3 ms·
He likely did try to help access the data. It's not uncomfortable at all to admit that. The idea that this is espionage (what he is being charged with) is ludi
by pydry 5y ago
He likely did try to help access the data. It's not uncomfortable at all to admit that.
The idea that this is espionage (what he is being charged with) is ludicrous.
This is an uncomfortable topic for his detractors.
Even more uncomfortable given that Obama worried it was unconstitutional and criminalized journalism.
If this happened to a Russian citizen in Russia finding evidence of Russian war crimes not one of his detractors would argue that he was guilty.
- cookie_monsta 5y agoHe's being charged with a bunch of stuff. Offering to help Manning crack passwords and encouraging them to dig deeper is the uncomfortable bit for his supporters. I agree that the espionage charges are ridiculous and dangerous for actual investigative journalists.
- pydry 5y ago>is the uncomfortable bit for his supporters. If you say so.
- colechristensen 5y agoWhat then is espionage and how does it differ from actively participating in the theft of classified information? (for the sake of argument, assume that Assange actually did do things like crack password hashes) i.e. what is the differentiator that makes Assange innocent of espionage and would make someone else guilty?
- pydry 5y agoExfiltrating classified tactics, techniques or technology for the purpose of supplying a rival power with a tactical advantage would be a good working definition. Whatever definition is used if it includes leaking war crimes to the public and youre ok with that you are signing up to putting the pieces in place for a fascist dictatorship. That is not an exaggeration.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Exfiltrating classified tactics, techniques or technology for the purpose of supplying a rival power with a tactical advantage would be a good working definition. Not particularly good, IMO: Knowledge of what resources you have where seems pretty damn important, and that's neither "tactics, techniques or technology" AFAICS. > Whatever definition is used if it includes leaking war crimes to the public and youre ok with that you are signing up to putting the pieces in place for a fascist dictatorship. This ever so conveniently ignores the crux of the matter, namely that he (at least according to his accusers) leaked so much more than just "war crimes". > That is not an exaggeration. Given the above, it's a huge exaggeration.
- pydry 5y ago>Not particularly good, IMO: Knowledge of what resources Sure, add that to the list. It doesnt change anything. It was a definition I came up with on the spur of the moment. If you're picking minor holes in it then you missed my broader point: if your country's legal definition of aiding and abetting the enemy includes exposing war crimes to the world at large then it's deliberately not about espionage at all. >This ever so conveniently ignores the crux of the matter, namely that he (at least according to his accusers) leaked so much more than just "war crimes". It's not convenient in the slightest. Leaking evidence of American war crimes is all he is on trial for. >Given the above, it's a huge exaggeration. It's not an exaggeration in the slightest. This prosection is a giant klaxon warning bell signaling impeding fascism. Not just the prosecution itself, but how little support there is for dropping the case.