3 ms·
1. Depends on whether kopecks are divisible into a smaller monetary unit or not. If they are divisible into 100 units, I believe the answer is "anywhere between
by sokoloff 5y ago
1. Depends on whether kopecks are divisible into a smaller monetary unit or not. If they are divisible into 100 units, I believe the answer is "anywhere between 7.00 and 7.99 kopecks".
(Problem #2 requires kopecks to be divisible.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ekster 5y agoA kopeck is like a cent (1/100th of a ruble).
- valbaca 5y agoThey're not. It's like a penny. Sure you may have parts of cents like with gas, but for girls buying books, it's the lowest currency value.
- Symbiote 5y agoLong ago, many currencies had more divisions than they do now. The penny of GBP came in quarter pennies (farthings) until 1950. Half US-cent coins were made until 1857.
- haxiomic 5y agoWorks even if Kopecks are divisible: say the books value is 7.5, Mash must have 0.5 (7.5 - 7) and Misha 6.5 (7.5 - 1), however now when you combine them they sum to exactly 7.5 not less than, the only way to arrive at less than is if Masha has 0. So its always exactly 7
- LeifCarrotson 5y ago6.5 plus 0.5 is 7.0, they don't add up to exactly 7.5.
- gabagool 5y ago6.5 + 0.5 is 7.0, not 7.5, so that should be valid. The book's cost can lie anywhere between [7, 8).
- haxiomic 5y agoRight on the original typo, but still not convinced, I’ve rephrased to original to try to be clearer
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> say the books value is 7.5, Mash must have 1.5 (7.5 - 7) and Misha 6.5 (7.5 - 1), however now when you combine them they sum to exactly 7.5 not less than There are several problems with this: - 7.5 - 7 is 0.5, not 1.5 - 1.5 + 6.5 is 8, not 7.5 - 0.5 + 6.5 is still less than 7.5 The problem specifies that 2x - 8 < x. There is no way to constrain this to the specific solution x = 7. Everything would work fine if the book cost -2.6 kopecks.
- haxiomic 5y agoThank you :) I’m being very clueless today
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- culebron21 5y agoBefore 1917, they were divisible into 4 polushkas.
- rjp0008 5y ago> (Problem #2 requires kopecks to be divisible.) Does it? Did I fail at problem 2? I got: Bottle + cork = 10 Bottle = 9cork bottle/9 = cork 9(bottle + bottle/9) = 9(10) 9 bottle + bottle = 90 10 bottle = 90 bottle = 9 9 = 9cork 1 = cork
- sokoloff 5y agoI read the second statement ("the bottle itself is 9 kopecks more expensive than the cork.") as: Bottle = 9 + Cork Your statement (Bottle = 9 * Cork) would be "the bottle is 9 times as expensive as the cork". I solve it to: Bottle = 9.5 Kopecks. Cork = 0.5 Kopecks.
- amativos 5y agoI think part of the point of this brochure is to think about the problems intuitively in the context they are presented. So in the first problem it's just kids trying to buy their first book, it would be silly to think Masha had a fraction of a kopeck (assuming you understand what a kopeck is, I really think it should have been translated as cent) and that the answer could be in range [7, 8). This may be what he talks about when he says that many academics fail at these problems. Similarly, in problem #2 the cork indeed costs 0.5 kopecks but in this case we're just thinking about cost conceptually, not in terms of how much money a person actually has on hand.
- sokoloff 5y agoIndeed, but it likewise seems intuitively reasonable to think that a book costs much more than 7 cents (or 7 times whatever the atomic unit of currency is) and that over 100 times the atomic unit is more reasonable.