3 ms·
> threatening to reveal their personal information, such as their legal identity What's the problem with that? Bad things on the internet happen more often tha
by mrtksn 5y ago
> threatening to reveal their personal information, such as their legal identity
What's the problem with that? Bad things on the internet happen more often than not because of the lack of responsibility.
Doxxing has become the primary sin in the Internet religion but it would solve all kind of problems. I am going to commit that sin and say that Doxxing is the solution, you can downvote me and make my comment greyed out and censor me when you argue against censorship.
Instead of deleting content, simply make sure that it's linked to someone who can pay for it if it turn out to be something to be payed for.
The Anonymity argument is only good when you are actively persecuted by a state actor. I don't agree that you deserve anonymity because the public will demonise you. If you hold strong believes that can be met harshly by the general public, you better be ready for the pushback and think of ways to make it accepted. That's how it has been done since ever.
Therefore, when a content is questionable maybe the users should be simply KYC'ed en left alone until a legal take down order is issued. If its illegal(like illegal porn, copyrighted content, terroristic activities etc), go to prison for it. If its BS get your reputation tarnished.
- breakfastduck 5y agoYou are so, so wrong here. Who the hell gets to judge what is 'to be payed for' in this world you're talking about? The mob? No thanks! In fact the internet actually went to shit the minute it pivoted from 'Dont share your personal info publicly' to 'please give us every last drop of your personal information and share it publicly'
- mrtksn 5y ago>Who the hell gets to judge what is 'to be payed for' in this world you're talking about Those who demand the payment, obviously. Denying the existence of the god or being gay could be something to be payed for in some places and obviously that is horrible thing but anonymity doesn't solve that. Fighting for a change or leaving that place solves something. Alan Turing himself was subjected to these things in the United Kingdom. A few decades later things changed in the UK and had nothing to do with the anonymity. Now those who think that gays deserve equal rights demand payment. Again, anonymity it's not helping the anti-gay folks but simply creates low quality discussion and stress and nothing more.
- breakfastduck 5y ago> anonymity doesn't solve that Yes, it literally does on the internet
- mrtksn 5y agoWhat it solved exactly?
- breakfastduck 5y agoStopped people getting doxxed, hunted down a lynched in countries where you're executed for being a homosexual, while still being able to communicate safely online with other people in the same situation? How exactly does anonymity not solve that problem?
- nemo44x 5y agoWell clearly people that think like them will always be in control of things. That’s the thing people don’t often consider - how will this policy/law/norm work when I’m not the one benefiting from it?
- TheDong 5y ago> What's the problem with that? > If you hold strong believes that can be met harshly by the general public, you better be ready for the pushback and think of ways to make it accepted. That's how it has been done since ever. The problem is that we're not talking about the general public. Let's say I'm Jewish. Someone on the internet may "doxx" me by finding a group of neonazis and spreading my information there, resulting in me getting threats and hate. The internet seems to specialize in this sort of "doxxing". Why? My theory is that the internet, even if you have a real name for a handle, still distances and dehumanizes others to the point where it's hard to understand the pain you're causing. It's hard to walk up and slap someone because you feel the slap and see them wince in pain. It's easy to DM someone on twitter something far more hurtful than a slap, laugh about it with your tribe of neonazis, and forget about it the next day.
- mrtksn 5y agoI think the solution of your problem is physically securing you against neo nazis instead of hiding your identity. Unless of corse you are writing this from the 1940's and you are in Central Europe. If that's the case, you have a case.
- TheDong 5y agoI am writing this on the internet. Physically securing myself does nothing to prevent hatemail, DoSs, and slander. The ideal that "lies can't hurt you, the truth is stronger than lies" has never seemed to actually work. There are countless fictions are far more prominent than facts, and there are countless people who's online experience has been damaged by a small contingent of dedicated attackers. The response to "harboring free speech to the extreme results in neonazis digitally harassing Jews" should not be "okay, fine, lock your door at night, free speech is more important than you being harassed".
- mrtksn 5y agoYou get your e-harassment non-anonymously too. If people believe that it’s wrong for you to be subjected to that, those who do this to you will pay for it. Anonymity does have uses but it’s powerful and open to misuse. What we see today on the internet is it’s misuse, mostly.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago...you cannot possibly be seriously decrying anonymity under the handle "mrtksn". If you're going to argue that, you can do it under your real name.
- mrtksn 5y agoI do. I'm not saying do like me, I'm proposing a solution that works only if it is a rule for everybody.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoSo could we please have your real name and home address? Be the change you want to see in the world.
- mrtksn 5y agoSure, as soon as everybody else has theirs in open.