7 ms·
Collectors are also confused about that $1.56M Super Mario 64 sale
- chovybizzass 5y agoi gave my segamaster system away....dammit
- alabamacadabra 5y agoWhat’s confusing about laundering money? Lol. This and NFTs, it’s just obvious money laundering.
- rasz 5y ago"sale". We dont know who the buyer is, if any real money changed hands, or even something as basic as the number of Super Mario 64 boxes "graded" by Wata Games. Just a reminder, the previous record holder Mario sold at Heritage Auctions and graded by Wata Games was purchased by Jim Halperin - owner of Heritage Auctions with a seat on Wata Games board, pure coincidence Im sure! https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/02/how-this-ultra-rare-copy-of-super-mario-bros-sold-for-100000/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/02/how-this-ultra-rare-c... "Jim Halperin, owner of Heritage Auctions and one of three buyers"... "Halperin sits on the advisory board for Wata Games"
- diognesofsinope 5y agoThis seems plausible. My first thoughts were (1) fraud like you said or (2) money laundering.
- rasz 5y agoWhoa, who said anything about fraud? Certainly not me. Pure coincidence! The fact Wata Games doesnt publish population lists, like any other legit grading agency https://www.psacard.com/pop https://www.psacard.com/pop is simply an ordinary oversight on their part, and surely has no influence on the prices.
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoYup. This smells (no pun intended) of money laundering to me. Any auction for an obscurely collectible item is perfect for money laundering, since there’s a huge amount of plausible deniability in someone’s honest willingness to pay such an exorbitant sum. More concretely, let’s say Joe Criminal has $1.56MM in ill-gotten gains. He proceeds to sell an obscurely collectible item in his possession at auction. Via a shell company/individual, he anonymously bids it up to $1.56MM, and pockets the money minus any auctioneer fees. As long as the authorities don’t investigate the identity of this anonymous bidder, Joe Criminal has successfully laundered his $1.56MM. And as long as the authorities think that some crazy collector truly believes that an original Mario 64 cartridge is worth $1.56MM (as would also be the case for other obscure collectibles), it’s unlikely this particular transaction will raise their eyebrows. It’s not like there’s an army of appraisers out there who could fairly value this cartridge.
- crazygringo 5y ago> it’s unlikely this particular transaction will raise their eyebrows Considering it's national news, would they really not investigate it? It seems waaaaay too conspicuous and high-profile to be an attempt at money laundering. And from what I understand, auction houses are now required to file a 1099-K with the IRS so that the seller can't hide from taxes, or hide their identity. So even without the news, something tells me that filing capital gains tax on a ~3,000,000% return for a video game cartridge is going to flag a little bit of suspicion... ;)
- rasz 5y agoIts bigger than some random money laundering. "This morning on 7/14/21, PSA-grading parent company Collectors Universe just acquired Wata Games. The timing is anything but coincidental after the gigantic Heritage Auctions activities this past weekend." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ARoutGa4vQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ARoutGa4vQ
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoAlso entirely possible that it’s a pump-and-dump scheme to inflate the prices of old videogames. I think we both agree that the buyer and seller are the same entity.
- CTDOCodebases 5y agoAnd surprise, surprise Wata was just sold to collectorsuniverse.com
- betaby 5y agoHow collectors differentiate one mass produced item from another?
- paulpauper 5y agograding
- thatguy0900 5y agoWhich one has the most nostalgia. And super Mario 64 revolutionized 3d controls at the time, rather pivotal game.
- rasz 5y agoBy rarity. But this isnt collectors, this is a scam pumping fake values for popular items by manufacturing rarity thru grading of the cellophane on a video game box.
- hakfoo 5y agoWell, with some collectibles, you can go into manufacturing variations. Here's a real-world example: http://maibockaddict.com/1831-capped-bust-half-dollars.shtml http://maibockaddict.com/1831-capped-bust-half-dollars.shtml The 1831 date as a whole had a production run of a bit under 6 million, but it can be broken into 20 widely recognized sub-types. These have established survival/rarity figures from surveys of the market and community-- some are "two dozen or so known" and some are "hundreds or thousands". It feels like they're trying to mimic the concepts from the coin hobby-- numeric grading, the appearance of third party certification and encapsulation-- without developing the background and ecosystem for it first. For example, those "20 sub-types" trace back to a paper book originally published over 50 years ago, actual research performed by a passionate expert which has been expanded on by the community. The grading conventions are even older.
