2 ms·
This is my theory. You look at human civilization and that's exactly what's happened. We started off by broadcasting everything as loud as we could (which isn
by cogman10 5y ago
This is my theory.
You look at human civilization and that's exactly what's happened. We started off by broadcasting everything as loud as we could (which isn't very loud) and we've slowly transitioned to signals that are both quieter and don't really survive escaping the atmosphere.
I can't imagine an advanced species wouldn't follow a similar communications path. The only way we detect them is if they specifically target our spot in the sky with focused EM for a very long time, generations! After all, they have no clue when we would be in our evolutionary path.
And for that to happen, the species would have to first find us. Not just find us, find us while we are still listening.
And this is all with the assumption that FTL communication/observation is even a possibility (It likely isn't).
IMO, the simplest answer is that FTL communication and travel is impossible. Advanced civilizations across the galaxy have all come to the same conclusion.
We might be able to explore our own neighboring stars throughout generations but it's unlikely we'll be able to ever send a message to another civilization that will get there while they are listening (without spending huge amounts of power).
- xwolfi 5y agoBut if you pursue an evolution over millions of years, at some point we'll have to miniaturise. Imagine we can make fully conscious silicon - let's say in 200 000 years (6500 human generations). At this point, we'd be tempted little by little to raise them as our intellectual children and find less and less need to make them with sperm and vagina. After a long while, there might be this great replacement, totally peaceful, that would lead these conscious organisms with a vastly superior intellectual efficiency to probably become very small and self centered and not behave like the territorial monkeys we are. What do you think a massively singular electronic intelligence will think when it notices a planet like ours ? "nuke them all and rape their women" ? This is monkey behavior that we still haven't fully shaken up.