8 ms·
US democracy: The threat in 2024 is 'completely uncharted territory'
- arisAlexis 5y agoThe majority of the comments here are flagged. Either flag this thread or let the discussion go on. Otherwise it's a super censored way of communicating.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoThe threat is already very real now and anyone who claims it's a partisan issue exclusive to one party is part of the problem. They're dismantling free speech rights, that's arguably even more dangerous than anything Trump has done. First they came for your right to free expression, and I did not speak out because I couldn't anymore. The end.
- cool_dude85 5y agoSorry, how are "they" dismantling free speech rights in the US?
- weimerica 5y agoPrivate corporations spend the last decade+ consolidating communications, then the USG works with those corporations to censor anything they deem "problematic?" Really, that falls into a textbook fascist definition. Consider that virtually every other mass-communication medium CAN'T do what the social firms are getting away with currently, rather than cheer on your "right side of history" allies.
- crisdux 5y agoOkay, I'll bite. Free speech is a legal doctrine and an aspect of culture that America has traditionally valued. Few examples below. * The Biden administration is working with technology companies to flag users and posts for removal. * Journalists and whistleblowers are being censored, monitored and even jailed. * More Americans than ever say they cannot speak their mind or they risk losing their livelihoods. * The public isn't allowed to have reasonable discussions on scientific research or theory if it is counter to the prevailing narrative or they risk being censored and removed from platforms. See ivermectin and lab leak. * Our biggest newspapers cannot report on majority held beliefs and perspectives without retribution from activists. * Our institutions are referring to books they don't like as "violence." * Our nation's intelligence agencies have embedded agents into our corporate news media that works as efficient propogandists. Disinformation sourced from these agencies is disseminated through these channels, reported as facts, and then used as a cudgel to silence and censor critics.
- BatFastard 5y ago>The Biden administration is working with technology companies to flag users and posts for removal. Is the spreading of misinformation "free speech". I agree people have the right to have different opinions, but when those opinion have been proven to be false, do you give up the right to spread it? A bit of a slippery slope. >Journalists and whistleblowers are being censored, monitored and even jailed. Journalists have been censored for the past 200 years. I see it getting better under the Biden admin, not worse. Whistleblowers were a particular problem for the Trump admin, not so much Biden admin. >Our biggest newspapers cannot report on majority held beliefs and perspectives without retribution from activists. Our institutions are referring to books they don't like as "violence." Any proof on this? Last one is just crazy.
- crisdux 5y agoAmong all the posts Facebook is saying is "misinformation", which I agree some of it is, they are removing legitimate claims from users that they are being harmed by vaccines. This isn't misinformation. Whistleblowers had a field day under Trump. Under Biden journalists are again being caught up in NSA surveillance, likely being illegally unmasked and then leaked to other members of the media. See Tucker Carlson. honestly, this isn't even about tucker. It's very likely illegal. These people are emboldened. Nothing ever happens to them. The American Booksellers Association yesterday referred to their promotion of an "anti-trans" book as violence. I think the last one is pretty easy to defend. Glen Greenwald documents this pretty extensively. All of our corporate media employ folks who previous worked for NSA, CIA, FBI, etc. They literally put them on TV with a moniker "Previous CIA Agent", etc. These people serve the purpose as "experts" and commonly report information from "anonymous sources" within the agencies. Their purpose is to effect public opinion. Recently see Russiagate, Boutygate, Hunter Biden laptop. The Iraq war and Vietnam War deployed these tactics too. We know for a fact that the CIA lied to us during the Iraq war. And they deployed these tactics. How is this crazy? The New York Times has reported on this relationship between intelligence agencies and the media extensively in the past. It was scandal in the 70s! This stuff is still alive and well.
- throwaway6734 5y agoYes they are trying to dismantle free speech rights by forcing private companies to provide platforms to publish content they do not want to. There's a reasonable threat in 24 that if the election is close state legislatures will override the will of the people and submit a different set of electoral votes. This was attempted in 2020 but thankfully failed. Edit: 2016->2020
- selimthegrim 5y agoWho attempted this? Biden shot down Pramila Jayapal objecting to the certification then.
- throwaway6734 5y agoThe former president pressured the vice president not to certify election results, members of the house voted not to certify election results, the former president reached out to state legislatures to get them to override the public vote, the former president prematurely declared electoral victory, and the former president still has not conceded electoral defeat
- selimthegrim 5y agoYou said 2016, not 2020.
- throwaway6734 5y agoApologies, I meant 2020. will edit nkwt
- weimerica 5y ago> Yes they are trying to dismantle free speech rights by forcing private companies to provide platforms to publish content they do not want to. Communications carriers providing content-neutral service? Thank God the post office, USPS, FedEx, phone, fax, ISP, cell-phone, sat-phone, and handheld radio companies have the freedom to engage in partisan political censorship as they please. It would be a tyranny on those poor corporations were it not the case. Oh won't someone think of the shareholders!
