4 ms·
I can see the day coming when few people will have general-purpose computers. Those will be the people who make things, and also have a good set of tools and ma
by Animats 5y ago
I can see the day coming when few people will have general-purpose computers. Those will be the people who make things, and also have a good set of tools and maybe a milling machine.
This has already happened with phones and tablets, after all. And Chromebooks. And Windows 365. And Windows S. And locked-down enterprise machines.
- pdonis 5y ago> Those will be the people who make things Which includes programmers.
- dane-pgp 5y agoAs long as you have paid for your annual "software development licence" from the government, and they haven't revoked it after finding you breaking "best practices" like producing or using encryption software without a government backdoor.
- pdonis 5y agoI am a programmer, and I have had no such problems.
- username90 5y agoWe are talking about the future here. Restrictions on our freedom will be added until it is no longer profitable or until people start to protest. And so far it has been immensely profitable and among the general public basically nobody complains, so more restrictions will likely continue to be added for a really long time.
- retrac 5y agoThere are subscription-only development studios and toolchains. (Always have been, really.) If there is a new platform where this is the only kind of thing we can run on a walled garden device, then I'm not sure quite how general purpose you could call such a device.
- pdonis 5y ago> There are subscription-only development studios and toolchains. (Always have been, really.) Yes, but nobody has to program on them. FOSS is a thing.
- dane-pgp 5y agoIf your FOSS-developed app wants to open a network socket to an IP address that isn't on the government whitelist, then the OS will perform an OSCP check to ensure the (hash of the) binary has been recorded, along with the identity of its developer, in a corporate or government-run database.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoI hope the software that blocks us from using computers doesn't block enough people to where there are no more programmers.
- Filligree 5y agoI don't know anyone who got into programming who didn't do it on a computer they had for other reasons. Nobody buys their kid a $2000 device just in case they might want to be a programmer, especially since the kid isn't going to play with that device -- there won't be any games for it. No, it's always a side-effect of using GPCs for other things. Even, or really, especially when it's inconvenient. Anecdotally, it is indeed getting harder to hire good people. I don't know that we've reached 'peak programmer', but the count isn't growing as fast as it used to.
- stan_rogers 5y agoYour "nobody" scenario is basically the whole beginning of the personal computing era. "Useless" machines that cost a fortune, had no available software (to within statistical error) and booted to BASIC. Without that era, we wouldn't have this one.
- ur-whale 5y agoI can see the day coming when owning and operating one of those will require the equivalent of a carry permit. And just like for weapons, none of the iphone and chromebook users will understand what the fuss is all about, who would want to use one of these anyways.
- user-the-name 5y agoAnd is there really anything wrong with that? Every house doesn't need a milling machine. Why should every house need a general purpose computer?
- HideousKojima 5y agoIf every house had a 3d printer, or a milling machine, or a small chip fab, or insert home manufacturing machine here, they would be far less dependent on a handful of established players for things like replacement parts etc. And much more immune against government regulation seeking to control thme and what they can buy/own/do.
- user-the-name 5y agoThey don't want to be. And that's fine. That is why we even have a society. We can live better lives by relying on others.
- giantrobot 5y agoA 3D printer, chip fab, or CNC mill isn't useful without feedstock, designs/models, and electricity. So even if every household had a bunch of micro-fabrication devices the government could still regulate whatever they pleased by regulating access between your property and the outside world. If everyone had a 3D printer and was manufacturing things the government didn't like then PLA/ABS/resin would quickly become regulated.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoNot to mention the "printing cartridge model" that some manufacturers are already trying to play at. Unfortunately this is inevitable as the 3D printing industry is getting more commoditised.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hytdstd 5y agoYes, you're absolutely right. So what do you think is stopping every household from buying a 3d printer/mill/whatever?
- nonameiguess 5y agoI'm really not sure I see this. Enterprise devices are more portable than they used to be, not less. Gone are the days of science relying almost exclusively on supercomputers that could only run specific proprietary Unixes and basically required proprietary compilers. Connection hubs and DSPs doing signal translation from various industrial devices and military and space communications networks to IP networks have gone from almost exclusively ASICs manufactured by one of two companies to FPGAs, fully reprogrammable blank slates you can do pretty much anything with. Phones and tablets are certainly less general purpose than desktop and laptop PCs, but much more general purpose than earlier incarnations of phones and tablet-like devices such as Palm Pilots, digital address books, graphing calculators, flip phones, land lines, things that could only do one thing and couldn't have any type of extension application installed at all from anyone, whether it was part of a walled garden or not. If the average American teenager today has nothing but an iPad and iPhone, that isn't completely general purpose, but it's a huge improvement on when I was a teenager 25 years ago and the closest thing my family had to a computer at all was a word processor, not a software suite like Word or Lotus but a specialized typewriter with some proprietary embedded firmware and no writable memory at all.
- wallacoloo 5y agoYou make good points: the barriers to entry have dramatically decreased across a huge portion of the stack. With one notable exception: the cost and complexity of modern fabs increases every year while the companies involved consolidate or die out. tsmc could easily decide “we’re not gonna fab your RISC-V design” at any moment and you’d be more or less SOL. I mean, you could fall back to a 150 nm process, but that kills a lot of opportunities. And if things continue — if Apple, Amazon and Google move further in the direction of custom silicon — this will happen. Apple already has a pretty big advantage with their custom silicon — which they don’t sell for use in non-Apple products. Now just imagine if they brought tsmc in-house and had exclusive access to the most advanced fabs on the planet. Your ability to compete, and the room for people to build GPC would constrict MUCH further. We have this enormous, all-pervasive stack built upon a foundation of like 3 companies, in the midst of massive consolidation. I honestly don’t understand how so many people who think about that are comfortable with it.
- rektide 5y ago> Those will be the people who make things, and also have a good set of tools and maybe a milling machine. One of the chief things I hope that home-cloud operators get to, quickly, is multi-tenancy. Given how easy it is to take some Raspberry Pi's & build a home Kubernetes cluster (or to spend $1000 & build a radically better version), the next question is: how do we scale that impact? I'd love for my work to scale to my friends! I used to spend so long trying to build ldap into the ftp, http, xmpp, &c self-hosted systems I made, thinking one day it might help friends too. And I still think that way, but now that vision is less about building super-tip-top services to serve everyone, and more about building a platform that my friends could run their own services on easily, in a reasonable way. #selfhosted, I hope, begins to federalize somewhat, that we can selfhost each other, via some common, well known platforms that support these endeavours to help us build together. Personally I like to imagine grade school having a half dozen servers, and kids getting their own virtual clusters to operate as they might, to learn about & immerse themselves in computing. This kind of feels like a maker-space sort of idea: a collectively owned means of production, an availability of tools that is community owned & operated. Ideally in my school server model, the kids themselves get the experience (at some point) of bootstrapping their own clusters, get the end to end experience (take one machine out, format the drive, compile a linux kernel, install os, install cluster/platform software, join another hardware unit to it). Similar to a rep-rap producing another one, sort of; creating the chain of knowledge to reproduce & understand. There's plenty of semi-interesting existing examples to cite with regard to collective hosting: the SDF cluster, tilde.club, &c. I guess I hope that we can virtualize a little more, give more people something closer to their own sovereign little spaces on computing hardware, where-as historically these have been operated more akin to singular shared spaces.