10 ms·
I don't believe the blurred images at the end have anything to do with eye focus, as the author suggests. After all, chromatic aberration is blurring of only a
by crazygringo 5y ago
I don't believe the blurred images at the end have anything to do with eye focus, as the author suggests.
After all, chromatic aberration is blurring of only a very, very small amount.
The demonstrated seemingly negligible perceptual effect of blurring blue to a huge degree in a multicolor image doesn't seem to have anything to do with that, but rather the fact that we perceive primary blue as a much darker color than primary red or green, and we perceive differences in lighter colors much more easily.
If the author were correct that we have big problems focusing on blue, then we'd see that blue text against a black background would be massively blurry -- but it's simply not. It's comparatively low-contrast (because blue is a dark color), but it's nearly indistinguishably as sharp as red and green.
- phnofive 5y agoI agree, in that it was pretty easy to dismiss effects on the example image. Doing this with shapes and a variety of hues and luminances would be a better way to prove the point if it bears out.
- isatty 5y agoI think that the title is a massive oversimplification because chromatic aberration by itself is not enough for us to be blind to the color blue. We do have cones that can detect blue for one. We are however, less sensitive to it so maybe the eye doesn't focus based on that channel(?).
- formerly_proven 5y agoI wanna point out that LCA cannot be responsible for e.g. blue displays being basically impossible to read. Why? Because they are still impossible to read when they're the only thing that's around, and blue LEDs are very monochromatic. So the eye would have to focus on the blue light, which would make LCA go away. I suspect that a plausible cause could be that there just aren't a lot of blue receptors in the retina, as the eye is pretty insensitive to blue overall.
- crdrost 5y agoI'm not sure you're right. At night both I and my wife have reported difficulty reading glowing blue signs compared to glowing red/green signs at the same font size, brightness, and distance. I'm also not sure that the author is correct; the wrong-focal-distance explanation seems rather weak simply because our focal length is adjustable.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoYou have astigmatism. I have a similar issue with blue when not wearing my glasses. I have 20/20 vision, but my astigmatism makes it difficult to focus on certain things. A computer being a big one. Blue light blockers help, but with proper astigmatism correction I don’t need them.
- techrat 5y ago20/10 vision in one eye, 20/13 in another, no astigmatism. Blue LEDs in clocks when viewed at night look completely fucked up.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoI’ve never met anyone without some astigmatism; especially, people with other vision impairment. Astigmatism is the number one cause of night blindness which is what you described.
- nickff 5y agoI mostly agree with you, but would add that blurring the blue is affecting the sharpness of the ocean, which has little detail in that image; blurring red or green affects details on the land, which are very noticeable. One might think the cloud-ocean edges would be blurred by the blurring of blue, but the clouds are so much brighter than the ocean (red & green channels), that you can barely notice any difference.
- mrob 5y agoSee the very low coefficients for the blue channel when converting (gamma-compressed) RGB to luma. E.g. the common Rec. 709 standard assigns only 0.0722 weight to blue. Y' = 0.2126R' + 0.7152G' + 0.0722B'
- codetrotter 5y agoDid you mean to respond to another comment in this thread where they were talking about YUV? Your comment does not make much sense to me here but would make more sense to me there.
- mrob 5y agoLuma is an approximation of perceived brightness. All the conversion formulae weigh blue substantially less than the other primaries. This supports crazygringo's assertion that "we perceive primary blue as a much darker color than primary red or green".
- anamexis 5y agoIt makes sense to me here - GP discusses how we see perceive blue as a dark color, and parent comment corroborates that with a low luma coefficient for blue.
- bioplastic 5y agoIndeed, green contributes more. Example of the Y channel after blurring r/g/b: https://imgur.com/a/3p15Qe1 https://imgur.com/a/3p15Qe1 And colured versions: https://imgur.com/a/Knq2Ue3 https://imgur.com/a/Knq2Ue3 (image source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flower#/media/File:Flower_poster_2.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flower#/media/File:Flower_post...)
- rob74 5y agoMore, as in 10 times more for green, and 3 times more for red. So it's true that we're pretty blind to blue, just the "focusing" explanation is not correct...
- gisely 5y agoChromatic aberration may be a contributing factor, but I am surprised the author didn’t mention that S cones (which we use to perceive blue) are only 2% of the cones in the retina [1]. Additionally S cones are distributed randomly when compared the regular lattice of M and L cones. The distribution of the different cone types alone may be sufficient to explain why our acuity for blues is impoverished relative to reds and greens. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cone_cell https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cone_cell
- larsbrinkhoff 5y agoAlso, S cones are mostly found outside the fovea.
- arthur2e5 5y agoThis lower resolution of blue is pretty well known in recent image compression work (XYB space of JPEG-XL and guetzil), and number of S cones is the only explanation I have seen on that.
- thehappypm 5y agoI'm sure you could find an image where blurring blue ruins it, and blurring red and green have no impact. This feels like cherrypicking especially given how trivial it would be to just show a bunch of examples.
- jcoq 5y agoI agree. Further, almost all of the blue channel in this image is from the white clouds or nearly black water. There's no other major source of blue.
- mtdewcmu 5y agoWhat would be the result if you flipped the colors, so that the sharp elements are blue and the ocean is red or green?
