4 ms·
No. That appeal to some notion of free speech is bunk. They can “stay neutral” by limiting the ability to share widely. Free speech doesn’t mean that you are e
by Spooky23 5y ago
No. That appeal to some notion of free speech is bunk.
They can “stay neutral” by limiting the ability to share widely. Free speech doesn’t mean that you are entitled to a billboard, radio station, or global content delivery network.
By aligning global distribution with easy content marketing, Google, Facebook, etc created a monstrosity that encourages the worst content and systematically evicerates high quality content.
That fundamental lack of understanding by naive engineers drives a lot of the problems we have.
- nomoreplease 5y agoThere was no appeal to free speech. You’re creating a straw man
- zepto 5y ago> Free speech doesn’t mean that you are entitled to a billboard, radio station, or global content delivery network. What has any of this got to do with Google Drive?
- shadowgovt 5y agoGoogle Drive is a global content delivery network. A document flagged as "Share with link" is reliably hosted worldwide.
- zepto 5y ago> Google Drive is a global content delivery network. No it isn’t. > A document flagged as "Share with link" is reliably hosted worldwide. Just like any other piece of content online. Are you saying all online content should be subject to censorship just because it can be accessed worldwide?
- shadowgovt 5y ago> No it isn’t. I'm afraid I don't follow. In what way does it differ? > Are you saying all online content should be subject to censorship just because it can be accessed worldwide? I'm saying no CDN is obligated to vend content in violation of its TOS. Content available at drive.google.com is quite different from content hosted at your-site.com: you control the content at the latter. It's your TOS to enforce there.
- zepto 5y agoIt’s not a CDN by the widely accepted definition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_delivery_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_delivery_network > I'm saying no CDN is obligated to vend content in violation of its TOS. Of course private businesses can choose the terms they operate under. It’s Google’s choices that people are criticizing. Pretending Google Drive is like a billboard is dishonest. We are talking about a file sharing service used for collaboration by individuals and businesses. It’s Orwellian for the content of such a service to be monitored. It would be like AT&T disconnecting calls if certain topics were discussed.
- shadowgovt 5y ago"A content delivery network, or content distribution network (CDN), is a geographically distributed network of proxy servers and their data centers. The goal is to provide high availability and performance by distributing the service spatially relative to end users." That accurately describes Drive's infrastructure. It has additional bidirectional support, but seamlessly transitions to unidirectional distributed broadcast if many people connect to the same file. > We're talking about a file sharing service used for collaboration That's one way to use it. Another way is to cheaply host content and then post the link to Facebook or Twitter. It seems Google is reserving the right to not support that use case. > It would be like AT&T disconnecting calls Private calls are a different model from a public & shared link. It's a bit more more like a television station cutting a live broadcast if the person on screen starts sweating a blue streak. Though that analogy is also not perfect... Hosted publicly-accessible documents are kind of their own thing. It's not regulated as a common carrier and it's also not a newspaper.
- zepto 5y ago> That accurately describes Drive's infrastructure. It accurately describes a piece of infrastructure that many (if not most major) services including drive use. It does not describe drive, but it’s a moot point since there is nothing relevant about calling drive a CDN. > Private calls are a different model from a public & shared link. Not at all. There is nothing stopping a phone call being made to a radio station, or placed on speaker to an audience of multiple people. This is analogous to the use case of posting a link to Twitter or a Facebook group.