3 ms·
Didnt Chrome remove ftp first. Is Firefox just following suit. Need to check. Mozilla's explanation/justification here for removing ftp is quite flimsy. It
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
Didnt Chrome remove ftp first. Is Firefox just following suit. Need to check.
Mozilla's explanation/justification here for removing ftp is quite flimsy. It presumes there could never, ever be any possible situation in which a user wants to use a browser for ftp. Whether now or in the future. It just does not add up. There are no specific references to ftp-based exploits, or other examples of how ftp is harmful. Who uses ftp for transfers of unencrypted files containing sensitive data over the open internet. ftp can be useful for stuff that is not sensitive and for transfers over the local network between devices (no internet connection required).
It makes sense to remove ftp if the web is just for advertising and sales. Why would any "consumer" need ftp.
Fortunately the text-only browser I use is probably not going to remove ftp. But any decline in ftp use that results from the decisions of these advertising-dependent organisations is concerning.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoI do suspect a likely reason is because while secure FTP protocols exist, they are often not well-supported by both servers and web browsers alike. So while FTP can be secure, the implementation in practice often is not, and Firefox and Chrome are both pushing a "literally everything over HTTPS" mentality. (I have significant reservations about this concept, but in a world where they're shoving your DNS requests through HTTPS, it isn't surprising they are also want file transfers to be through HTTPS.) You can see here where the GUI didn't support FTP over SSL, and then eventually got marked WONTFIX because they decided to deprecate FTP entirely instead: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=85464 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=85464
- antisol 5y ago> Mozilla's explanation/justification here for removing ftp is quite flimsy That's just how you do big changes these days. Especially if you're Mozilla. Here's a step-by-step guide to how it works: 1. Decide that you want to drop something because it's not shiny anymore. 2. Scream "OMG WE NEED TO DO THIS FOR SECURITY!!!" 3. Watch while people commend you for taking such a brave stance for "teh security" See also: webextensions.