2 ms·
> The CA runs the challenge from their own servers and contacts the registrar directly. No, they contact it via the internet, which is controlled by the nation
by sneak 5y ago
> The CA runs the challenge from their own servers and contacts the registrar directly.
No, they contact it via the internet, which is controlled by the national authorities in the countries between the CA and the DNS server (which you are calling the registrar, but isn't always).
It's not a direct connection; there are NSPs in between.
- xg15 5y agoThis is true, but the CA does not have to disclose where on the network their servers are located or which network path the validation requests will take. Let's Encrypt sends queries from multiple servers that use different NSPs to make this kind of attack harder. (what they call "multi-perspective validation"[1]) To spoof a challange, an attacker would first have to find out where the servers are located, then compromise all relevant autonomous systems and intercept the reqests from each server. I admit though, it's still a risk. An attacker can pick an arbitrary CA for spoofing - so even if Let's Encrypt does their homework, maybe some other free CA has a less secure ACME implementation. [1] https://letsencrypt.org/2018/12/31/looking-forward-to-2019.html#new-features https://letsencrypt.org/2018/12/31/looking-forward-to-2019.h...