10 ms·
Senet
- amitport 5y agoI once won an AI tournament for senet :) so for me this post relates to AI... But still... it's a mystery how this gets to the top of HN
- OJFord 5y ago> it's a mystery how this gets to the top of HN Because people (such as me!) found it interesting and up-voted it. Per the guidelines: > What to Submit > On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- comicjk 5y agoRandom wiki pages are one of the things that give HN its pleasant Old Internet atmosphere to me. Sometimes I've thought about sampling over wikipedia uniformly at random, submitting to HN, and observing the trends in what rises to the top.
- coldpie 5y agoHahaha. Have you ever clicked the "Random Article" button on Wikipedia? I learned the world has a _lot_ of tiny villages no one has ever heard of.
- bckr 5y agoWhat if there were a recommender system in the loop that looked at which articles tend to be voted up and then would be more likely to submit articles that it thought HN would find interesting — would a uniform distribution filtered by a "probability to be well-upvoted" be a good way to do this?
- lakkal 5y agoI used to do that a lot. Lots of small villages and soccer/football players...
- ggggtez 5y agoWhat's the best strategy? I barely notice any strategic edge, or even penality for making moves that look bad.
- amitport 5y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27890183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27890183 on this thread
- ggggtez 5y agoTaking a look, I don't really see any concrete lessons to take away. Maybe the most concrete thing is that a 3 block is valued at 20 while a 2 block is valued at 8. Unfortunately, this heuristic is probably just arbitrary, and nearly any set of weights would probably still produce a meaningful result since the main strategy is just Expectimax search. Disappointing. I was really hoping for some intuition that a human could apply
- amitport 5y agoWell it was just an anecdote, but in any case, there are a few strategies in this codebase, and I think if you look at https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai/blob/master/SmartUtility.cpp https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai/blob/master/SmartUtilit... you'll find it does a little more than what you said.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago>> I once won an AI tournament for senet :) When and where was that? More details please? :)
- amitport 5y agoIt was around 2010 before all the reinforcement learning madness :) It was a university student competition in (mostly computer science bachelor and master students). The core algorithm is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectiminimax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectiminimax which is a type of heuristic tree search over the possible board states. Winning such a tournament meant you can write efficient C++ code (so you can search more states during the allocated turn) and you can invent/feature-engineer good heuristics that estimate how close is a board state to winning the game. I don't remember what heuristics was used, I don't even remember the rules :) But I've uploaded the source to github a few years ago: https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai The heuristics are at: https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai/blob/master/SmartUtilit https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai/blob/master/SmartUtilit... I can't really make sense of it anymore :) but it seems to work
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoThanks! I think these days the idea is to replace hand-crafted heuristics with (deep) reinforcement learning. But adversarial search by minimax and friends is still the core of AI players, far as I can tell.
- amitport 5y ago(Fixed link: https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai/blob/master/SmartUtility.cpp https://github.com/amitport/senet-ai/blob/master/SmartUtilit... )
- zests 5y agoI love ancient board games. It's amazing to think about chess and how rules have been changed slightly over time for 1000 years. The game has since been stable for about 500. The computer era is revolutionizing the game again and maybe will usher in new popular variants (Fischer random, no castle chess) as our understanding of the game evolves.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> The computer era is revolutionizing the game again and maybe will usher in new popular variants… It’s going to be fascinating to see. I can imagine games getting “frozen” with hard coded rules and clear Official Rules too. I expect that to happen to word spellings, for example, with most everything we write having a layer of autocorrect in the loop. Digital games could do the same, when you can’t make house rules without programming your own variant.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Digital games could do the same, when you can’t make house rules without programming your own variant. Or go the other way, as low-/no-code customization tools and online distribution make it easier to make and share variants than it is to do so at any scale with physical games, subject to the openness (both in design and social factors like IP status) of the base game.
- zentiggr 5y agoI love the idea of "Bad Chess"... such a wild concept on top of an otherwise very structured ruleset.
