2 ms·
Abiogenic petroleum is a fringe crackpot theory, not seriously considered by geologists. There are two possibilities, here. 1. You are an experienced geologis
by vkou 5y ago
Abiogenic petroleum is a fringe crackpot theory, not seriously considered by geologists.
There are two possibilities, here.
1. You are an experienced geologist, and know far more on the subject of geology than I, or anyone else posting in this subthread. In that case, surely you would be able to preface your claims with a big fat disclaimer that most experts disagree with you, and that there are incredibly serious hurdles that your claims need to overcome.
2. You are, like me, a layman with little actual knowledge in the subject. In this case, you need to defer to expert consensus.
Given your other response in this subthread, I think we'll have to go with the latter.
Human knowledge doesn't advance because someone who is very smart, but understands nothing about a subject tells people that wet streets cause rain, and that they need to wake up and do their own research. Human knowledge advances when someone who deeply understands a subject posits a claim that can withstand cross-examination by people who know what they are talking about.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenic_petroleum_origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenic_petroleum_origin
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoI don't disagree with your point. However, i disagree with your tone, particularly using "fringe crackpot theory". He's not advocating that green men put oil underground. He's promoting a theory that most (majority? some?) of oil has non biotic origins. Wikipedia itself says there are deposits worldwide that are abiotic, and also refers to this abiotic origin thesis as unlikely. He isn't arguing "wet streets cause rain". We are far from "fringe crackpot theory". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenic_petroleum_origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenic_petroleum_origin When the dispute is around the question of quantity "how much" vs whether it is physically possible at all, and the question currently is settled in terms of probability (95%~) vs replicable experiment proof (99.99% reliable), we should refrain from using wording that ridicules the other side.