5 ms·
Mass Infection Is Not an Option: We Must Do More to Protect Our Young
- pjc50 5y ago(Named after https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Snow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Snow , the dead epidemiologist, rather than https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Snow_(journalist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Snow_(journalist) the channel 4 newsreader, in case anyone was confused)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crawfordcomeaux 5y agoThe absence of official requests to reorganize society around well-being at this far into the pandemic is telling. Where are the calls for abandoning economic concerns? What about developing a more giving society? What about promoting people isolate within communities large enough to actually meet all their needs, as opposed to a bubble of only a few, which is practically guaranteed to lead to all kinds of codependent mess? What about dismantling the parts of society that allow for such rapid transmission of contagion and not simply pausing these or those parts? The avoidant, isolatory, individualistic approaches we've seen in the world are still only a subset of mitigations we could've been trying, but deep changes don't seem to be officially proposed anywhere I've seen. This has been bothering me since the pandemic was announced. I don't understand what it'll take for people to get serious here. It seems like the same hesitation to implement drastic changes that underlie the persistent states of white supremacy. It seems like a pandemic version of the "Gosh...I don't know. That seems over the top." response to actually dismantling fundamentally racist systems instead of ineffective, slow reform. Denial can look like lying. It can also look like indecisiveness. It can also look like trying to do a bunch of things that will have predictably negative effects in order to look like something's being done, but for sure won't address the core issues. Even this letter smells like denial, since the proposed actions don't address all needs and is an appeal for more of the same types of mitigations we've been seeing. Humans have a finite set of needs and thriving means meeting them all in ways that deny none. Have any of these strategies been examined from that perspective? Online schooling sure hasn't. That's one singular massive thing that's been imposed on young people and it's been an incredible challenge to watch friends who are teachers and friends who are parents comply with what everyone agrees are neglectful-toward-children approaches. This letter seems to ask for more of the same. I'm glad people are speaking up and look forward to proposals way more radical than this. Humans have a finite set of needs. If any solution hasn't been assessed from the perspective of "does this systematically deny anyone's needs?" then the assessment is incomplete to the point of being massively harmful. THAT is unethical and illogical.
- pjc50 5y ago> What about dismantling the parts of society that allow for such rapid transmission of contagion and not simply pausing these or those parts? Look, I'm in favor of more countermeasures but I'm not willing to talk of permanently ending nightlife and the traditional British pub. Or live music. Or church services. Or football crowds, despite the thousands of cases from the Euros.
- mxmmdmddm 5y ago> Where are the calls for abandoning economic concerns? I'm sorry, but you're completely off your rocker if you think economic concerns are a social construct and can just be abandoned. We are born into the world in a natural state of cold, hunger, and exposure, and someone has to labor to provide food, warmth, and shelter, and that comes through voluntary exchange (economy) or literal slavery, which is why every society that has done away with markets has turned into a slave state Your calls for abandoning economic concerns are on the lunatic fringe where they belong
- crawfordcomeaux 5y agoThanks for this comment. I'll be more specific: Financial and/or debt economy concerns. Long live the gift economy and all it concerns.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Invictus0 5y agoHundreds of millions of people around the world have decided to refuse the vaccine. If policymakers decide to maintain the restrictions until, say, 80% vaccine uptake, they will be waiting forever. At the end of the day, governments are beholden to their constitutents, and the people have decided they would rather get sick.
- roenxi 5y agoWhat exactly is this letter calling on governments to do? It seems obvious to me that most people are capable of isolating themselves if required. It isn't like keeping away from other people is hard just because the government makes it legal. Why is it necessary to have a government mandate to lock everyone down, given that UK has been vaccinated?
- thom 5y agoThe only times we've had full remission of the pandemic in the UK has been during government mandated lockdowns, so it seems pretty clear that just trusting people's instincts doesn't work. That said, I don't see why people are arguing the toss about Monday's changes - we already have skyrocketing cases, and as much as school holidays might move the needle, that didn't seem to be enough over the Winter.
- pjc50 5y ago> most people are capable of isolating themselves if required. .. depending on economic circumstances and availability of sick pay. The problem here is that a lot of people are in jobs where they're unavoidably exposed to other people. Or have children who have to go school. At least the school holidays will impair school transmission for a month or two. > given that UK has been vaccinated? This isn't true; we're only at 67% of adults, and vaccination of children is still at the trial stage I believe? https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations Where did you get the claim that the UK was fully vaccinated?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]