4 ms·
> At least with privately funded research, the people providing the money aren't going to fund bullshit fake research They absolutely are if it helps them prom
by pjc50 5y ago
> At least with privately funded research, the people providing the money aren't going to fund bullshit fake research
They absolutely are if it helps them promote something. Cigarettes and asbestos industries helped produce plenty of fake safety studies.
The problem is that research has been marketized; you have to "sell" your proposal to get funding, so naturally you big it up as much as possible. And thus the incentive to fake results.
- WalterBright 5y agoIf you are personally funding Professor X to do some research say, on making a better LCD display, and Professor X comes up with nothing but personal aggrandizement passed off as "research", are you personally likely to fund him some more? I seriously doubt it. Any more than you'd continue taking your car to an auto shop that took your money but didn't fix it.
- StanislavPetrov 5y agoYou aren't paying Professor X to fix your product, you are paying Professor X to endorse your product.
- WalterBright 5y agoPersonal aggrandizement is not the same as endorsing your product.
- ta988 5y agoIt doesnt work like that. You have a proposal that you send. A group of people (never the same ususally) come and review your work with half of the people that have not heard from you. They look at your story, and your metrics (papers, patents...) and put a bunch of scores (such as societal interest, innovation, approach, personel...) then the jury convene discuss a bit and change their scores if they want. The head of the jury then takes. all of that, combine and make a report. So in practice I've seen big abuses at every stage. Friends that help other friends get grants. Enemies that destroy theor enemies grants. Thieves that destroy the grant and then develop the work themselves after (that one we reported two times for two events to the funding agency that just removed that person from jury panels, nothing else). In the end, no one cares if they failed to achieve what they promised because nobody sees the grant (not public unless you submit a FOIA request) or remembers it 5 years later.