4 ms·
Certificates issued are good for multiple weeks, and all of the automated tooling renews when there is over 7d of certificate validity left, so they'd have to h
by sneak 5y ago
Certificates issued are good for multiple weeks, and all of the automated tooling renews when there is over 7d of certificate validity left, so they'd have to have a very long outage for this to actually take properly configured sites down.
They're not in the request path, and aren't accurately considered a point of failure. This is how the PKI works, by design.
- Ajedi32 5y agoIn this case it looks like their OCSP servers are down as well though. I think the validity period for OCSP responses is a bit shorter than 7 days. Even ignoring that, 7 days is a rather short period of time for such a large portion of the web to migrate to another CA if that were to become necessary for whatever reason. IMO having another free, independently operated ACME CA would be ideal, particularly if it could support having built-in fail-over added to ACME clients as a default setting.
- coder543 5y ago> IMO having another free, independently operated ACME CA would be ideal Did you see this comment? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27885851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27885851
- Ajedi32 5y agoObviously yes; it's in the comment chain I'm replying to. ZeroSSL is good, but AFAIK its free tier[1] doesn't support everything Let's Encrypt does (like wildcard certs) which makes it difficult to use as a drop-in replacement for many people. [1]: https://zerossl.com/pricing/ https://zerossl.com/pricing/
- gsich 5y agoTrue, but my guess is that most certificates are not wildcards.
- terom 5y agoTheir pricing page seems to be a little confusing, but [1] does state that wildcard certs issued via ACME are free of charge. The SSL.com [2] pricing model, OTOH... > By using ZeroSSL's ACME feature, you will be able to generate an unlimited amount of 90-day SSL certificates at no charge, also supporting multi-domain certificates and wildcards. Each certificate you create will be stored in your ZeroSSL account. [1] https://zerossl.com/documentation/acme/ https://zerossl.com/documentation/acme/ [2] https://community.letsencrypt.org/t/is-ssl-coms-acme-really-free/154463/3 https://community.letsencrypt.org/t/is-ssl-coms-acme-really-...
- Arnavion 5y agoTheir OCSP servers have always been spotty. OCSP stapling helps guard against that, at least.
- jchw 5y agoLet’s Encrypt ACME is a service that many depend on for their services, like Netlify, Synology, or Digital Ocean. It is true that existing certificates on existing hosts shouldn’t be impacted, but new certificates will be, and in my opinion that does actually matter. There may even be legitimate use cases for lazily grabbing certs in the request path; it’s pretty easy to do given that the Go ACME integrations basically do this plus some caching and scheduled renewal logic. This is of course aside from the OCSP point that others are noting, which does at least make PKI downtime a little more sketchy.
- jopsen 5y ago> There may even be legitimate use cases for lazily grabbing certs in the request path; Anything springs to mind? If you're using per-user sub-domains on your service, I'd imagine you'd be using wildcard certificates.
- dharmab 5y agoWhy use a wildcard? They're expensive and if compromised have a large blast radius.
- jchw 5y agoLE limits the number of subdomains you can request on a given domain, so it is probably somewhat necessary to use wildcard certs.
- jchw 5y agoHow about this: a service that runs on a customer’s own domain, under a subdomain. Think blogging, GitHub issues, some kinds of SaaS products. Seems like something not covered by wild cards that would not be thwarted by LE rate limits and probably is useful in practice.
- jopsen 5y agoSpot on..! sure it's not great that you can't setup a new domain. But that shouldn't be in the hot path for anything.