3 ms·
Lapsed Buddhist here. > The Arahat Daniel M. Ingram According to the instruction I received, there have been no arahants since a few decades after the death o
by denton-scratch 5y ago
Lapsed Buddhist here.
> The Arahat Daniel M. Ingram
According to the instruction I received, there have been no arahants since a few decades after the death of the Buddha. Choose your teacher carefully. Many meditation teachers are charlatans; watch out especially for those who claim to be enlightened.
> The type of meditation I had been practicing was jhana
...or "dhyana", if you go with the Sanskrit version.
The OP spends a lot of his words talking about "mindfulness" and the industry associated with it. But if he was practising the dhyanas, he was NOT practising mindfulness as such. Practising the dhyanas is serious, headbanging stuff, involving deep, single-pointed concentration. The dhyanas build on mindfulness, which is really a basis for all practice; but single-pointed concentration is almost the opposite of normal mindfulness practice.
The OP is correct that the "mindfulness industry" blames the faults of meditators for bad experiences. I've known people who survived bad experiences with meditation, but who were finally broken by being gaslighted by their teacher.
The "mindfulness industry" minimises the risks of meditation practice. The industry generally claims to be secular, or at least, to not depend on a religious interpretation. If you folllow an openly-religious meditation teacher, you shouldn't hear that reassuring touchy-feely nonsense; instead you will be told that the path you have embarked on is dangerous, and that if you aren't prepared to stick it out to the end, then it would be better not to begin.
And if you arrive at meditation as a result of psychiatric problems, step away quickly. You need to be mentally fit to undertake meditation practise.
- mandmandam 5y ago> According to the instruction I received, there have been no arahants since a few decades after the death of the Buddha. I don't believe that is the standard view. I haven't heard it before at least. And it seems odd to me that anyone would claim this, seeing as no one knows every person who's lived in the last 3500 years. >The industry generally claims to be secular, or at least, to not depend on a religious interpretation. If you folllow an openly-religious meditation teacher, you shouldn't hear that reassuring touchy-feely nonsense I think you are labouring under some dogma, all due respect.
- mping 5y agoIn Mahayana tradition, there are many many Arhats (not only in the Mahayana but in the Hinayana too), and some Bodhisattvas, even today. Of course, they don't announce it but they were certified by Patriarchs.
- drew_drew 5y agoI acknowledge that there is controversy over Ingram calling himself an Arahat. I think it's a disagreement about the definition. Ingram has been very clear about what he thinks the requirements for being an Arahat are and why he thinks he satisfies those requirements. One could argue that his definition does not meet the requirements of the title. Regardless of what you think of his definition of an Arahat is, Ingram's book is the best written reference I know for describing the "Deep End" of meditation, and the "Progress of Insight" as it can manifest in practical terms. The article talks about Willoughby britten and Daniel Ingram as references. Here's a video of them being interviewed together. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTLr0gqQTuU&t=2453s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTLr0gqQTuU&t=2453s Shinzen Young is a good person to talk to about the "Deep End" of meditation. He doesn't write a lot but here's a video of him talking about the distinction between "Dark Night"/"Dukka Nanas" and mental health issues. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQ5B70ac_9M&t=56s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQ5B70ac_9M&t=56s I'm horrified that there are "certified" meditation instructors that don't know this stuff.