8 ms·
Adobe Joins Blender Development Fund
- xor99 5y agoNice, I think Adobe has a lot to learn from software like this. I would like to see similar funding and support for for FreeCAD and OpenSCAD
- meetups323 5y agoJust tried OpenSCAD for the first time a bit ago, really cool technology. But the inbuilt editor is a bit of a pain, and the language design is a bit odd... it feels as if they took a lisp and tried to hammer it into C-style syntax without following any C-style semantics. I'd absolutely love to see the renderer brought into something like a VS Code webview and maybe even adopting a real Lisp for the code.
- xor99 5y agoI found it confusing for a similar reason especially when you get into more complicated designs with multiple parts. I think development could be massively sped up with a little funding. I tried libfive (https://libfive.com/studio/ https://libfive.com/studio/) too which is roughly similar to OpenSCAD but faster to sketch with imo. There was a good discussion here on this topic too if you were interested: https://forum.openhardware.science/t/open-source-cad-and-open-science/2991 https://forum.openhardware.science/t/open-source-cad-and-ope...
- barcoder 5y agoThis is really good news. I love how well Blender and Substance play together. I'm sure we'll see tighter integrations. I am relieved that Adobe is supporting Blender rather than making a move for their own 3D engine. Maybe that'll come down the line though.
- gimmeThaBeet 5y agoActually, looking it up, it just like adobe just released some procedural modelling for Substance a la Houdini, Grasshopper, Sverchok et al. That's really exciting to me, I really love procedural anything. And they do have Stager for setting up scenes, and Modeler (formerly Oculus Medium) for sculpting. I haven't used substance in a while, nor the adobe stuff, just a hobby I haven't had a lot of spare time for :). However, even with Adobe, I'm really tempted to give them the benefit of the doubt in this case no matter what their own product plans are. With how companies/studios' 3D pipelines are, you can't lock your customers into all your tools. I'm assuming what Adobe would like is "blender users will have a Substance subscription, and have access to our assets marketplace" I guess the good part is really getting to be a solid part of the list of "suites your tool should support".
- varbhat 5y agoGood for Blender to get Supported from Adobe for it's development. I believe that Blender will become more awesome from this sponsorship. > ensure the longevity and success of this dynamic open-source community Nice. But, Can you(Adobe) please also make Photoshop and other Adobe products available on Linux as well ? It would really benefit Open Source community.
- mattl 5y ago> Can you(Adobe) please also make Photoshop and other Adobe products available on Linux as well ? It would really benefit Open Source community. How would it benefit the open source community? They would be proprietary binaries, likely only on one architecture.
- marderfarker2 5y agoMore people switch to Linux, gaining developer attention, in turn more developers support their software for Linux.
- mattl 5y agoProprietary software or free/open source software? I don't see how more proprietary software is something the open source community wants.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoAssume for a moment that people are going to want to run the proprietary applications either way. Would you rather that they run proprietary applications on a proprietary operating system, or that they run proprietary applications on an open source operating system?
- pdpi 5y agoWe're in a world where most people predominantly use proprietary software on proprietary operating systems. Many people are tied to those platforms because key parts of their workflows keep them from migrating - in this case, people who use Adobe's tools as their daily drivers would have a hard time moving to Linux. If Adobe made their software available on Linux, that would allow many people to migrate, which would in turn help expose those people to lots of other F/OSS software, which would then build up their userbase over time. None of this would happen instantaneously, of course, but there's a precedent for this sort of "small" change causing large shifts. For example, OS X having a unix foundation was the trigger for the gradual (but eventually large-scale) move of software developers towards macs.
- echelon 5y agoBlender has too much steam now. Proprietary modeling software is going to have a hard time competing with free. Adobe realizes this, and they're going to tool their products such as Substance to be as Blender-compatible as they can. It'll be interesting if Blender starts encroaching on Adobe's moat. Not sure what Adobe will be able to do if/when that happens. I'm curious if this can happen with the game engine world too, but Godot is too far removed from Unity and Unreal to even be comparable. It's a shame CRYENGINE isn't open source, though it's a bit dated at this point. Maybe Lumberyard?
