30 ms·
I don't normally go for memes, but this describes it pretty well. https://mobile.twitter.com/cyb3rops/status/1415937079645777921 https://mobile.twitter.com/cyb3
by viraptor 5y ago
I don't normally go for memes, but this describes it pretty well. https://mobile.twitter.com/cyb3rops/status/1415937079645777921 https://mobile.twitter.com/cyb3rops/status/14159370796457779...
There's a lot to discuss about those specific issues, but at the very core of it is: why is the printer spooler running as SYSTEM and why hasn't it been fixed a decade ago?
- Santosh83 5y agoI guess the thinking is if it ain't broken, don't fix it. Now that they've been majorly embarrassed, you can expect a re-architect of the print spooler for Windows 12.
- smolder 5y ago...And the insertion of new, obscure, poorly secured services related to emojis or something.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>you can expect a re-architect of the print spooler for Windows 12. I don't envy the poor buggers tasked with that. The printing subsystem has been accumulating cruft for decades.
- tinus_hn 5y agoThey can just switch to AirPrint or something really similar and immensely simplify things while keeping 99% of the functionality people need.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThere is just so much stuff that that doesn't cover. Some companies have really complex printing requirements. There is a ton of legacy drivers, application software and printers that need supporting.
- tinus_hn 5y agoYeah and all these things are not in the 99% most people really need
- IntelMiner 5y ago(Un?)fortunately Microsoft isn't Apple. They can't cut users arms off and then say "well just become left handed!" just because it suits them Their entire business model is based on being a stable target that enterprises can build software on top of. For what it's worth. I did once try spending a weekend trying to jury rig a cheap printer without Wi-Fi to my mothers iPad The printer instantly came to life with Apple's CUPS software. Windows and Linux clients were more than happy to forward items to it to be printed once configured The iPad however required Air Print. Something CUPS does not support, indeed Apple themselves refuse to implement it! At least according to the Debian Wiki There's a bucket of alternative software like Avahi that is meant to expose CUPS as an AirPrint-able printer but I was never able to get it to work. And in true Apple fashion there were no error messages or the like from the iPad itself. Print jobs would simply fail silently in the background If "make a crappy HP printer work on a home network and talk to an iPad" is in that 1% scope of yours then I cannot imagine the kinds of stuff Microsoft's customers would lose out on trying to squeeze into the AirPrint world
- tinus_hn 5y agoYou can turn this into an Apple whine fest if you like but that has absolutely nothing to do with simplifying printing. Reality is that 99% of printing is a person clicking a button because he wants to have a piece of paper that shows the things he sees on screen. You don’t need the insane complexity that is Windows printing for that. But you do need someone to say this printer driver is old and no longer supported. Now you may want to believe in a dream where your precious inkjet from the 90s will be supported forever. But just like Windows 10 dropped support for a ton of these museum pieces, so will Windows 11. And you can blame Microsoft (or Apple) for that and they’ll just point to the manufacturer. Believe it or not, we are heading for a future where operating systems will not let manufacturers run their crappy code in the kernel or in privileged processes just because that was a right they had 20 years ago. It’s unnecessary and dangerous so it’s going away. Your iPad does not support your cheap printer and Apple isn’t going to fix it. And guess what happened? The new cheap printers that are in store right now do support AirPrint so iPads can print to them. Because customers demand it. It’s not rocket science.
- tyingq 5y agoIt seems like a problem that's occurred many times, going back to at least 1999: https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=windows+spooler https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=windows+spo... I don't know if there's anything different enough this time to cause them to go that direction.
- iaml 5y ago> Now that they've been majorly embarrassed, you can expect a re-architect of the print spooler for Windows 12 Bold of you to assume they care.
- technion 5y agoThe plot twist here is that the print spooler runs as SYSTEM on domain controllers where there is special guidance not to ever disable it on these most critical dedicated servers: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/security/windows-services/security-guidelines-for-disabling-system-services-in-windows-server https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/security/win... Print Spooler: OK to disable if not a print server or a DC
- tyingq 5y agoAhh, a domain controller is responsible for pruning invalid print queues in ActiveDirectory.
- amluto 5y agoAs far as I’m concerned, the print spoiler shouldn’t be a systemwide service at all. Unless a computer is serving a local printer for use by others, just printing a document can be done entirely in the context of the user doing the printing.
- sebazzz 5y agoIs it OK to disable it on a domain where no printing happens?
- tyingq 5y agoThe print spooler has a pretty spotty history too: https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=windows+spooler https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=windows+spo...
- tinus_hn 5y agoYou can run the print spoiler without having it listen to network. Is that also required?
- oneplane 5y agoIt doesn't matter because you can have something else that does listen on the network and even if that doesn't have administrative privileges you can use its user privileges to access the spooler that way, and there you go, instant SYSTEM access.
- kerng 5y agoMy understanding is that its it's about the code path for installation of drivers that is being exploited. In order for people to print to printers not seen before, Windows downloads and installs the driver automatically from a remote printer when a low privilege user wants to print. I guess that's why it runs as high privilege. Not defending anything just hoping to provide useful insights.
- tialaramex 5y agoThis feels like the sum of many independently defensible decisions that somebody ought to have stood back from and gone "Woah, that's not OK" overall. Should we do a modern rewrite of the print spooler, maybe cut it up into different chunks following modern practices and use the less risky codepaths invented since it was built? No, printing is no longer critical path for many customers, so minimal budget for this software. Should there be a separate fancy print spooler for the people who might actually want unprivileged print requests to result in magically installing privileged device drivers? Alas this would take a rewrite, which we can't do, see above. Should the print spooler have SYSTEM? Alas the single print spooler we ended up with because of the above decision needs SYSTEM or it will not function as intended. Should machines with no business printing anything need Print Spoolers (which get SYSTEM)? Alas the single print spooler we ended up with also performs necessary central clean-up that must take place on systems with no print spool. Only when you zoom out and see the result is it obvious, we should spend some of our security budget getting rid of this arrangement, it's clearly a problem waiting to happen.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>My understanding is that its it's about the code path for installation of drivers that is being exploited. That was the PrintNightmare exploit. There don't seem to be any details on this one yet.