- goblinux 5y agoVery Bad Chess by Zach Gage is the best I’ve seen of this. It’s on the iOS App Store, might be on google play. Worth a look if you like “bad chess”
- btilly 5y agoIt's amazing to think about chess and how rules have been changed slightly over time for 1000 years. Medieval chess was a very different game. For the most stark example, the queen did not get her modern move until around 1450. The game has since been stable for about 500. And yet something as basic as, "white moves first" was first suggested in 1857.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoLooks a bit like Mancala. I don't know much about Senet, but we played Mancala all the time, when I was a kid (in Africa).
- amitport 5y agoWell it's more like backgammon
- samatman 5y agoIntriguingly, mancala is the Egyptian Arabic name for that game. Some very early boards from e.g. Aksum in Ethiopia were identified by archaelogists as mancala boards, but are more likely to have been for Senet. It's probable that the Ancient Egyptians played both, but I don't believe the record is clear on where mancala came from and at what time it reached Egypt, presuming that isn't where it came from, which it might be.
- metaphor 5y agoApparently, variants abound. I grew up on a small island in the Pacific and played something similar[1] called chongka' as a kid as well. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southeast_Asian_mancala https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southeast_Asian_mancala
- myWindoonn 5y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Game_of_Ur https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Game_of_Ur for which we have guessed at the probable rules and can play it today.
- acheron 5y agoThere’s a great video on YouTube of Irving Finkel (quite an interesting guy) playing the Royal Game of Ur. https://youtu.be/WZskjLq040I https://youtu.be/WZskjLq040I
- iamjake648 5y agoI can't remember the exact book, but contained in a book about Ancient Egypt, there was the rules, paper pieces and a sample board for this game - we used to play it all the time as kids. My grandpa helped us make a wooden set of pieces and a board before he passed, it was a a great little intro to woodworking project.
- tallies 5y agoEgyptology?
- iamjake648 5y agoyup, that's the one!
- AvocadoCake 5y agoI found the game strangely addictive: http://www.playonlinedicegames.com/senet http://www.playonlinedicegames.com/senet
- krylon 5y agoSo when chess was first played, this game was already ancient. That is pretty cool.
- ggggtez 5y agoChess is old, but not as old as backgammon. And backgammon is an evolved version of this game. There are 3 ancient games still played commonly: chess, backgammon, and go.
- shadowgovt 5y agoI find it interesting that they span three very broad genres of gameplay: * deterministic with heterogeneous pieces * deterministic with homogeneous pieces * nondeterministic
- addingnumbers 5y ago> Espen Aarseth asked if the game Senet could be said to still exist, given that the rules were unknown. In response, Alexander de Voogt of the American Museum of Natural History pointed out that games did not have a fixed set of rules, but rules varied over time and from place to place. The game is the rules. Those people played different games. If you can do anything you want with it, it's a toy, not a game. If everyone forgot and lost the rules to pinochle, would we say pinochle still exists because people are playing poker with the same deck of cards?
- jlkuester7 5y agoI get your point, but really is anything like this so black and white? What about "house-rules"? If I am playing Pinochle with several additional house-rules (that either add or subtract from the "official" Pinochle rules) then what am I playing? On one hand I could see the argument that I am technically no longer playing official Pinochle, but it seems wrong to say that I am playing a game that is completely distinct from Pinochle. It seems more accurate to describe games (and honestly most other human activities) as existing on a continuum of more-or-less instead of a rather black and white boolean reality.
- addingnumbers 5y agoYou'd be playing a variant that directly evolved from pinochle. There's an undeniable lineage there. If you reverse-engineered your own rules from scratch knowing nothing but what a deck of cards looked like, it would be silly to claim you'd rediscovered pinochle. Say we fling a chess set out into space and ten million years later and alien civilization discovers it and concocts a game where they take turns placing pieces on the board like some elaborately-scored tic-tac-toe, would you say they rediscovered Chess?
- platz 5y agoIf you fling a chess set out into space, once it is disconnected from it's environment, does it enter a macroscopic superposition of states and start playing itself?
- v7p1Qbt1im 5y agoI remember getting the game as part of a collectors edition of the show LOST. Used to play it quite a bit.
- platz 5y agoYou played a modern interpretation. No one knows what the original game was.