- 9erdelta 5y agoLumberyard did get open sourced under a different name, O3DE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EM6ZIbBJGQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EM6ZIbBJGQ
- mikeyouse 5y agoYep - Lumberyard was just partially rewritten / open sourced under the "Open 3D Engine Foundation" with the LF -- just announced like a week ago or something: https://o3de.org/ https://o3de.org/
- wokwokwok 5y agoI mean… funding is good, but heck, Adobe is one of those companies that doesn’t have a great track record of being nice, fair or kind. See for example, their “year subscription billed monthly” lockin. What’s in this for them? …because I flat out don’t believe for an instant they’re doing it out of the goodness of their hearts.
- kristaps 5y agoMaybe the same reason why Google keeps Firefox alive - to be able to show there is no monopoly in some category of software.
- Hamuko 5y agoDoes Adobe have any products that compete with Blender directly?
- ink404 5y agoDimension could be seen as competition
- kakwa_ 5y agoI'm not sure how much of it overlaps with Blender and how much of it is complementary to Blender. But Adobe recently acquired Allegorithmic and their 3D texture tool Substance. https://www.substance3d.com/ https://www.substance3d.com/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/23/adobe-acquires-allegorithmic-makers-of-the-substance-texture-tools https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/23/adobe-acquires-allegorithm...
- dartharva 5y agoIs it really in Google's control whether or not Firefox lives? The only connection Firefox has seems to be that Google is one of its sponsors in exchange of being its primary search engine. I don't think they'd go that far as to intentionally denying Firefox users access to their sites even if they wanted, because that'd immediately draw some lawsuits.
- eltondegeneres 5y agoIt's great to see free software projects get stable funding, but I'm surprised to see the amount they're contributing is so low at €30,000/year. Just €2,500/month is probably a great ROI on PR for Adobe. https://fund.blender.org/corporate-memberships/ https://fund.blender.org/corporate-memberships/
- mkl95 5y agoThat's peanuts for Adobe, not a good look.
- rubyn00bie 5y agoI think you probably nailed it. I’d guess the €30,000 probably generates the maximum ROI on this PR spend.
- Roonerelli 5y agoBy coincidence Snowden was tweeting about them just the other day https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/1416774441539936259 https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/1416774441539936259 https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/1416778909358731266 https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/1416778909358731266
- Danieru 5y agoWhy would Adobe do this? My guess: Autodesk. Maya and Max are Autodesk's cash cows. Blender is attack said cash cows and thus weakening Autodesk who Adobe might be seeing as a competitor in other realms. Weak reasoning I know. At such a low dollar sponsorship it could just be Adobe uses Blender for their commercials or something else trivial.
- gmueckl 5y agoWhat gives you the idea that these tools are cash cows? It's quite then opposite, really. In FY20, Mesia and Entertainment was 5% of Autodesk's revenue as per their own report. I think this is Adobe hedging their bets against Autodesk as they don't have a full 3D DCC software suite. There are 3d modelling and rendering features in some products, but they are just in a supporting role.
- willismichael 5y agoIt would be really interesting to see a future in which giant companies fund open source work as a way to weaken their competitors.
- ebspelman 5y agoMaya and Max contribute less than 8% of Autodesk's total revenue[1]. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/416285/revenue-of-autodesk-by-segment/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/416285/revenue-of-autode...
- stackedinserter 5y agoDon't click this link, it's a "create account" trap/paywall.
- qwertox 5y agoAdobe's "Press Release" [1]: > Better with Blender, together: Adobe partners with Blender on development fund and new plugins > [...] > First, I am thrilled to announce that we’re joining the Blender Development Fund to help ensure the longevity and success of this dynamic open-source community. Additionally, we are going to help creators work with the best of Adobe right in Blender by launching two new plugins — Substance 3D [2] in Blender and Mixamo Auto-Control Rig Plugin [3] for Blender (both now available, in beta). -- All in all, these plugins sound like marketplaces for Shaders and Animation Curves, respectively -- [1] https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2021/07/20/blender-development-fund-partnership.html https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2021/07/20/blender-develop... [2] https://www.substance3d.com/ https://www.substance3d.com/ [3] https://www.mixamo.com/ https://www.mixamo.com/
- jbverschoor 5y agoEmbrace extend.. no thank you
- echelon 5y agoNot at all. This is "Commoditize your Complement". Adobe is doing this to weaken one of its greatest competitors, Autodesk. Additionally, Adobe's software works well with Blender as part of a comprehensive design suite. They'll likely increase the number of subscribers in the short term by doing this. The danger to Adobe would be if Gimp and Inkscape got anywhere near as high quality as Blender. As pointed out by a few comments on one of my threads [1], Amazon is doing the same thing to Unity and Epic Games' Unreal Engine with their open sourced Lumberyard engine, O3DE. Amazon is going to make money from Prime Games and Twitch. If their move succeeds, an engine is just a commodity. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27895345 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27895345
- high_byte 5y agoI hope it ends with their money because most Adobe products suck, at least in terms of code
- qwertox 5y agoMaya has the most impressive C++ SDK I've ever seen. It tells you so much about how Maya is coded. With the SDK you get just as much power as the developers of Maya get, the same tools. Also, the UI is insanely well scriptable.
