8 ms·
Publicly Available Standards
- CiPHPerCoder 5y agoSuggested title: Publicly Available Standards by ISO ISO is somewhat unique in requiring you to pay money to even know what the standard says before you can ever think about being in compliance. Most other standards organizations (i.e. NIST, IETF, W3C) do not have this weird financial burden, so merely "Publicly Available Standards" doesn't sell the significance of this. Making their standards publicly available is a good move by ISO. I hope we see more of this.
- hlandau 5y agoThis offering isn't, as far as I know, anything new. AFAIK ISO is funded by their paywall and as an international treaty organisation is probably far harder to reform than industry organisations, so I don't have much hope for this to change. ISO's attitude to this was recently expressed on Twitter: https://nitter.snopyta.org/MetaCatie/status/1368910356664483845#m https://nitter.snopyta.org/MetaCatie/status/1368910356664483... ISO even takes freely available standards from other organizations and paywalls them, even reneging on previous agreements to make a standard freely available, for example: https://www.theregister.com/2021/06/18/schematron_standard_paywall/ https://www.theregister.com/2021/06/18/schematron_standard_p...
- tephra 5y agoI'm not sure about the numbers but I would have thought that ISOs main funding comes from all the member nations who pay a bunch a money proportional to the countries GDP?
- Santosh83 5y agoSo they're funded by dozens of nations yet charge a fee to access their so-called Public Standards? Operational costs cannot be covered by the member countries? After all, public standards benefit everyone, and is the raison d'etre for the ISO to be constituted in the first place. A corporate paywall makes sense, not from an org acting for the public.
- JyrkiAlakuijala 5y agoNational standardization organisations participating in ISO usually make their budgets publicly available. Last time I looked I got an impression that the standards sales are contributing to their budgets (perhaps 1/3 or 1/4 of income). From the annual reports it was a bit unclear why the usual national standardization organization need to have wealth in $50M (instead of between 100'000 and a million) for being able to continue distributing standards.
- mqus 5y ago> Making their standards publicly available is a good move by ISO. I hope we see more of this. Afaik there were always publicly available standards in the ISO portfolio. Is this list new?
- mvanga 5y agoI wonder if there exists a Sci-Hub equivalent for ISO standard PDFs somewhere.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoMy pet fish found ISO standards PDFs on Sci-Hub a few times.
- have_faith 5y agoClever girl
- auxym 5y agoSome can be found on libgen.
- Gracana 5y agoI'm envious of people who can work with freely available standards. In my industry (machine design, industrial automation), almost all of the standards cost money. UL, CSA, NSF, ANSI, ASME, BSi, IEC, ISO, DIN, etc. Our library contains many thousands of dollars worth of documents, and it costs many more to keep them up to date. If your company has a slow or complicated purchasing process, it's a real hinderance when you realize you need a standard and have to stop working so you can deal with acquiring it. I think the only ones that are freely available are NFPA 70 (national electric code), NFPA 79 (electrical standard for industrial machinery), but if you want to download or print them, you still have to pay.
- bierjunge 5y agoI feel your pain. Most projects I work on are medical software, often connected to hardware. Getting this stuff certified is impossible without paying thousands of euros for the standards and then you pay even more for a few people who judge if you did it like the standard says. But maybe the next project will be outside of the medical field.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoMy library (in the same industry) contains a few hundred dollars worth of documents, because that's all I could get purchasing to pay for. We're just a small integrator, many to most in our field simply don't know what's in the documents because they don't buy any of them. You can go a long way with cargo-cult designs, and a ton of companies get by with approximations, but there are a ton of mistakes made because ANSI/ISO/DIN/IEC refuse to make the documents available for free.
- helloworld11 5y agoSorry to intrude with an ignorant question, but I know next to nothing about this and it sparked my curiosity. These thousands of dollars in documents are the text descriptions/instructions of various ISO standards? Do they really cost that much or am I misinterpreting? Wouldn't their content have been pirated by now if they were so expensive? (assuming i'm correctly imagining what you said)
- OJFord 5y agoActually, HN guidelines are to do the reverse: > If the title includes the name of the site, please take it out, because the site name will be displayed after the link. e.g. if this had been 'ISO announces publicly available standards' on iso.org itself, the submitter should (or if not and a popular/noticed submission, a mod would) change it to the 'Publicly available standards' that it is.
