5 ms·
The viable HSR network for the US looks roughly like this: * Existing NEC (DC to Boston via Baltimore, Philly, NYC, Hartford/Springfield/Worcester or Providenc
by jcranmer 5y ago
The viable HSR network for the US looks roughly like this:
* Existing NEC (DC to Boston via Baltimore, Philly, NYC, Hartford/Springfield/Worcester or Providence)
* NYC to Montreal and Boston to Toronto, with an interchange at Albany
* Midwest star shape, centered at Chicago, with prongs to Minneapolis, St. Louis, Detroit, Cleveland, Louisville or Cincinnati. The southern Midwest region is kind of hard for me to crayon a network.
* (Not part of the US strictly speaking) Detroit to Quebec via Windsor, Toronto, Ottawa, Montreal. Basically all of Canada's population on one rail line, with easy access to the US via interchanges at three separate points.
* Hooking up the Midwest to the NEC, although I'm somewhat dubious of the viability here.
* Texas Triangle (Houston, Dallas, Austin, San Antonio)
* California: SF, San Jose, Sacramento, LA, San Diego, Las Vegas, Phoenix.
* Maybe viable: Portland-Seattle-Vancouver
* Maybe viable: SEHSR, from Miami to Atlanta, and thence to Midwest (via Nashville) or NEC (via North Carolina's Research Triangle and Richmond).
(Citation: this is largely based on Alon Levy's crayoning, found here: https://pedestrianobservations.com/2021/03/22/high-speed-rail-followup/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2021/03/22/high-speed-rai...)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Existing NEC (DC to Boston via Baltimore, Philly, NYC, Hartford/Springfield/Worcester or Providence) This is the problem. The real route is Boston - New York - D.C. The others are lower population, lower GDP and not in line with the other three. But if you build the core route and exclude Philadelphia, you'll have an uproar in the Senate.
- jcranmer 5y agoI was on the train a week ago. Of the three of us sitting at the table who got on at Boston, one was going to Philadelphia, one was going to Wilmington, and one was going to Baltimore. One of the chief advantages of trains is that you do not have to cater only to point-to-point routes; you can instead serve a combinatorial explosion in routes for comparatively little time: a stop adds only ~5 minutes to a HSR train, and that's the worst-case scenario. There is no advantage to bypassing Philadelphia: the amount of money it costs to bypass the city is going to be quite large, and you will miss out on all the potential revenue from stopping at the city itself. From my practical experience riding the train, the biggest factor in existing slow trains in Connecticut isn't all the stops it makes in Connecticut, but the incompetence of Metro North's dispatching that keeps a high-speed train plodding along below highway speeds between stations. (Also, side note: Philly's MSA is larger than Boston's, and Philly provides more Amtrak riders than Boston's 4 stations combined--and one of those isn't even on the NEC!).
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> no advantage to bypassing Philadelphia Trains spend a lot of time speeding up and slowing down. A single stop adds much more than five minutes to total transit time. [EDIT: Apparently this doesn't apply to maglev. This could be a game changer for HSR in the American political landscape.]
- sudosysgen 5y agoMaglev trains can start and stop much, much faster than regular trains.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Maglev trains can start and stop much, much faster than regular trains Ah, wasn't aware of that. Thank you.
- jcranmer 5y agoConventional trains' acceleration profiles are already limited by passenger comfort rather than engineering difficulties. Being able to start and stop much faster isn't helpful if it's already outside maximum operating guidelines.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI was under the impression this wasn't the case. Passenger planes accelerate at around 3.5m/s/s. That's 100km/h every six seconds.
- jcranmer 5y agoAnd when planes take off, all the passengers and crew are seated in seats with fastened belts, all luggage is stowed, and tray tables are closed. By contrast, when a train departs a station, there are frequently passengers who are still roaming the aisle with their luggage. And I might have a cup of coffee or something sitting on the table in front of me (or behind me, from the perspective of the train's direction of acceleration).
- jbay808 5y agoOne thing to consider is that these routes, if they get proper use, do tend to bring the population density and GDP along with them.