4 ms·
This coupled along with the fact that iMessage's E2EE has been backdoored by the non-E2EE iCloud Backup key escrow is a good argument for leaving iMessage, Face
by sneak 5y ago
This coupled along with the fact that iMessage's E2EE has been backdoored by the non-E2EE iCloud Backup key escrow is a good argument for leaving iMessage, FaceTime, and iCloud all turned off on a device.
I go one step further and leave the SIM card out, which means the SMS vulnerability path is closed too.
- msh 5y agoThen you could just as well get a iPod touch or iPad mini.
- sneak 5y agoNeither of those has a vibrate motor to let me know about notifications. They also can't be used to pair to an Apple Watch. I know this because I used to carry an iPad Mini in my pants pocket.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThen buy an iPhone, and turn off iCloud Backup in Settings, it's not hard to do. Then your iMessages are fully E2E Encrypted.
- sneak 5y agoNope, because they get escrowed by the other end of the iMessage conversation. Also, the whole point of disabling iMessage (in this thread) is to close the iMessage-related zero click exploits described in TFA.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThe other end of the conversation escrows the key on any messenger. Otherwise how would you read the message? Unless you consider Snapchat, but that's not End to End Encrypted. And are you really sure that Signal or your preferred messengers don't also have Zero-Click exploits? After all, they aren't sandboxed to the degree iMessage is with BlastDoor.
- sneak 5y agoSnapchat claims to be end to end encrypted, last I looked. Signal does not escrow endpoint keys in an iCloud Backup, so your first statement is incorrect.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThis is false. Snapchat has "snaps" protected, but text messages and group messages are not end to end encrypted. Also, Signal putting your escrow keys in iCloud? I don't think you know what you are talking about. You can set iMessage to not put your keys in iCloud like I said above by turning off iCloud Backup which makes it fully End-to-End with your own key on your device, just like Signal. If you are worried about the other party having their conversations being backed up, tell them to disable iCloud Backup. If you are this worried about the privacy of your communications, hopefully the other party would be as well. And Signal and any other E2E messenger is absolutely storing copies of your key on the recipient's phone, just like iMessage would. If it didn't, there'd be no way to verify that a message was sent from the same sender.
- Dah00n 5y ago>You can set iMessage to not put your keys in iCloud like I said above by turning off iCloud Backup which makes it fully End-to-End "Fully" smells like a weasel word here. Either it is E2EE or it isn't. iMesssage isn't by default from what you are saying and if it requires the other end to also turn off icloud backup before it is E2EE then I'd go as far as stating that it is a completely useless attempt to be E2EE. In fact I'd argue Apple is full of sh*t if they actually ever stared that it is E2EE (but I have no idea if they did). Comparing Signal to such a mess is... well at a minimum it is disingenuous.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoIt's not a weasel word. The messages are fully end-to-end encrypted, we know that, the EFF has stated as such. However, iCloud Backup means copies of your messages that arrived after the end-to-end process are backed up online. For most people who buy iPhones, having their messages not be permanently lost if their phone is stolen is a fair trade. If you don't want copies of your messages backed up after they arrived through the end-to-end encryption process, then turn it off.
- smoldesu 5y ago...or I could just use a truly-secure option that doesn't destroy my personal security model. Owning an iDevice presents a considerable security risk to my current setup.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThere is no such thing as a "truly-secure option." As anyone truly concerned about security will tell you. You will be forced to make compromises somewhere unless you want to live under a rock in the desert. You can't drive without a State ID, can't get a home loan without credit, can't work without a Social Security Number except under limited circumstances, can't make money without reporting to the IRS, and so on. It's entirely about what compromises you want to make, and the tradeoffs therein.
- sneak 5y ago> can't work without a Social Security Number except under limited circumstances Something like 96% of human beings don't have a social security number. Many of them work.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoLike the nation you live in doesn't have its own Tax Authority with information on you, and doesn't have its own ID Number you need to use for working. The technicals are different, the point is the same.
- smoldesu 5y agoI don't count on a "truly secure" option existing, I just manage my risk by reducing the amount of Big Tech thumbs in my personal pie. Apple, much like Amazon, Microsoft and Facebook, have no right to any of my personal information, end of story.
- nobodylikeme 5y agoI just wanna know how big are your pants pockets
- gjsman-1000 5y agoBut then you are using SMS, which your cell carrier can absolutely see and intercept because it's decrypted. So in either case... turn off native messaging and use Signal or something if you are paranoid. You aren't really using the "phone" part anymore, so buy an iPod touch or something. Also, iMessage is fully E2E if you disable iCloud Backup. Which can easily do in Settings.
- sneak 5y agoPlease stop using the term "paranoid" to describe those who desire personal privacy.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThere is a degree to where you are actually paranoid though, otherwise we wouldn't have that word. If you are this paranoid, you shouldn't be carrying an electronic device.
- caymanjim 5y agoIt's not paranoia when it's true. While most people value the convenience of conventional phones calls and default messaging applications over true privacy, those who prefer privacy aren't being paranoid. Companies are monitoring communication to increase ad revenue; government are monitoring communication to catch criminals, enable industrial espionage, and suppress dissent. It's only paranoia if it's delusional. We know that we're being spied on, even if we're not being individually targeted. Even democracies that supposedly value freedom engage in widespread surveillance in direct violation of their own laws. I'm in the camp of pragmatic resistance to surveillance. I use browser plugins to block ads and cookies where it doesn't get in the way of reaching the content I want; I use Signal for messaging even though almost none of my recipients do; I disable location services except for things like Maps that actually need to know where I am; I turn off all the spyware I know about that's built into operating systems; etc. I'm not a tin-foil-hat-wearer; I'm not doing anything illegal that I need to hide; I'm just trying to push back in a small way against the erosion of privacy and rights that permeates everything electronic. But the parent isn't paranoid. They really are watching. And we shouldn't be so complacent.
- askonomm 5y agoShould probably also dig an underground bunker and collect cans of sardines to last for decades.
- abaracadab 5y agoDon’t forget your pentium and DOS collection! Air-gapped of course.
- beervirus 5y agoCanned food has a surprisingly short shelf life. Sealed containers of dry beans and rice are the way to go.