auctions and graded by Wata Games was purchased by Jim Halperin - owner of Heritage Auctions with a seat on Wata Games board, pure coincidence Im sure! https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/02/how-this-ultra-rare-copy-of-super-mario-bros-sold-for-100000/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/02/how-this-ultra-rare-c...
"Jim Halperin, owner of Heritage Auctions and one of three buyers"... "Halperin sits on the advisory board for Wata Games"
- diognesofsinope 5y agoThis seems plausible. My first thoughts were (1) fraud like you said or (2) money laundering.
- rasz 5y agoWhoa, who said anything about fraud? Certainly not me. Pure coincidence! The fact Wata Games doesnt publish population lists, like any other legit grading agency https://www.psacard.com/pop https://www.psacard.com/pop is simply an ordinary oversight on their part, and surely has no influence on the prices.
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoYup. This smells (no pun intended) of money laundering to me. Any auction for an obscurely collectible item is perfect for money laundering, since there’s a huge amount of plausible deniability in someone’s honest willingness to pay such an exorbitant sum. More concretely, let’s say Joe Criminal has $1.56MM in ill-gotten gains. He proceeds to sell an obscurely collectible item in his possession at auction. Via a shell company/individual, he anonymously bids it up to $1.56MM, and pockets the money minus any auctioneer fees. As long as the authorities don’t investigate the identity of this anonymous bidder, Joe Criminal has successfully laundered his $1.56MM. And as long as the authorities think that some crazy collector truly believes that an original Mario 64 cartridge is worth $1.56MM (as would also be the case for other obscure collectibles), it’s unlikely this particular transaction will raise their eyebrows. It’s not like there’s an army of appraisers out there who could fairly value this cartridge.
- crazygringo 5y ago> it’s unlikely this particular transaction will raise their eyebrows Considering it's national news, would they really not investigate it? It seems waaaaay too conspicuous and high-profile to be an attempt at money laundering. And from what I understand, auction houses are now required to file a 1099-K with the IRS so that the seller can't hide from taxes, or hide their identity. So even without the news, something tells me that filing capital gains tax on a ~3,000,000% return for a video game cartridge is going to flag a little bit of suspicion... ;)
- rasz 5y agoIts bigger than some random money laundering. "This morning on 7/14/21, PSA-grading parent company Collectors Universe just acquired Wata Games. The timing is anything but coincidental after the gigantic Heritage Auctions activities this past weekend." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ARoutGa4vQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ARoutGa4vQ
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoAlso entirely possible that it’s a pump-and-dump scheme to inflate the prices of old videogames. I think we both agree that the buyer and seller are the same entity.
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoMoney laundering is not the same as tax evasion. The seller doesn’t care about hiding from taxes; he cares about hiding the true source of his illegal income. If anything, paying taxes on laundered money makes it look more legit. The only party who needs to hide their identity here is the buyer, since unmasking them would reveal that no money actually changed hands. As far as the seller’s concerned, he wants to appear as if he earned $1.56MM of legitimate taxable income selling an old N64 cartridge to some crazy anonymous buyer.
- crazygringo 5y agoRight, but the seller (who the IRS knows about) is the one who can clearly be suspected of being part of the laundering. The IRS refers signs of money laundering to the relevant investigative agency, whether when a car wash mysteriously multiplies its earnings by 50x all in cash transactions, or when somebody suddenly gets mega-gigantic super-super-suspect capital gains. The relevant agency is going to ask the auction house who the buyer was, the auction house is going to comply, they'll trace shell companies as needed, end of story. It's not anonymous once the police/feds start investigating. Money laundering is successful when it stays hidden among seemingly normal transactions. Not when it sets splashy newsworthy records.
- CTDOCodebases 5y agoAnd surprise, surprise Wata was just sold to collectorsuniverse.com