- paulpauper 5y agoIt's similar to MTG cards. That's what happens when you have a large fanbase plus considerable disposable income
- erhk 5y agoNot this time
- rasz 5y agoExcept this time there is no rarity element. Somehow as by magic the most popular games sold in tens of millions are reaching records.
- furyofantares 5y agoThat's why collectors introduce grading to these things, they desire rarity and grading provides it.
- rasz 5y agoExcept there already is rarity in retro games. There are games with "Only 13 copies are known to exist" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Raid_(1982_video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Raid_(1982_video_game) - this one sold for mere $16K at the same auction. Then you have your classic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nintendo_World_Championships https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nintendo_World_Championships with ~90 in circulation $180K at same auction. They all got outbid by the most common games ever released on the platform.
- dreyfan 5y agoIt’s staged just like the NFT auctions. Bootstrapping demand by fabricating a sale between two cooperating parties.
- choward 5y agoBasically just the start of another pump and dump scheme.
- lapetitejort 5y agoI've been a game collector for several years now. At the start of the pandemic, when every other other collectible started rocketing up in price, retro video games were no exception. Some games have doubled or tripled in price. However I'm not sure how susceptible they are to pump and dump schemes. They are fairly large physical objects, compared to trading cards and digital goods. The auction process and shipping takes takes days for one item to move. You can sell them to retro stores, but only for about 30% of their ticket price. Prices have remained stable according to reliable trackers [0]. 0: https://www.pricecharting.com/game/super-nintendo/earthbound https://www.pricecharting.com/game/super-nintendo/earthbound
- chadcmulligan 5y agoWon't they have to pay tax on that though?
- finnh 5y agoThat's the point - you launder money by paying taxes on it.
- pdpi 5y agoYou launder the money by inconspicuously inserting into legitimate accounting. The whole point is that you’re trying to avoid attention. The taxes are an unfortunate side effect. An auction that makes the news is nothing if not conspicuous. It’s tantamount to lighting a sign and saying “follow the money trail starting here”
- unstatusthequo 5y agoMoney laundering? Seems obvious to me.
- ianhanschen 5y agoReally surprised the article didn't mention the practice of money laundering.
- graeme 5y agoIf one wants to launder money, creating an eyebrow raising sale gathering press headlines and bafflement from insiders is not a great way. You want to be under the radar for money laundering. Not impossible, but another explanation seems more likely. (I don’t mean an innocent explanation necessarily)
- ashleyn 5y agoThey may have underestimated the community surrounding gaming. "It's something my kid plays, who pays attention to this stuff?"
- AussieWog93 5y agoI was talking about this in a Facebook chat for video game dealers. We are as confused as Kelsey is. Something seems genuinely fishy here.
- chrisco255 5y agoHow many sealed copies of Super Mario 64 remain in the world? Seems like yesterday that this game was launched. Story aside, I absolutely loved this game as a kid. I remember excitedly waiting this game. Nintendo Power shipped out a VHS cassette to hype the Sept 29, 1996 launch of the N64 that summer. I watched it over and over, I was so amazed by the graphics and the gameplay. For months after Super Mario 64 launched there were lines at Walmarts and video game stores showing off demos of it, of people waiting to play it. It was a huge event. The freedom of being able to run around and go anywhere in this game, I had never quite seen before. The fun of Mario's acrobatic maneuvers like wall jumps, triple jumps, stomps, and the flying cap were jaw dropping at the time. I can totally see why this game has sentimental value. I don't know if the rarity of sealed copies is sufficient to justify the price, but it is a masterpiece.
- salamandersauce 5y agoWe don't know. It's not that rare though, pricecharting seems to have 1 on average sold a month. The "condition" and high grade of 9.8 are supposedly what makes this super valuable. The thing is grading is somewhat subjective and depends on the grader. It's entirely possible to crack the thing open get it re-graded and have it come back as a 9.5. It's also entirely possible that someone out there still has a sealed case of the thing and we just don't know about it since it's such a common game. The price to me is just incredibly detached from reality.