- AlbertCory 5y agoThere's been an extensive debate on an external mailing list about standards, and why TCP won over OSI. The free and open nature of IETF had a hell of a lot to do with it. Among all the other advantages noted here, it leads to a much shorter development cycle and a greater number of people participating -- people whose energy is invaluable.
- swiftcoder 5y agoNot me thinking "all standards should be freely available". Guess I'm a just filthy communist...
- jraph 5y agoOr just sensible.
- pornel 5y agoIn contrast, for all other standards ISO works similarly to Elsevier. People who write the ISO standards are required to transfer copyright to ISO, and lose control over their work. ISO says the paywall is to pay for development, but the authors don't get a cut of the sales. https://twitter.com/isostandards/status/1367138676162105344 https://twitter.com/isostandards/status/1367138676162105344 I don't know how these things usually get done, but the JPEG XL standard has been written for free by volunteers, and ISO paywalled it. The authors would like to change that: https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1415696597585993732 https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1415696597585993732
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoThe usual workaround is to publish the final preprint publicly, and give Elsevier/etc an identical paper just with the “[Preprint]” watermark or letterhead removed.
- Tomte 5y agoThe Ada Rapporteur Group managed to have the standard be free. ISO/ANSI still sell it, but it's identical and the free Language Reference Manual is accepted as canonical: http://www.ada-auth.org/standards/ada12.html http://www.ada-auth.org/standards/ada12.html I think the trick was to do make sure the US Government holds copyrights, and then there is some rule that government documents need to be free. Maybe someone can comment on the specifics, it's been years since I've heard that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- necovek 5y agoIndeed, and I encourage people to look for "preprints" and "drafts" for standards they are interested in. Sometimes you need to look for the WG pages/forums that developed it, and they are usually public, especially for the IT-related standards. I've learned C intricacies by printing and going through an "ISO C9X" draft of the standard while in high school.
- teddyh 5y agoCool, ISO 10646 was there, but sadly ISO 9995-7 is not.
- Dah00n 5y agoIf I can't read a standard to follow it without paying a lot to see it then it isn't a standard in my world. ISO is more than useless. It is actively doing harm.
- HelloNurse 5y agoThese standards were made freely available because unusually enlightened committees, common sense, public interests and/or private interests occasionally prevailed over ISO traditions.
- rjsw 5y agoThere are also some machine interpretable bits of ISO standards available [1]. [1] https://standards.iso.org/ https://standards.iso.org/
- oezi 5y agoI wish there were more open access standard organizations. At least members could force ISO to publish standards once a predefined amount of development costs (let's say 100k per standard is recouped).
- traceroute66 5y agoJust as an FYI. If you want to obtain ISO standards legally but for a price significantly lower than ISO, the answer is simple. Buy them from EVS, the Estonian Centre for Standardisation and Accreditation[1]. They have a nice English website, and you don't have to have any ties whatsoever to Eestonia, or Europe. The customer service people speak perfect English too if you have any questions. [1] https://www.evs.ee/en/ https://www.evs.ee/en/
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoWow, that’s big information. Thank you for sharing.
- traceroute66 5y agoIts been a little while since I shopped there, IIRC their search engine is generally good, but if you see high prices come up, just make sure you're looking at the price for the EN version and not the ISO version. EN just means the regionally adopted version of the standard. For all intensive purposes EN and ISO are typically identical[1][2]. EN is ISO with additional Z Annexes as applicable. [1]https://northridgequality.com/difference-en-iso-14971-part1/ https://northridgequality.com/difference-en-iso-14971-part1/ [2]https://www.wearwell.co.uk/whats-the-difference-between-an-iso-en-iso-and-bs-en-iso-standard/ https://www.wearwell.co.uk/whats-the-difference-between-an-i...
- lstamour 5y agoAlso if the standard you’re looking for only has a high price in their catalog, it’s possible it’s freely available online. Not every standard is published as a regional version, generally only those that would cost more to obtain or are popular enough to require translation.
- Tomte 5y agoBut be careful with the prefixes. DIN EN 13850 was "Postal service - Quality of service - Measurement of the transit time of end-to-end services for single piece priority mail and first class mail", but it has been rescinded. DIN EN ISO 13850 is "Safety of machinery - Emergency stop function - Principles for design"
- joelkevinjones 5y agoSome languages, like Ada, Java, and C# have some parts of their standards available. Notably missing are any for C++ (14882) or C (9899).