6 ms·
"People we don't agree with, often representing views we don't like, often get into power! Democracy has failed us" And yet the logical conclusion never seems
by roenxi 5y ago
"People we don't agree with, often representing views we don't like, often get into power! Democracy has failed us"
And yet the logical conclusion never seems to be embracing a small limited government. The power base keeps expanding then everyone gets surprised when their side loses an election.
- mrfusion 5y agoAlso people can’t simply disagree anymore. The other side is just wrong or labeled some kind of denier or conspiracy theorist.
- BobbyJo 5y agoAssumption of good intentions has gone out the window. All I see on Reddit is 'so and so is evil!' and 'they want to punish the poor!'. It's impossible to make the case anymore that all sides want to improve everyone's lives and they simply disagree on the method.
- hanniabu 5y agoIn all fairness, there's a lot of system things in the US that's hostile against the poor
- BobbyJo 5y agoNeeding to trade resources for other resources is inherently hostile toward people with fewer resources. Even so, we can all acknowledge that the intent of such a system is to create a fair and prosperous society.
- mahogany 5y agoWhat I'm curious about is: when or how often has this sort of divide happened before? I'm wondering if this is a periodic phenomenon in the US. And if/when this has happened before -- what fixed this level of hostility?
- mrfusion 5y agoI’m under the impression the media (and social media) caused it but I’m open to other ideas.
- jhbadger 5y agoIn the time leading up to the Civil War, literal physical fights would break out between Northern and Southern members of Congress. We haven't gotten quite to that point..yet.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI only know of that happening one time. Were there others?
- verdverm 5y agoApril 12, 1861 – April 9, 1865
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWell, it at least happened before the Civil War. It ended when one side got stomped down militarily so hard that it could no longer fight back. Other than that... has it happened to this degree before? I'm not sure that it has.
- at_a_remove 5y agoI was baffled by the reaction to the Brexit vote. The people who lost seemed just ... miffed that somehow everyone else had "voted wrong." Who are all of these people, going around, voting wrong? It wasn't supposed to be like this! We were supposed to win! Anything with a vote means that someone is going to be unhappy with the results afterward. That's how it works.
- pan69 5y agoWhen the voting system is that binary, yes.
- TMWNN 5y ago>I was baffled by the reaction to the Brexit vote. The people who lost seemed just ... miffed that somehow everyone else had "voted wrong." Who are all of these people, going around, voting wrong? It wasn't supposed to be like this! We were supposed to win! The weeping and wailing began the night of the referendum. By the next morning we were confidently told by the press, Reddit, and Twitter that millions of Leave voters were already regretting their vote, and that another referendum was thus the only fair/democratic/correct thing to do. (That even if such millions of Regretters actually existed that does not mean that a revote would occur is a minor technicality.) People also forget how anger on Leavers' part against delay on Brexit did not become significant until 2019. The Supreme Court agreed that there was reasonable basis for the Miller case, and (more controversially) unexpectedly ruled for her in the second Miller case. But Leavers understandably came to see both lawsuits as part and parcel of an unrelenting attempt on Remainers' part to stop Brexit by any and all means, whether legitimate or not. The fact that Miller actively campaigned for revoking Article 50 didn't help the Remain cause, and discredited her claim during the first case that she wanted to protect parliamentary sovereignty. It's pretty clear in retrospect that what drove the Labour collapse in 2019 (In some Red Wall seats—seats that Labour had held with massive majorities for 50-100 years—the Tories didn't have to gain a single vote to win) is both Labour Leavers unhappy about their party not continuing its 2017 acceptance of Brexit coming, and Remainers who disliked the idea (whether explicit among Lib Dems, or implicit among much of Labour) of ignoring a democratic vote in 2016. That's why another referendum was so unpopular, because no one believes that it would not be rigged against Leave.[1] Those who in other circumstances might have supported a "People's Vote" didn't, because they saw it as yet another attempt to delay and prevent Brexit via Neverendums. I think Leave would have won another referendum conducted under the circumstances of the first one, but Leavers understandably didn't trust the People's Vote folks to implement another referendum in any way that Leave can again win. Not after 3.5 years and counting of shenanigans such as the Miller case. [1] Even supporters of same, no matter what they said. That's why they were for it.
- tablespoon 5y ago> "People we don't agree with, often representing views we don't like, often get into power! Democracy has failed us" > And yet the logical conclusion never seems to be embracing a small limited government. Come on. A big chunk of the disagreement itself is about the desirability of a "small limited government," so you're basically saying that when there's political disagreement, people should solve it by giving up and just adopting your politics. That's not a "logical conclusion."
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoIt is when the disagreement can be eliminated by reducing a vote's consequences.
- tablespoon 5y ago> It is when the disagreement can be eliminated by reducing a vote's consequences. But that "solution" fails to understand the crux of the disagreement, so it doesn't solve it at all. It's like trying to solve a disagreement over tax rates by abolishing private property.