3 ms·
This seems like a misnomer. This seems more like rendering API architectures more so than GPU-architecture. Which is still important: Immediate mode vs Tile-ba
by dragontamer 5y ago
This seems like a misnomer. This seems more like rendering API architectures more so than GPU-architecture.
Which is still important: Immediate mode vs Tile-based is a big shift in overall style. And GPU-hardware is designed for particular software architectures (because the CPU will be inevitably invoking calls in a certain pattern).
But it'd probably be more accurate to call this blogpost "Rendering Architecture Types Explained" moreso than "GPU Architecture". A modern GPU running DirectX 9.0 or OpenGL 2.0 would still be immediate mode for example.
- oflordal 5y agoNo, this is about HW architectures. While they are likely evolving towards one a other there are tile based (like Imagination and ARM Mali) And immediate mode (Nvidia AMD) that both implement the same APIs (OpenGL, Vulkan etc). All these HW architectures are modern and in use.
- monocasa 5y agoInterestingly, Nvidia has been using tile based rasterizers for a bit too. https://www.techpowerup.com/231129/on-nvidias-tile-based-rendering https://www.techpowerup.com/231129/on-nvidias-tile-based-ren...
- Arelius 5y agoIt's been often quoted that Nvidia has switched to tile based for their Desktop renderers, but I haven't seen a source that confirms this. I suspect this is speculation due to changes in raster order that produce side-effects that look tiled even though they aren't.
- ribit 5y agoThis has been empirically tested on multiple occasions. There is an article on realwordtechnologies discussing this, and the results have been related for newer AMD GPUs as well. I have a little tool for macOS that tests these things out, and the Navi GPU on my MacBook is definitely a tiler (the Gen10 Intel GPU is not).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Arelius 5y agoIt's brought up in multiple other comments, so I won't bother going into detail, but the empirical testing, is flawed and is actually measuring changes in other details about thread launch behavior.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- opencl 5y agoBasically all modern GPU architectures implement tiled rasterization. NVIDIA has been doing it since Maxwell (2014) and AMD has been doing it since Vega (2017). Even Intel has been doing it for a few years now starting with their Gen 11 (2019) GPUs.
- Arelius 5y agoThose are going to require some serious citations. I'm quite sure most desktop GPUs don't run as tiled renderers at least under normal circumstances.
- monocasa 5y agoAMD has even talked publicly about how their rasterizer can run in a TBDR mode that they call DSBR. https://pcper.com/2017/01/amd-vega-gpu-architecture-preview-redesigned-memory-architecture/2/ https://pcper.com/2017/01/amd-vega-gpu-architecture-preview-...
- ryuuchin 5y ago> Specifically, Maxwell and Pascal use tile-based immediate-mode rasterizers that buffer pixel output, instead of conventional full-screen immediate-mode rasterizers. https://www.realworldtech.com/tile-based-rasterization-nvidia-gpus/ https://www.realworldtech.com/tile-based-rasterization-nvidi... He describes it as "tile-based immediate mode" in the article and the video should go into more detail about it. It's been a while since I watched it.
- cma 5y agoThe parent article already discusses that article, saying those GPUs don't use TBR in areas where the primitive count is too high or something: > Another class of hybrid architecture is one that is often referred to as tile-based immediate-mode rendering. As dissected in this article[1], this hybrid architecture is used since NVIDIA’s Maxwell GPUs. Does that mean that this architecture is like a TBR one, or that it shares all benefits of both worlds? Well, not really… What the article and the video fails to show is what happens when you increase the primitive count. Guillemot’s test application doesn’t support large primitive counts, but the effect is already visible if we crank up both the primitive and attribute count. After a certain threshold it can be noted that not all primitives are rasterized within a tile before the GPU starts rasterizing the next tile, thus we’re clearly not talking about a traditional TBR architecture. [1] https://www.realworldtech.com/tile-based-rasterization-nvidia-gpus/ https://www.realworldtech.com/tile-based-rasterization-nvidi...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lmeyerov 5y agoAgreed. For non-movies/games people -- think ML, neural networks, simulations, ETL -- this is far from how we think about them. Instead, focus is much more on thread divergence, NUMA memory models, consistency models, hw/sw schedulers, latency hiding, growing variety of DMA modes, funny ISA stacks, etc. The rendering pipeline is a tiny bit relevant for GPGPU people, e.g., if you're trying to do 1990s style shoehorning of it into antiquated webgl 1/2 rendering primitives because google/apple won't let you do the real thing.