- readflaggedcomm 5y ago>Democrats sort of gasped and said, ‘They can’t do that.’ And then they realized there was absolutely nothing they could do about it. Because it's within the Senate's power, as he notes. Calling it "theft" is disingenuous. Using it as a pattern for future "theft" is especially strange when presidential elections have already been decided in the House.
- pfisch 5y agoThere is no time when the outcome of a presidential election was set aside based on "fraud" with no meaningful evidence of fraud. An event like that would most likely shatter the country and probably end democracy.
- pc86 5y agoIf you're going to make comments like "end democracy," which is pretty inflammatory and hyperbolic, you should probably have an example or two of what you think will happen that will truly end American democracy?
- chrchang523 5y agoIt is worth noting here that the 1876 election was substantially worse than recent events, and US democracy survived that.
- pfisch 5y agoBut in that election there was very clear evidence of fraud, and a compromise was reached.
- pfisch 5y agoIn that event I think many states and congress would've refused to recognize the executive branch and from there things would've quickly spun out of control.
- readflaggedcomm 5y ago
- dominicjj 5y agoThe US isn't a democracy of course. By design. Who's writing this? Ah, yes. Every single time.
- codingwageslave 5y agoYup...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- seneca 5y agoA Republic can be a form of Democracy. There are types of Democracy other than direct.
- manishsharan 5y agoI always thought that Replublic and Democracy are orthogonal concepts. A nation could be a Monarchy and a Democracy while another one could be a Republic and Fascist state. Please note that I am not an expert on this subject. However I have frequently observed Americans commenting on this forum and on Reddit that America is a republic but not a democracy. This confuses me so much. edit: typos
- seneca 5y ago> I always thought that Replublic and Democracy are orthogonal concepts. Yes, you're correct. I should have been more accurate and said a Republic CAN be a Democracy, or specifically said Democratic Republic. I'll edit my post to clarify. > I have frequently observed Americans commenting on this forum and on Reddit that America is a republic but not a democracy. This confuses me so much. It's a political talking point that often gets interpreted as fact. Democrats want a more direct Democracy, specifically things like eliminating the Electoral College. In that case, because the Electoral College is specifically setup to tamp down the power of high population states which are generally Democratic (as in the party) strong holds. To that end, you hear them claim Republics are undemocratic, and the less informed of their ranks interpret this to mean Republics are mutually exclusive with Democracy. In more academic circles, there are arguments about the validity of a Republican (the system, not party) government, but that's rarely what you're encountering.
- Aboh33 5y agoLeft-Wing/Right-Wing/Center-Beak
- roenxi 5y ago"People we don't agree with, often representing views we don't like, often get into power! Democracy has failed us" And yet the logical conclusion never seems to be embracing a small limited government. The power base keeps expanding then everyone gets surprised when their side loses an election.
- mrfusion 5y agoAlso people can’t simply disagree anymore. The other side is just wrong or labeled some kind of denier or conspiracy theorist.
- BobbyJo 5y agoAssumption of good intentions has gone out the window. All I see on Reddit is 'so and so is evil!' and 'they want to punish the poor!'. It's impossible to make the case anymore that all sides want to improve everyone's lives and they simply disagree on the method.
- hanniabu 5y agoIn all fairness, there's a lot of system things in the US that's hostile against the poor
- BobbyJo 5y agoNeeding to trade resources for other resources is inherently hostile toward people with fewer resources. Even so, we can all acknowledge that the intent of such a system is to create a fair and prosperous society.
- mahogany 5y agoWhat I'm curious about is: when or how often has this sort of divide happened before? I'm wondering if this is a periodic phenomenon in the US. And if/when this has happened before -- what fixed this level of hostility?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zhdc1 5y agoIt's just as likely that the Republicans nominate one of Tim Scott, Marco Rubio, or Mitt Romney, and the US presidential election comes down to a qualified center-right Republican and Joe Biden.
- wand3r 5y agoI absolutely doubt this. I think it is extremely likely that Trump is nominated with Desantis. If not, it is expected that Desantis would be front runner. Straw polls do show Nikki Haley as main choice I believe though. Haven’t been following it thay closely. I think the 3 people you listed would be highly unlikely choices.
- deregulateMed 5y agoI'm so horribly disappointed in Biden. He ran a campaign pretending to be moderate, but cannot stop spending money. Doesn't seem to matter which party you choose, both are pro war and pro big government corruption/cronyism. At best I'll vote against the incumbent, at worst I'll vote third party. The plight of being a 10%er is that you don't have voting power or money.
