2 ms·
So, quoting a court's justification of its decision, proves the court made the right decision? Of course the ECHR is going to claim "this case is unique and is
by skissane 5y ago
So, quoting a court's justification of its decision, proves the court made the right decision?
Of course the ECHR is going to claim "this case is unique and isn't inconsistent with our rulings in other cases". Just because they claim that doesn't make it true.
- slg 5y agoI never said it was the right decision. I said it is possible for the two decisions to coexist and that is the description for how they coexist. I don't know what I else I could write here that would satisfy you.
- skissane 5y agoSo, my claim is, that the ECHR's case law on genocide denial is inconsistent, and that inconsistency is politically motivated. I don't think I've proven the claim. But I think an objective person would have to say that there is a reasonable possibility it is true. Do you agree there is a reasonable possibility the claim is true?
- imwillofficial 5y agoSuddenly ::crickets::
- slg 5y agoSorry, I didn't realize I had an obligation to spend all of my Friday night constantly refreshing HN. My fault.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slg 5y ago>Do you agree there is a reasonable possibility the claim is true? Sure, it is reasonable it is politically motivated. It is also reasonable it isn't. Giving the lack of definitive answer, I chose to give the benefit of the doubt to the ECHR. Either way, I don't understand what point you are trying to make.
- skissane 5y agoWell, my point is this – if you try to justify laws against genocide denial, it is easier to justify them if those laws are consistent, and based on principle rather than politics. If there is a real possibility that we have unprincipled inconsistencies in them, that is a problem for their justification.
- slg 5y agoWhy is the justification impacted by the consistency of certain implementations? Speed limits aren't consistent. You can't go above 60 mph anywhere in Hawaii, but some places in Texas you can go 85 mph. That doesn't mean speed limits aren't justifiable. Laws are always going to vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Sometimes that difference is based on principle. Sometimes it is based on politics. But even if it is tweaked due to politics, it doesn't invalidate the principle behind the entire law.
- skissane 5y agoWhen laws treat members of different racial/ethnic/national groups differently, that's a form of discrimination. If there was a genocide against group A, and another against group B, and we say that it is illegal to deny the genocide against group A, but legal to deny the genocide against group B, that is treating group A and B differently. It is going to upset many members of group B, and damage social cohesion. Especially so if the different legal treatment is based on politics rather than principle. I don't think your case of speed limits is really comparable. Nobody's personal identity is based on a speed limit, those laws – however rational or irrational they may be – are not relevant to personal identity. But genocide denial laws are relevant to personal identity – to racial/ethnic/national/etc identity – since different genocides have different victim groups, and there are people alive today who belong to those victim groups and identify with them, and the victims of a genocide (and their descendants) have a special interest in whether it is legal to deny that genocide.