- diogenescynic 5y agoI'm not. Easy way to launder money. People have no idea how much money laundering is currently going on. That's what a lot of these speculative vehicles are great for.
- DavidPiper 5y agoTangent: Love how the article is about Super Mario 64 but the picture at the top is of a Super Mario World cartridge.
- skhr0680 5y agoWe're getting old. On a TV quiz show I was idly consuming last night, the topic was 1989-2019s Japan and a young guy's question was "what is this console" with a picture of a GameCube. He answered "NES" ...
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoThe article pretty much answers the question. This is part of the price discovery process in the extreme high end of what's basically a new market. There's a grader and an auction house that are relatively new developments in this market, and that makes big money collectors comfortable coming into what to this point had been much less formalized. It's not the first time this has happened in a collectibles market, and it won't be the last.
- gowld 5y agoThere are no collectors here, though, only self-dealing dealers pumping up prices.
- mesozoic 5y agoDefinitely fishy to me. 1008 Alpha Black Lotuses printed and a perfect one sells for half a million. 12 million copies of Mario 64 and then this price for one with fucked up corners, no way.
- skhr0680 5y agoEasy money: 1. Discover old stock of sealed Mario cartridges 2. Get your friend to help you "sell" one for a million bucks 3. Auction off the rest one at a time for a much more reasonable $100,000 a pop
- rasz 5y agoHeritage only sells graded games. Wada Games is the grading body, they wont grade your copy higher than the one that just sold, despite the fact it had a crushed box. Nobody will pay 100K for most common game in N64 history. Car analogy time: Imagine waking up in a reality where Auction house dealing in art decides to do cars and in their first auction sells 2001 Mexico made VW Beetle they graded "pristine" (despite dented fender) for $80 million dollars while simultaneously selling $16K "pristine-" 1967 Beetle and $6mil Porsche 911 GT1 Strassenversion (20 ever made)
- fomine3 5y agoA bit less confusing for me compared to recent $$$ NFT sales.
- pl-94 5y agoHow can you confirm that the sealed object is not a fake? Sealing an object is quite easy no?
- valdiorn 5y agomoney laundering or some tax fuddly-duddly would be my guess?
- TrackerFF 5y agoMaybe it's like a variation on the old fiddle scam. Someone (with high-grade stock) are working with someone inside, and now they're trying to pump up prices to attract unsuspecting new money. It's no different than selling art, only that the rating companies are the ones setting the standard for how "rare" something is. 9.4 rating? Sorry, dime a dozen. 9.6? Million dollar piece.
- cainxinth 5y agoWhat’s confusing? Bubbles abound. 20 year old pickup trucks with six figures on the odometer are selling for $20k. Pokémon cards are going for millions. Houses are being bought above asking price, sight unseen. P/E ratios on the stock market have gone to plaid. An NFT collection of animated gifs sold for Picasso prices. And a satirical, dog meme currency has a $25b market cap. It’s unsustainable, but you won’t find me making big bets one way or the other, because, as John Maynard Keynes said, “the markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.”
- mensetmanusman 5y agoPhysical goods are only going to get more rare as our digital economy grows, so the spend per article will increase on non-bit items.
- tyleo 5y ago> Physical goods are only going to get more rare as our digital economy grows What is the reasoning to back this up?
- werber 5y agoThe scarcity of an item like a 25 year old Nintendo game will only increase with time, I think was the authors intention
- AstralStorm 5y agoAnd why would that be scarce if we had, say, a way to perfectly clone such items? It's actually quite trivial to do, only copyright is stopping that. The original has no intrinsic value over a perfect physical copy. (As opposed to a reproduction.)
- mensetmanusman 5y agoValue is subjective. People value original artwork even though we can do per pixel exact copies beyond the resolution limit of human vision :)
- arbitrage 5y agomoney laundering & tax evasion. there, we solved it.
- milross 5y agoI think they are just trying to raise the value of the collection so that the sideline investors will get their attention about the said sale.
- auiya 5y agoThat money's not going to launder itself, what's confusing?