3 ms·
> the “mindfulness industry” is full of charlatans and poor advice Thank you for saying this. There is an endless, dangerous trend of dismissing monastic trad
by throwaway_zen 5y ago
> the “mindfulness industry” is full of charlatans and poor advice
Thank you for saying this.
There is an endless, dangerous trend of dismissing monastic traditions like Zen and trying to extract meditation from its context, under the assumption that teachings and formal practice are unnecessary.
It happens in scientific research on meditation as well as on popular McMindfullness.
- babyblueblanket 5y agoIsn't this a common/popular stereotype in so many movies? Hoity-toity protagonist believes they're more educated/better than the savages who follow old tradition, then have to eat some humble pie. An age old tale we can't seem to learn.
- shadowfox 5y agoThere are equal number of these where after a short training montage the protagonist is not only an expert in said tradition, but in many cases better than the long term practitioners. So maybe people are focusing on the second lesson rather than the first.
- blunte 5y agoEvery industry is full of charlatans and poor advice. Unfortunately, some cost you more than just lost money or lost time. In this case, however, the participants may more likely be vulnerable. They are seeking some solution to their problems, and mindfulness is promoted as one. As the author makes the case, it really was a solution to his problems. But it seems he took it too far.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]