3 ms·
> "Irreversible transactions are a feature." They're definitely a bug. If I buy a TV with a credit card, and receive a box of rocks, I can do a chargeback. If I
by helsinkiandrew 5y ago
> "Irreversible transactions are a feature." They're definitely a bug. If I buy a TV with a credit card, and receive a box of rocks, I can do a chargeback. If I make that same transaction with cryptocurrencies, I'm SOL unless a fraudster suddenly decides that they really want to make good on it.
Agree with all you said apart from this - I'm not sure how reversible transactions would help you get money back from a fraudster. With 'legacy' money its eBay/Amazon or your credit card company (or the laws that they operate under), the level above the currency/transaction that gets you your money back. I imagine if Amazon accepted bitcoin they would also provide refunds.
The legal protection provided by using a credit card (in the UK/EU anyway) is by far the biggest reason not to use anything else for transactions on the internet.
- MereInterest 5y agoWith reversible transactions, the credit card company can reverse the transaction without the consent and cooperation of a fraudster. With irreversible transactions, the fraudster must initiate a transfer signed by their private key in order to transfer funds back to my account. Even with a court order, if the fraudster is in another country, they can just ignore it and I'm SOL. I agree that the legal protections are the bigger part of it, but the actions prescribed by those legal protections can only be implemented if transactions are reversible. Edit: I forgot to add, I'd also put the existence of ransomware as an effect of irreversible transactions. Prior to the rise of bitcoin, the main economic incentive for viruses was to rent out time on a botnet. Afterwards, the irreversible transactions meant that ransoming data from the computer owner was economically viable.