4 ms·
Oh, not again. This is mostly an ad for some streaming service. See the author's comment on the video: Get your SPECIAL OFFER for --- here: It's an exclusive o
by Animats 5y ago
Oh, not again. This is mostly an ad for some streaming service. See the author's comment on the video:
Get your SPECIAL OFFER for --- here: It's an exclusive offer for our viewers! Start your free trial today. --- is a new kind of streaming service run by filmmakers...
This is actually a real problem, it's quite fixable, and not enough is being done about it. I've posted a link before to the PJM grid's training materials about this, which few will read. If you're really interested, go read the training materials on emergency procedures. I'm not going to provide a link. It's not the end of the world. The last time this happened, there were some breaker trips and blackouts, and one transformer burned out.
There are a few places in the electrical grid where you woud like to have a big capacitor between the center of the transformer delta and ground. That hasn't been done enough. Also, having more large spare transformers around would be good.
However, monitoring DC current flow between the center of the delta and ground is in place, so that the need to shut down can be detected before the transformer overheats.
It's not likely to hurt anything other than long distance power transmission. Nothing else has continuous wires hundreds of km long any more. Effect on fiber optics is zero.
Incidentally, this has nothing to do with "EMP", which is something else entirely.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jampekka 5y agoI've been following Sabine Hossenfelder for a while and I think she may be even the best popularizer of science/physics at the moment. She has started to add sponsor messages to her videos, which is quite sad, but for me it tells more about the sorry state of academic funding and the academic community in general. She goes against the "establishment" and criticizes very real problems that academia would rather just ignore. I don't know enough about solar effects on electric grids, but I wouldn't pass it off just because it has to be (sadly) funded with borderline scam ads because the borderline scam academic funding structure won't fund it.
- Animats 5y agoCould be worse.[1] Could be better.[2] [1] https://www.brimhall.com/p-104-total-shield-emf-protection.aspx https://www.brimhall.com/p-104-total-shield-emf-protection.a...? [2] https://www.pes-psrc.org/kb/published/reports/PSRC%20-%20K17_Report_Final%2020190927.pdf# https://www.pes-psrc.org/kb/published/reports/PSRC%20-%20K17...
- elevaet 5y ago> There are a few places in the electrical grid where you woud like to have a big capacitor between the center of the transformer delta and ground. How big should these capacitors be? How does this compare to what's typical right now? You sound like you know something about how big power systems work - how quickly can a grid be disconnected from the transformers in an emergency situation? It seems like we would have at least some warning if a big CME was heading our way.
- aaron695 5y ago> See the author's comment on the video: The author is Sabine Hossenfelder, well posted on HN - https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=backreaction.blogspot.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=backreaction.blogspot... A moderate scientist, but unwilling to put up with BS. Has interviewed some of the top people in physics, not popular people but top people. Has several books out. One of the best scientists out there talking real science IMO. Puts in a lot of work to her videos that go to a pretty high level. Has a odd and funny sense of humour. Also does music videos. Also needs to earn money. People complain about product placement and influencers, people complain about pay walls, it all gets pretty boring. She puts in very obvious ads, not sure what more people want. Generally she's pretty right. I'm sure she can be wrong. I learned something from her video. This month across Europe thousands of pidgins went missing. Some claim it was solar weather, but no one seems willing to confirm or deny that. How can that be? Do we not track this stuff. I'm happy for her to do a video on this.
- sbierwagen 5y ago>Effect on fiber optics is zero. Note that underwater cables carry a copper conductor to power the inline laser amplifiers. Would they pick up an eddy current 100m underwater? Probably not, but you'd hope they have disconnect switches at the beach landing hut, and someone on call 24/7 within 10 minutes drive distance to open them. Without the amps, an undersea fiber cable is just an unusually long strand of glass.
- Johnythree 5y agoThe problem is large scale ground currents, eg currents of thousands of amps traveling through the ground. Which means that deeply buried (or underwater) cables are particularly vunerable. And of course that even happens today, eg the ground currents caused by electric trains and trams can be very destructive.