- high_byte 5y agoidk about maya I was thinking about flash when I wrote this. but same with blender. python api a bit clunky but ui is really amazing. really made me appreciate artist-coders as they have a really unique ui
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoAdobe is investing seriously in 3D now (with buying Allegorithmic), which as someone who is forced to use their software because of my industry I'd be ok with but they've instead decided that now your "Creative Cloud" subscription only applies to 2D creativity because all the 3D software they've just acquired is now an seperate subscription on top of that. Not to mention their software all still basically ships as yearly versions, we now just have to pay for every years updates when before you could say buy one year, skip two, buy the next.
- gotodengo 5y agoI have to admit, I'm a bit concerned about Blender's future development. I've been a Blender user for 15 years, I jumped on somewhere before the 2.4 redesign. There have been some really awesome advances in Blender over the past two years. Things that really changed my typical workflow in an absolutely good way, Eevee and all of the node work for a couple amazing new additions. They've also changed a lot of things, namely keybindings, UI, certain modifiers, that had been done in a certain way, and that I'd committed to muscle memory, for over a decade. Those changes also had the effect of breaking years worth of accumulated tutorials and bookmarks as the workflows they mentioned are not longer relevant. It's intensely aggravating to spend 10 minutes figuring out how to do something that you used to know how to do with the flick of a wrist. Especially when you fall back to searching how to perform the action and only find 4 year old stackoverflow posts which state the old way to do it. I've even recently taken a weekend reimplementing the old full color icons, which required a full custom compilation, due to the lack of contrast in the new uneditable monochrome replacements. I fully admit this may just be my initial steps into the grumbly guy who doesn't like change in my software. But I can't help but compare Blender to Firefox. Awesome tech and a great mission, sometimes aggravating UI and workflow changes, important relationships with would be rivals. As someone who is also still on Firefox, my opinion is that loads of cash didn't necessarily turn out great for them either. For me at least I consider my custom hacked up, modified keybindings as best they can be, Blender to be nearly feature complete for the work I do. It's awesome that it being opensource has allowed me to nudge it in the direction that works for me. Like I said though, as a long time user I am a bit concerned.
- Tomte 5y agoI've started with Blender after the UI changes and wouldn't have otherwise (I know, because I've tried several times). The next x users are many more than the current y users. Annoying the y for no reason would be stupid. But not making improvements for the x because the y were there first is a recipe for declining relevance.
- dman 5y agoIsnt this a recipe for always taking your current users for granted? [Not saying it applies in Blender's case, but more generally]
- jbverschoor 5y agotitle change: "Adobe Joins Blender Development Fund for €2500/month (blender.org)"
- thordenmark 5y agoAdobe could learn a lot from Blender about making 3d user friendly. The 3d tools in Adobe products are -terrible-.
- caniszczyk 5y agoAdobe recently joined the Open 3D Engine (O3DE) project too: https://www.linuxfoundation.org/press-release/linux-foundation-to-form-new-open-3d-foundation/ https://www.linuxfoundation.org/press-release/linux-foundati... https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/gametech/open-3d-engine/ https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/gametech/open-3d-engine/ So they are doing a lot more funding of open source work!
- humaniania 5y agoDo these types of contributions give them access to data/roadmaps/internal comms that they might not otherwise have had?
- nanna 5y agoThey're also supporting the development of automatic pdf tagging in LaTeX too. Mentioned here but probably more succinctly elsewhere https://www.latex-project.org/publications/2020-tagged-pdf-feasibility.pdf https://www.latex-project.org/publications/2020-tagged-pdf-f...
- imvetri 5y agoAdobe has its style. Step in, rebrand.
- fomine3 5y agoI can't wait Autodesk joins Gimp Development fund