- ggggtez 5y agoThe modern rules are largely just a guess, but the rulesets I've played with are... so-so. There is enough excitement, I guess, but nearly every game comes down to 50/50 luck. It's incredibly difficult to gain any sort of strategic edge. It's a curiosity,. But you should probably rather be playing backgammon.
- wanda 5y ago> Senet is the oldest known board game. I was always under the impression that a form of backgammon was on the ancient Mesopotamian/Sumerian scene around the same time -- though, now that I actually come to look for a good source to support that notion, I'm struggling to find one. Wikipedia and other sources just say "backgammon can be traced back nearly 5000 years" [0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backgammon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backgammon
- mabub24 5y agoYou might be thinking of Ur, which is roughly 4,500 years old. This is an interesting video from Dr. Irving Finkel on it and its playing rules.[0] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZskjLq040I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZskjLq040I
- guard-of-terra 5y agoThere are quite a few rulesets for the board. It's hard to say how exactly the inventors has played it. In this video the basic ruleset is shown. More advanced sets make use of more tile types, of pieces being two-sided - so that pieces have to return where they have started from, after being flipped at the opposite side of the board.
- karmakaze 5y agoToo bad we don't know the rules. Also, I think it's one of the oldest board games including Go and Backgammon.
- thrower123 5y agoI remember as a kid having a shareware sampler that had some very nicely done videogame versions of Senet, Hnefatafl, the Royal Game of Ur, and some sort of a Pueblo board game . Peak late 90s skeumorphism, complete with little rendered win/loss cutscenes. Unless I can find that CD, it's probably gone forever though
- themodelplumber 5y agoThere are a lot of people out there who remember shareware CDs. I'm always surprised by that particular aspect of software nostalgia. Same with things like ads in computer magazines; lots of people remember extremely well. Did the game happen to be one of these? https://archive.org/search.php?query=senet%20shareware https://archive.org/search.php?query=senet%20shareware
- thrower123 5y agoI think it is the Steve Neeley one, actually
- taejo 5y agoThe Internet Archive has a collection of those shareware samplers, maybe yours is there? https://archive.org/details/cdbbsarchive https://archive.org/details/cdbbsarchive
- anthk 5y agoI think you have these at https://wiby.me https://wiby.me by searching "Windows 98". I can´t remember the URL right now, but there was a game collection full of items with "real life mimicking" pieces.
- raunak 5y agoAnyone else know about senet from the Rick Riordan series The Kane Chronicles?
- dang 5y agoA couple small past threads: Senet: the original board game of death? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22288441 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22288441 - Feb 2020 (6 comments) Senet: board game from predynastic and ancient Egypt - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11099052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11099052 - Feb 2016 (5 comments)
- gnatman 5y agoI was introduced to senet via the 1995 pc game "Nile: Passage to Egypt" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nile:_Passage_to_Egypt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nile:_Passage_to_Egypt
- peter303 5y agoIn the Ten Commandment movie Nefertiti plays a different actual Egyptian game called Hounds and Jackals.
- getpolarized 5y agoIt's super sad that the history of Senet is mostly unknown. The texture we have of Chess history for example is part of the allure. That the rules have changed, we know how they changed, why they changed, how people played in the past, etc.
- coolguy132435 5y agoI am so happy to see mention of Senet anywhere - I have been addicted since I saw it featured on an episode of Lost back in highschool. About a decade ago, I found a Windows version that supported online play, that I played heavily with my then long distance girlfriend. I introduced the game to my family, and my mom even sewed together a fabric board for playing during flights. We play as a family any time I visit. A few weeks ago, I started writing up a text based version of it in Java, but put it on hold for the moment.
- jamilabreu 5y agoAwesome! Just this week I started a newsletter about the random Wikipedia articles I come across: https://randomwalk.substack.com/ https://randomwalk.substack.com/ Going to use this one in one of my next posts :)
- animal531 5y agoOn my games to create is still this idea of an AI generated super board game. For example I feed it in all board/unit/move/turn/winning/losing conditions etc, and it spits out a random game. Players can then play and vote on new games so that the popular and good ones rise up.