4 ms·
> There's something fundamentally flawed There isn't really. You're adopting, I assume, J.S. Mill's view, that the cure for bad speech is more speech, which he
by crazygringo 5y ago
> There's something fundamentally flawed
There isn't really. You're adopting, I assume, J.S. Mill's view, that the cure for bad speech is more speech, which he famously published in 1859.
However, since then it's been widely accepted that when speech reaches a certain level of harm then the greater good is to prevent/punish it. You can't incite violence under the guise of free speech. You can't advertise that something is safe when it's not. This is because more speech can't undo violence and death after it occurs.
And when it comes to misinformation with regards to provable and intentional lies about voting procedures, election results, etc. that falsely harm the country's institutions and legitimacy, it's entirely consistent for that to fall under the widely-accepted prohibition of speech that rises to a certain threshold of harm. It directly leads to mobs, riots, and revolution based on lies, not based on actual injustices.
This doesn't mean any harmful speech is prohibited -- that's ridiculous. You're generally allowed to insult people, tell lies, etc. But there's a threshold of harm that gets established.
- overgard 5y agoGiving anyone the ability to arbitrate what is "good" speech vs "bad" speech is way too much power. In any era of history there have always been "truths" that were massively popular and eventually overturned. I don't think we are the first era to be an exception. So when you're talking about punishing "bad" speech you are talking about creating super powerful entities just because they agree with you. That intent scares me far more than whatever nonsense you get from q anon or antivaxxers.
- cmckn 5y ago> Giving anyone the ability to arbitrate what is "good" speech vs "bad" speech is way too much power. But that isn't at all what is happening here. Google has decided that they don't want to enable people to distribute certain data using their platform. They're not being crowned the omnipotent oracle of good and bad. > you are talking about creating super powerful entities just because they agree with you. This position is bizarre to me -- what do you think an elected government is? I vote to create "super powerful entities that agree with me" every 4 years. Those entities possess the power to destroy all life on earth. Google is not anywhere near as powerful as those entities, and while it is not (directly) democratically accountable, it does derive its power from its users. No information will be permanently erased just because Google does not spend money and time making it available on Drive.
- nzmsv 5y agoIt's easy to think that the most powerful entity is the one with the biggest stick. Consider this though: imagine a VIP and their bodyguard. The bodyguard is much stronger and carries a gun, but he is not the one with power. The VIP can replace the bodyguard at will. An entity that gets to tell millions exactly how to vote and which nuke-wielding bodyguard to hire is surely more powerful than said bodyguard.
- CRConrad 5y ago> The bodyguard is much stronger and carries a gun, but he is not the one with power. The VIP can replace the bodyguard at will. Tell that to the Gandhis. And several Cæsars.
- overgard 5y agoThe amount of power google has, they can crown the winner. We can't pretend that "oh thats just google's opinion" when they control access to humanities collective knowledge. My argument is very humble. Everyone gets to talk, whoever is most convincing gets listened to most. I don't need a paternalistic company protecting me from bad thoughts. > This position is bizarre to me -- what do you think an elected government is? A system with an intentional freedom to allow dissent?
- Angelore 5y agoThey are not protecting you from bad thoughts. They are protecting themselves from lawsuits. Moderating all this content is not free. If google was not under risk of losing money by not doing this, they would have done nothing.
- CRConrad 5y ago> My argument is very humble. Everyone gets to talk, whoever is most convincing gets listened to most. I don't need a paternalistic company protecting me from bad thoughts. You're talking now, and this isn't (AFAIK) on Google Drive. You want Drive to be a democratically guaranteed national resource, nationalize Google.
- dudeman13 5y ago>Giving anyone the ability to arbitrate what is "good" speech vs "bad" speech is way too much power The government already has that power. See that bit about saying rat poison is medicine or incitement laws. Are you scared that we support such behaviour from the government?
- refurb 5y agoOh please. Those are incredibly narrowly defined. Our republic won’t fall because some drug company can’t lie about a product they are selling. This is a false equivalency - “telling Pfizer they can’t claim their drug cures AIDS is no different than suppressing the Covid lab leak theory”. Yeah, it’s massively different.
- dudeman13 5y agoWat. I'm not arguing for a specific instance of 'has great effects' for judging good/bad speech. Just that the government already has the power to judge good/bad speech - and people are not revolting against that. Why doesn't the government's ability to judge good/bad speech give you the heebie-jeebies, but that specific instance does?
