4 ms·
I'm a fair way from the vocal HN crowd on this one. I can't see the problem with Tesla calling what they have "Full" self driving. I don't know who keeps the of
by roenxi 5y ago
I'm a fair way from the vocal HN crowd on this one. I can't see the problem with Tesla calling what they have "Full" self driving. I don't know who keeps the official definition, but I don't care what they think and vice versa. This looks like full self driving to me.
You lot are very demanding. I'm not sure the public will care that much.
- rvz 5y ago> This looks like full self driving to me. ‘Looks’ can be deceiving. Especially when the Tesla CEO overpromised to his customers about achieving Level 5 self driving capabilities, when a year later it was found to be still admittedly ‘Level 2’. I have to give it to Musk for being able to continuously mislead his customers and continue to make money out of a product feature that does not work as advertised. If it was anyone else they would be sued to the ground. > I can't see the problem with Tesla calling what they have "Full" self driving. I have no problem with them calling it ‘Fools’ Self Driving.
- tluyben2 5y agoWell, when people read full self driving, they think they never have to touch the wheel in whatever circumstance. Can you remove the wheel? That the public does not care does not mean it is not a wrong message which might lead to bad accidents, by the public.
- roenxi 5y agoMy retort to those people is that would probably be illegal, and they shouldn't expect to be able to do illegal things. I don't think I've heard of a self driving car yet where it is OK to take your hands off the wheel.
- tluyben2 5y agoThe issue is that this is not about reading the small print: this is about the point that if you walk into the street, hit up a stranger and ask if the phrase 'full self driving' suggests to them that they need to keep hands on the wheel, pay attention or anything like that. There are 1000s of videos on the web where people are doing things in Teslas, including having sex, while driving and that gives me the distinct impression that the public did not read the small print and believes the marketing phrasing. It is false advertising and I find it weird that it is allowed. People will believe it and not spend time sweating the nuances like you or I would.
- voakbasda 5y agoI believe most people have read the fine print. They just don’t believe or understand the limitations, in the light of the amazing things it can already do. They understand the potential consequences, but they naively believe that anything bad will happen to someone else. By way of example, the causes to most industrial accidents are well known in advance, and workers are trained to avoid them by using proper procedures or safety equipment. Yet these same accidents still occur with regularity. Why? Because some people will be too lazy/ignorant/stupid to follow directions. You can’t make anything foolproof, because the universe will simply evolve a bigger fool. Don’t blame the car. Blame the idiots behind the wheel that do the stupid things. They are the problem here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- erhk 5y agoIts great that you believe that. I dont and we can stop the conversation here.
- ac29 5y agoYou make it sounds like its a minor technicality. The reason you cant take your hands off the wheel isnt because of outdated laws, its because Tesla's software will happily steer the car into stationary and moving objects alike, as well as make other dangerous moves like late lane changes across solid lines.
- plebianRube 5y agoHowever, it's kind of genius if you think about it, that tesla has people paying 10k a pop to test their software and collect data for them.
- Jasper_ 5y agoHere's a video from 2018, from the official Tesla account. https://vimeo.com/192179726 https://vimeo.com/192179726 It starts with the words "The person in the driver's seat is only there for legal reasons. He is not doing anything. The car is driving itself." The rest of the video shows the car moving without the person touching the wheel. So yeah, I do indeed wonder where people have gotten the impression that it is OK to take your hands off the wheel in a Tesla-make car.
- addicted 5y agoIt's the exact opposite. The question here is not what the "official" definition is. It's what Tesla drivers and potential owners would think it means.