5 ms·
The "bitcoin is not money" argument seems unlikely to work. There are people selling things for bitcoin. Not universally, but enough places that I don't see a c
by jfengel 5y ago
The "bitcoin is not money" argument seems unlikely to work. There are people selling things for bitcoin. Not universally, but enough places that I don't see a court accepting the argument that it doesn't act like money.
The "selling bitcoin is not transmitting money" seems more likely to me, at least as long as the sums are small. If they're selling more than $10k worth of bitcoin then it sounds like they're engaging in banking, if not money transmitting.
But if they're selling a lot of bitcoins, they know perfectly well that it's a mechanism for moving money around. The fact that they don't know the destination doesn't make it not money laundering. If people are bringing large sums of money to some dipsticks rather than buying it on the open market, they're almost certainly trying to avoid visibility.
- skeeter2020 5y agoThis defense seems doomed as money != a specific government-issued currency. IANAL but I suspect this is determined by an instrument serving enough of the underlying functions of currencies, which BC most certainly does. Also, effective money laundering OFTEN involves the facilitators NOT knowing the nodes in the graph; that's what makes it effective in the first place.
- Turing_Machine 5y ago> This defense seems doomed as money != a specific government-issued currency. According to the statute in question (and also the Uniform Commercial Code), it is. The statute reads, in part, "Money,” in its common use, is some kind of financial instrument or medium of exchange that is assessed value, made uniform, regulated, and protected by sovereign power." Also: ... the Uniform Commercial Code defines money as “a medium of exchange *currently authorized or adopted by a domestic or foreign government...” I think they have a good argument. While Bitcoin is certainly "money-like", it does not appear to fit the U.S. government's current definition of "money".
- SomewhatLikely 5y agoFWIW El Salvador now accepts Bitcoin as legal tender.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoSupposedly. The rollout is a clown show. https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/07/11/el-salvador-bitcoin-bukele-scrambles-to-get-something-anything-into-place-by-7-september/ https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/07/11/el-salvador-...
- psychlops 5y agoI don't think it's a bad argument. The UCC defines money as something that has a government attached to it. If people treated leaves like money for simulated drug sales, it shouldn't get them jail time. "Money" means a medium of exchange currently authorized or adopted by a domestic or foreign government. The term includes a monetary unit of account established by an intergovernmental organization or by agreement between two or more countries. https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/1/1-201 https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/1/1-201
- luma 5y agoI have no idea if you're right, but the defendant appears to think you are wrong and that Bitcoin is in fact money, and he publically said as much back in 2017: https://i.imgur.com/7gP31ks.png https://i.imgur.com/7gP31ks.png This motion to dismiss is going to be pretty hard for him to defend.
- jbverschoor 5y agoIt nowhere says that it’s money
- bawolff 5y agoThe defendants personal opinions dont really seem relavent to the question of if its money in the eyes of the court.
- SturgeonsLaw 5y ago> Bitcoins are completely different [to dollars] Seems that post is actually saying the opposite
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OldHand2018 5y agoIf "bitcoin is not money" then you are opening a can of worms that nobody wants opened. Especially if you treat it like personal property as the linked document prefers. Wash sale rules probably start to apply. You're going to need to charge sales tax and get a business license from your local city just to trade on Coinbase, etc. No thanks. Each dollar bill or Euro or Yuan, etc, has a serial number. That means you can lay claim to an exact bill, just like with Bitcoin. But we call money fungible because we don't actually care which dollar bill it is we are holding. They are all the same from a value standpoint.
- DennisP 5y agoThe IRS already treats bitcoin as personal property.
- arcticbull 5y agoIndeed, I think the wash sale rule only applies to stock, options and securities. It's their commodity treatment that allows you to avoid wash sales. Commodities futures for instance do not trigger wash sales. [1] [1] http://www.bairdfinancialadvisor.com/brennanjandricgroup/mediahandler/media/875/Wash%20Sale%20Recap.pdf http://www.bairdfinancialadvisor.com/brennanjandricgroup/med...
- OldHand2018 5y agoWould you like the state of California to take that position? How many Bitcoin sales have you done so far this year? Do you have a seller's permit? > OCCASIONAL SALES—A sale by (and purchase from) a person who is not engaged in a business requiring a seller’s permit is exempt from sales and use taxes. These types of sales are “occasional” sales (some states have similar exemptions for “casual” sales). Generally, a person who makes three or more sales for substantial amounts in any period of 12 months is required to hold a seller’s permit. A person who makes a substantial number of sales for relatively small amounts is also required to hold a seller’s permit. (The 12 month test period can be the 12 months before the sale in question, the 12 months after the sale in question, or any other 12 month period in which the sale occurs.) A person holding two garage sales with no other sales in any 12 month period in which the garage sales are held are regarded as making exempt occasional sales. A business that is not required to hold a seller’s permit would be making an occasional sale when making a single sale of its assets upon termination of its business. Such persons should be aware that making two or three sales in anticipation of final liquidation will generally result in all the sales being subject to sales tax. https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub61.pdf https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub61.pdf
- bawolff 5y agoI think bitcoin is money, but "There are people selling things for bitcoin" is a silly argument. People barter all the time with non-money things.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]