- refurb 5y agoWhat I said, scope.
- overgard 5y agoThe government has an explicit limitation on excersizing that power. The first amendment is, well, first, its not exactly forgettable. The primary law of our land is "government can't fuck around with free speech". I see no ambiguity here. There's a huge difference between shouting fire in a theater vs saying, are the vaccines safe. We can have our disagreements but its in nobody's interest to outlaw them.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The first amendment is, well, first, Well, no, the first article of amendment (usually abbreviated “first amendment”) is the eighth article of the Constitution, following the seven original articles. “Amendment” is revision/change.
- logicchains 5y ago>However, since then it's been widely accepted It's not widely accepted at all, except maybe in the small circle of Silicon Valley elites whose ideas align with yours politically.
- intended 5y agoThere’s a huge chunk of forum managera, BBS admins, moderator who have long since seen this tested empirically. The Silicon Valley elite are dinosaurs who came to this realization too damn late. They, argued about free speech too long. The elite are out of touch. The greatest hold they have on speech isn’t shutting or removing misinformation. The hold they have on society is that the data needed to make these decisions intelligently is behind an NDA. Every scientist who worked on this with data, is employed by These forms. That is where the silence is deafening. And the success of it is that people are still arguing yesterday’s battles while the front has moved away.
- shrimpx 5y agoI don’t know about you, but any social group I’ve been part of has had its boundaries beyond which some speech and behavior becomes unacceptable and has consequences. What kind of social groups are you part of where all speech, including lies, insults, smearing, is accepted?
- logicchains 5y ago>What kind of social groups are you part of where all speech, including lies, insults, smearing, is accepted? What kind of horrible friend group are you part of that believes people should be thrown in jail for telling lies or insulting people?
- Pyramus 5y agoI'm a bit surprised, it's enshrined in both US written and case law? See e.g. [1] for an overview or [2] specifically for hate speech. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exceptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fighting_words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fighting_words
- simonbarker87 5y agoAnnoying that you are getting down voted for what seems to be a very reasonable comment. I have very few friends “in tech” and this is the view that basically all of them hold, this is the view that most of my family hold. Across the 100-150 people that spans the full (European) political spectrum and many different backgrounds and life experiences from growing up extremely wealthy, finding wealth through hard work (and luck) and success and borderline surviving - do not “SV tech circles”. Basically it’s a view point that is able to accept nuance and grey. People who work in absolutes dominate headlines so it’s all we hear, in reality the majourity of people live in the middle.
- imwillofficial 5y ago> u can't incite violence under the guise of free speech. No, you can’t incite violence with speech. Everyone is responsible for the actions they take, even if misinformed.
- shrimpx 5y agoThat’s not a reasonable position. In the limit that implies that you treat everyone as the enemy. Isolate in your own protected world, because you might get duped or harmed any minute now. That to me is a shitty world I don’t want to live in. I’d rather reasonably trust people and have a common baseline and shared narrative.
- imwillofficial 5y agoReasonable or not, this is reality.
- CRConrad 5y agoNo, it's bullshit.
- fighterpilot 5y ago> the greater good is to prevent/punish it. It's clear that a handful of genocides were caused in large part by hate speech, such as the Rwandan genocide and the Holocaust. What's not clear to me (although I'm open either way) is whether strict hate speech laws would've reduced the odds of these happening. Do we have reason to think that to be true? The first order effect is to chill that kind of speech. But is there a second order effect of making these people into martyrs and fostering resentment towards the protected group that does more harm than good? My understanding is that pre-Nazi Germany had hate speech laws, and it didn't seem to work there? https://www.bjpa.org/content/upload/bjpa/4_an/4_Anti-Semitism_September-October_1940.pdf https://www.bjpa.org/content/upload/bjpa/4_an/4_Anti-Semitis...
- daddylongstroke 5y ago>It directly leads to mobs, riots, and revolution based on lies, not based on actual injustices. Would love to see an example. The vast majority of revolutions in human history were results of hunger.
- crazygringo 5y ago...did you not see the Capitol riot/mob on Jan 6?
- daddylongstroke 5y agoHaha! Good one. Definitely not a revolution.
- CRConrad 5y ago>>> mobs, riots, and revolution Two out of three.