- jcoq 5y agoThat's an interesting thought but unfortunately I'm travelling. One thing is that the ocean is hardly blue. Not sure why my eyes register it as such, but it's mostly very close to black with nearly equal parts of red and green, at least the parts I sampled. I think a certain amount of this article's claim is predicated on the reader erroneously believing the ocean should become blurry.
- gcanyon 5y agoI’d love to see the same comparison across a range of images.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThe author is correct. Lighting designers sometimes use the effect deliberately to create blue spotlights that viewers can't focus on. That description doesn't do it justice - you have to experience it to appreciate it. It's very striking and slightly surreal.
- tobr 5y agoThey might be correct about chromatic aberration and the difficultly of focusing on pure blue, but the conclusion from their experiment is completely wrong.
- rst 5y agoIt also matters a bit that the blue channel is only 2% of all color-sensitive cones in the retina. That has a lot more to do with poor spatial resolution int the blue channel than the optics. http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/vision/rodcone.html http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/vision/rodcone.ht...
- sgtnoodle 5y agoI dunno, but when I look at glowing blue signs and blue Christmas lights at night, they look significantly more fuzzy than other color lights.
- usefulcat 5y agoAlso the blue LED on a PS3. Those always looked blurry to me. It’s especially obvious because of the adjacent green LED.
- farbissina 5y agoYou are so right! I always assumed it was the LED's problem until I started reading all these comments. I think I remember the PS2 having the same thing.
- Wistar 5y agoYes! I have difficulty with some blue signage and especially with certain intense blue LED lights as they seem to vibrate to my eyes. I also find it hard for me to read the text in blue on the small, scrolling LED signs common in storefronts.
- dalmo3 5y ago> At long last, we can see why the human eye can't focus on blue light At long last indeed. For decades I wondered why blue lights are disturbingly blurry at night, to the point I'd rather not look at them. I always thought it was just me since other people didn't seem to care as much.
- glenngillen 5y agoI’ve found my people! I have similar issues and nobody I’ve ever spoken to about it seems to have the same experience. Two similar issues I’ve had, and I’ve wondered if they’re related, are: - at conferences with very large overhead projection sometimes the setup produces an effect where each time I blink it’s like it separates the RGB elements. It’s like a combination of being able to see the refresh rate (like when a CRT was filmed out of sync) and the colours being projected out of alignment. - a stadium near me as those digital display advertising signs around the sidelines. If I’m not looking directly at them they appear to flicker. Which actually makes watching a game at that venue not enjoyable as watching the action means I have a permanent shimmering right on the periphery. Does anybody know what’s happening with either of these?
- bacan 5y agoThis article is false. Tried this out Photoshop and not even close. Here are my results, with a 22px Gaussian Blur on the Channels https://imgur.com/a/AS0LAyk https://imgur.com/a/AS0LAyk IMO The only reason the blue appears a little less blurry is that most of that color is in the water & clouds. Not in the land masses, with the sharp borders
- GuB-42 5y agoRight, I picked the "blurred blue" and "blurred green" pictures, converted them to grayscale using luminance and "blurred blue" still looks sharp and "blurred green" still looks blurry. If it really was the effect of blue light, the effect should have disappeared by converting to grayscale. It is well known that luminance matters much more than color when it comes to perceived sharpness. Digital and analog video exploit that by encoding color at a lower resolution (chroma subsampling). And blue only accounts for less that 10% of luminance while green is around 70%. You may find different values because color spaces are a mess but that's the general idea.
- Retric 5y agoThat’s not an apples to apples test because of how greyscale is computed. Try swapping the blue and green channels rather than converting to greyscale.
- skupig 5y agoI think for a proper comparison, you would need to swap them by perceived brightness (luminance), not just the RGB value. You can't do that here because the green channel in this image is out of the possible range of luminance you can achieve with blue (in any standard color space, probably). Which really illustrates why TFA doesn't make any sense- our eyes are less sensitive to blue, so the contrast provided by max RGB value blue is going to be completely drowned out by red and green if the source of your contrast is white on black. Here's what it looks like with all channels shifted to have the same luminance: https://i.imgur.com/AnKNdfX.jpg https://i.imgur.com/AnKNdfX.jpg - note it is perhaps a little softer as the peak brightness is closer to black. Now here's what each channel looks like blurred by 2.5px: https://i.imgur.com/XzVWeZg.jpg https://i.imgur.com/XzVWeZg.jpg https://i.imgur.com/LB5JArJ.jpg https://i.imgur.com/LB5JArJ.jpg https://i.imgur.com/jf4ntth.jpg https://i.imgur.com/jf4ntth.jpg They're all clearly fuzzy in comparison to the un-blurred image. The answer to "why we're blind to the color blue" is not chromatic aberration (although it could be a contributing factor, maybe even why we have less blue receptors), it's that we're less sensitive to blue and therefore contrast is usually defined by red and green.
- tigershark 5y agoExactly. In the real life I find very difficult to focus on violet signs against the black night background, but it’s a completely different effect from the one in this article and it’s exacerbated by the bigger pupil diameter in the night that increases the aberration.
- stkdump 5y agoMaybe the (evolutional) reason that we perceive blue as darker is exactly that it would otherwise reduce the sharpness of what we see.
- ddingus 5y agoIt has a whole lot to do with our eyes having far fewer blue receptors.