3 ms·
I don't understand why ARM don't just release the source to their drivers. Seems like they'd have a lot to gain and little to lose bu doing so.
by nicoburns 5y ago
I don't understand why ARM don't just release the source to their drivers. Seems like they'd have a lot to gain and little to lose bu doing so.
- ironman1478 5y agoI haven't worked with their GPUs but I do work with their camera ISPs. I suspect that their reason might be that that seeing how to write software against the chip sort of gives away the secret sauce for how the chip works. I don't know if I would agree with that, but you can kind of intuit the design of chip based on its interface. How much values that provides is unclear though :/. Also, they do charge customers for that code and it costs money to support/customize it work customer use cases. I suspect that's another part of the equation.
- Nextgrid 5y agoI'd argue that anyone who has the skills & resources to make use of the "secret sauce" to compete wouldn't be stopped by having to reverse-engineer a binary driver?
- ironman1478 5y agoYou're probably right. But I'm just saying what ARM might be thinking.
- brandmeyer 5y agoAMD rationalized closed-source driver development as a defense against the release of hardware trade secrets.
- flakiness 5y agoI thought they mostly open-sourced the GPU driver for Linux? I interpret it as a way to compete against(proprietary) CUDA dominance, but maybe that is wrong? https://github.com/torvalds/linux/tree/master/drivers/gpu/drm/amd/amdgpu https://github.com/torvalds/linux/tree/master/drivers/gpu/dr...
- floatboth 5y agoYeah, and their main reason for some proprietary drivers existing is usually 3rd-party proprietary dependencies. E.g. they open sourced AMDVLK by starting with the closed Vulkan driver and replacing the proprietary compiler dependency with LLVM.
- brandmeyer 5y agoMuch of the AGESA code for booting the system remains hidden.
- bsder 5y agoPatents. Graphics and video are patent minefields. If you don't officially release the documentation, opposing companies find it much harder to sue you for patent infringement.
- tyingq 5y agoPatents they have a license to use, but not to share, or fear of infringing some unknown patent, so they don't want to say much.
- fulafel 5y agoTransparency and openness are things that in-house lawyers probably attack by default. They point all imagined risks re patents and bugs, liability, reputation, and security, and they specialize in CYA arguments.
- terminalcommand 5y agoNot all lawyers are the same :). Sure, not releasing the source code exposes you to less risks. I think the main thing that these Chinese companies fear is that a competitor can produce similar products more easily if they have access to driver source code. From a legal standpoint, I imagine you would have less liability for bugs, because you opensourced it for anyone to see and have the option to improve upon. If the company did not introduce the bugs on purpose or as a result of some really negligent behaviour, the company doesn't have to fear liability issues. Potential patent claims etc. may be filed, but you can assess that risk. Let a patent research firm do a risk assessment and tell you how much chance people would have suing you. And all firms need to have some sort of legal liability insurance. If you can work it out with your insurance provider that you are going to opensource part of your code, you do not have to fear anything. You could always release two different drivers, one basic opensource driver for the community. One closed source optimized driver for the company. If you are using some risky IP etc. keep it in the closed source driver. AMD and Nvidia do this, seems to work for them.