4 ms·
I see this claim a lot - "you can't save on rent because your landlord has to cover their costs". But this is only true if your landlord purchased at the time
by refurb 5y ago
I see this claim a lot - "you can't save on rent because your landlord has to cover their costs".
But this is only true if your landlord purchased at the time you rented. I rented a $1.8M apartment for $3,000 per month (~1/3 of total ownership costs). That's because my landlord bought 20 years before when the apartment was worth $200k. His monthly costs were maybe $1,000.
- mrep 5y agoI am extremely doubtful of the claim that an apartment that only nets 36,000 in rent per year is somehow worth 1,800,000. That's a 2% return before any associated costs. I literally just looked at another rental property that was netting 8k a month across all tenants and was listed at 1,150,000. There is no way that other owner could actually sell that place for 1,800,000.
- refurb 5y agoNot sure what to tell you. The place two doors down that was smaller went for $1.5M. Of course the landlord couldn’t sell it for $1.8M with me in it (because of SF rent control). But when I moved out and it was empty? They absolutely could.
- forgingahead 5y agoThere are plenty of places that rent far below what they cost the landlord in mortgage/taxes/HOA/repairs/etc. Home ownership, especially buying a home as an "investment" is such an emotional thing that plenty of people buy property just to buy property, the math doesn't come into it. Most of the time, even with the appreciation of the property that they sell, the landlord would have been better off putting their money into other more liquid investments with higher returns. But, many people just buy property because they don't know any better.
- snowwrestler 5y agoYour landlord doesn’t save on HOA fees, repairs, taxes, or insurance because they bought 20 years ago. Those are all costs that are charged in present dollars. Repair services want to get paid in 2021 dollars. Property taxes are based on assessments of current value. Insurance premiums are set to cover present replacement costs. The only thing your landlord saves on by buying 20 years ago is the nominal cost of the property itself, either as a low fixed mortgage payment, or as a paid-off property. This is just the effect of time and a fixed mortgage rate. If you were able to buy now, in 20 years you could be in the same position with respect to your property costs.
- refurb 5y agoOwner owns the building, he’s the HOA. Property taxes are capped in terms of growth. Likely paying 10% of what I’d pay if I bought. And biggest of all, he locked in his mortgage payment while rents went up 4x. And rents were still lower than cost of owning as housing prices priced in appreciation.