6 ms·
The problem with your classical analogy for entanglement is that it doesn't match the data. Or rather, it only matches the data for quantum properties that are
by tsimionescu 5y ago
The problem with your classical analogy for entanglement is that it doesn't match the data. Or rather, it only matches the data for quantum properties that are similarly blue or red.
The non-classical properties of entanglement start appearing once you start measuring combinations of the redness and blueness of those balls.
Let's say that instead of looking at the balls, you pass them through some machine that will let a red ball pass through with some probability P that you control; if the ball is blue, the machine will let it pass with probability 1-P. Let's say further that you have three such machines. You set the first machine to P=1. You pass each ball falling from this machine through a second machine, which has P = 0. You will never see a ball pass through to the end - if it were red, it would pass the first machine, but not the second; if it were blue, it would not pass the first machine at all.
But, let's say you now put a third machine between the other two, and you set P = 0.5. With classical balls, nothing changes - a blue ball doesn't make it past the first machine, while a red ball goes through the first, may or may not pass the second, and never makes it through the third regardless.
However, a quantum ball actually has a chance to pass through the 3 machines if you set it up this way. In fact, that chance is pretty large - more than half of the balls will start passing once you add the middle filter machine.
Still, this is easy to explain if we assume that the middle machine actually paints the ball instead of just detecting its color. This is where the entanglement experiment comes in: if you pass the pair of balls through the three machines, with ball 1 passing through machines P=1 and P=0.5, and ball 2 passing through P=1, you will find that sometimes both balls make it through, even though both balls can't be red at the same time, and they can't communicate about passing through the P=0.5 machine (you can repeat the experiment with the balls being taken arbitrarily far away before passing through the filters).
- tylerhou 5y agoBell's inequality (as you allude to) describes how transformations on quantum wave functions cannot behave classically. But classical wave functions can certainly be entangled as entanglement is a property of a wave function, not transformations on wave functions.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI'm not sure what you mean by classical wave functions - I've only seen the term 'wave function' used for quantum mechanics. Are you referring to classical wave equations? I'm not sure how the concept of entanglement is supposed to apply to classical waves though.
- tylerhou 5y agoI'm saying that you can represent probability distributions of classical objects as a "wave function."
- lisper 5y agoNo, you can't, at least not one that behaves like the quantum wave function does. Classical probabilities are real numbers between zero and one. The wave function takes on complex values, which allows you to add two wave-function values with non-zero magnitude and get zero, i.e. produce destructive interference. Classical probabilities can't do that.
- tsimionescu 5y agoSo basically a box with two colored balls could be described by a "classical wave functions" (a real-valued wave function), where the values of the two balls are entangled, and then yes, your experiment would exactly describe what happens. But this sheds no light on quantum wave functions and quantum entanglement.
- feoren 5y agoThis is a great thought experiment, thank you. I'm not totally clear how the machines could work without actually taking a measurement, though. It sounds like you're saying the 2nd machine (P = 0.5) takes measurements (and therefore "paints" the balls), but the other two don't? I've heard of the apocryphal "half-silvered mirror", but I don't get why reflection isn't an observation/interaction there either.
- lisper 5y ago> I don't get why reflection isn't an observation/interaction there either. I know this comment is going to get lost in the noise, but that is a really excellent point, one of the best that has been raised here so far. This is a point that is often glossed over, but it is actually really important, and quite challenging to explain without getting deep into the weeds. The answer is that passing through a half-silvered mirror is an observation/interaction, but it is special because it can be practically reversed by using additional mirrors so that you can get back to a state where you can no longer tell what the outcome of the "measurement" was. All measurements are reversible in principle, but some are irreversible in practice because the number of things you'd have to reverse is just too large. And in particular, by the time a measurement has affected the state of any macroscopic system (like a ball) it is absolutely impossible to reverse in practice, though not in principle. This process of becoming irreversible-in-practice is called "decoherence". See [1] for a more detailed explanation. [1] http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...
- thisrod 5y agoI agree with this. But it's worth pointing out that lots of good physicists don't. It's a statement of the Everett/relative state/many worlds interpretation, which is simply too weird for many people to accept. That's why there are about a dozen other interpretations of quantum measurement theory, which are all weird in other ways that I can't accept. The weird part is precisely this: "you can get back to a state where you can no longer tell what the outcome of the 'measurement' was." In other words, at lunchtime you believed that a horizontally polarised photon hit your nose at 10am in morning, and you were right. Now it's dinner time, you don't believe that, and you would be wrong if you did. If the Everett interpretation doesn't pose a massive challenge to your ideas about reality and human identity, you haven't understood it. There are physics professors who picture photons choosing which way to go at a beam splitter, then transmitting the news backwards in time, because that seems more plausible to them. Of course, interpretations are not science. Everyone agrees how an experiment would go: any attempt to reverse the interaction of the photon with your nose and brain would fail, because thermodynamics. From a purely scientific viewpoint, it simply doesn't matter how many other yous are superposed in parallel universes, because their existence or lack of it has no consequences that (any of?) you can observe. But scientists are as fascinated by this as everyone else is.