7 ms·
The author appear to be using OnePlus 3T which uses a Qualcomm Snapdragon 821 with X12 LTE Modem. It support VoLTE with AMR-WB but not EVS. I doubt EVS is a har
by ksec 5y ago
The author appear to be using OnePlus 3T which uses a Qualcomm Snapdragon 821 with X12 LTE Modem. It support VoLTE with AMR-WB but not EVS. I doubt EVS is a hard requirement until VoNR in 5G. But not supporting it seems strange.
In the old days Network require certification for phones to work. I am not sure if that is the case in US but for many part of the world that is no longer required.
It could also be the lack of band support if AT&T forces VoLTE on certain band, but I also think that is extremely unlikely.
Edit: Turns out AT&T operate on a whitelist system [1] ( What ? ) with a list [2] of phones. Sort of surprised but also not so surprised coming from an US Mobile Carrier.
At least US is moving quickly to drop 2G and 3G and refarm those spectrum along with dropping circuit switch backend. But mobile cost is still ridiculously expensive.
[1] https://www.xda-developers.com/t-mobile-att-require-volte-phone-calls-shut-down-3g/ https://www.xda-developers.com/t-mobile-att-require-volte-ph...
[2] https://www.att.com/idpassets/images/support/wireless/Service-Capabilities-Unlocked-Devices-ATT-Network.pdf https://www.att.com/idpassets/images/support/wireless/Servic...
- blfr 5y ago> Turns out AT&T operate on a whitelist system [1] ( What ? ) with a list [2] of phones. Sort of surprised but also not so surprised coming from an US Mobile Carrier. Pretty sure all carriers in Poland operate on a white list of phones. https://wificalling-volte.pl/ https://wificalling-volte.pl/
- tpmx 5y agoHaving a white list of devices is pretty unusual in Europe, afaik.
- distances 5y agoCan confirm, I've worked with mobile phone related stuff for about 15 years and never before this article have I heard of a whitelist. My first reaction is that the concept sounds ridiculous, you're supposed to be able to put a SIM card to any device you find and just use it.
- blfr 5y agoThat's exactly how it works, just without VoLTE and VoWiFi.
- g_p 5y agoThe US (not sure about Canadian) mobile market is completely different to the European one. It's almost alien in comparison - the carrier tries to control absolutely everything, and generally sees the handset as an extension of their network to the extent they want to "type approve" every firmware release on every handset that is "allowed" onto their network. Apple appeared to become the exception due to having such an "in-demand" handset (going exclusive with AT&T initially might have helped them negotiate better terms with other carriers to get the iPhone to their networks) - mobile operators can't modify the iOS firmware at all. On any other phone, expect branding, pre-installed bloatware apps, modified startup and shutdown screens, modified top-bar to show "5G" on presence of a 4G network, and 6+ month delays to security updates while they get the above modifications made to the firmware before they approve it. Arguably part of the "control" mindset comes from CDMA networks, where you couldn't "pop the SIM" and change network - you had to get the ESN whitelisted on the network, and that gave the carrier a lot of control over your ability to switch phone, or whether you could buy it from anywhere except themselves. I guess GSM carriers admired this level of customer-capture, and wanted to replicate it. It sounds like "GSM" carriers are going to have to move fully towards whitelisting to preserve voice calling service when they get rid of their circuit switched fallback networks. Inbound roaming of foreign users will be interesting in the next few years - without any CSFB voice support, they will likely not be able to serve most incoming roamers (who don't have network-to-network arrangement for VoLTE roaming), and that might cause a loss of roaming revenues once travel levels return towards more of a normal.
- tpmx 5y ago> when they get rid of their circuit switched fallback networks Why? Isn't that stuff they run in software (on network hardware) and could emulate forever for a low cost? (Or at least for another decade until very, very few people would care.)
- anticensor 5y agoIn Turkey, device whitelisting is required by law, but it is done by the government itself, not by the carrier operator.
- ksec 5y agoInteresting. What is the rational of that? So I cant bring in a obscure phone that no one have heard of before into Turkey and expect it to work on any mobile network? This is hardly "Mobile" at all.
- anticensor 5y agoNot like that. It is done by IMEI-IMSI-personal ID number matching, not by device types. If any one component of that triplet changes, you have a month to register it to yourself again. Otherwise, no service to you anymore. And yes, they will probably refuse to register an IMEI for a device that is not previously certified to operate in Turkey.
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoOrange (.fr) has a whitelist of devices even for data LTE.
- chasil 5y agoThe earliest supported OnePlus is the 6t. https://www.xda-developers.com/will-my-phone-work-on-att-after-3g-shutdown/ https://www.xda-developers.com/will-my-phone-work-on-att-aft...