- mindslight 5y agoI want to be fiscally conservative, but it's nonsensical without addressing the elephant in the room - inflationary policy. Spending money on deliberate projects is necessary to alleviate the nasty effects of the previous trillions that were, and still are, being given away to the banks. Focusing on the few scraps that the government throws to the people is a red herring. Also the Democrats' hands are tied, not being able to pass substantive non-financial legislation like HR1. Budget is one of the few things they can use this "reconciliation" to push through without filibuster, and so they're trying to use spending to solve everything.
- sremani 5y agoAnother day, another Harvard-Soviet fragilista dooms-day prediction. YAWN!
- gadders 5y agoThis is a pretty partisan article. It thinks only Trump and the Republicans are a threat to democracy.
- hanniabu 5y agoThey're the party that's passing voter suppression laws across the country
- gadders 5y agoThat is also a partisan view.
- caeril 5y agoRight. Just like properly implementing identity authentication in your application is user suppression. TOTP/U2F are evil, by this reasoning.
- blackbear_ 5y agoNice strawman. Now please tell me how banning voting on Sunday helps "properly implementing identity authentication"? (Whether the provision passed or not is not important, what matters is that it was proposed in the first place)
- threatofrain 5y agoYes, and the Christian Science Monitor is known for its American liberal bias.
- zests 5y agoI would advise people who are worried about this to read more global news. Similarly, read about political polarization in the US during the Nixon era.
- FreakyT 5y agoPeople on here seem to be missing the point — one of the (only 2) major political parties in the US has effectively declared that a core party doctrine is “any election that we lose is, ipso facto, fraudulent”. That sort of belief is what gets you to situations like what we see in Myanmar, with “declaration of fraud” being the only excuse for installing any leadership.
- pjc50 5y agoSee also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Bolivian_political_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Bolivian_political_crisis : a very disputed election. Is the US becoming a Latin American country?
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoThat's the accusation which emboldens irrational hate, yes. Where's the proof?
- thatswrong0 5y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/01/07/us/elections/electoral-college-biden-objectors.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/01/07/us/elections/... https://www.npr.org/2021/02/28/970877930/why-republicans-are-moving-to-fix-elections-that-werent-broken https://www.npr.org/2021/02/28/970877930/why-republicans-are... https://www.salon.com/2021/02/27/republicans-roll-out-tidal-wave-of-voter-suppression-253-restrictive-bills-in-43-states/ https://www.salon.com/2021/02/27/republicans-roll-out-tidal-... Irrational..? Are you really just going to ignore the elephants in the room here?
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoYes, and voter id laws are racist. Pull the other one.
- thatswrong0 5y agoGood point. You're right - the intention behind these laws is obviously to secure our elections (since we had such a fraudulent, unfair election last time) and not at all about trying to disenfranchise the opposing political party and undermine the democratic process. Separate but equal facilities are fair, right? https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-wisconsin-election-2020-government-and-politics-daa3ac227c936d7fc038996af6e27cbe https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-wisconsin-election-2... https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/mar/02/texas-polling-sites-closures-voting https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/mar/02/texas-pollin... https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/02/politics/georgia-voter-rolls-report/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/02/politics/georgia-voter-rolls-... https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2021-07-01/supreme-court-upholds-arizonas-voting-restrictions-turns-away-democrats-challenge https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2021-07-01/supreme-co...
- jkingsbery 5y ago> Another is that we have a very strong opposition. The Democratic Party is well organized, it’s well financed. It controls the most economically and culturally powerful regions of the country. So... the party that holds the presidency and both chambers of Congress is the "opposition?" That's an interesting take on things. Perhaps he means "opposition to authoritarianism," but the party of "I have a pen and a phone" and "We need to pass the bill to find what's in it" has it's own authoritarian tendencies. I'm NOT a fan of Trump, but the idea that this is a problem only with the Republicans is silly. So is the idea that the dissolving of "mutual toleration" mentioned in the article is a one way street. There are plenty of interviews like this one https://www.nationalreview.com/2021/07/ive-never-felt-this-sense-of-discrimination/ https://www.nationalreview.com/2021/07/ive-never-felt-this-s... that express how norms on the left have also changed pretty drastically over the past few years. The government has been in multiple law suits with a group of nuns, called the "Little Sisters of the Poor," all of whom are celibate and most of whom are elderly, trying to force them to buy health insurance that includes birth control. Maybe that group of nuns is misguided, but how does the left demonstrate mutual respect? How do situations like that demonstrate "restraint in using their institutional powers?"
- FactolSarin 5y agoOnly one side is trying to undermine the electoral process itself. Don't forget that many Republicans voted against certifying election results. Sorry those nuns are upset about buying health insurance, but I pay for all kinds of things I don't want to pay for too. Having good faith debates about that kind of thing is part of democracy though, and in the end it's pretty minor. Showing restraint in institutional power means not using that power in an attempt to overturn an election just because you think you could legally get away with it.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Only one side is trying to undermine the electoral process itself. I'm no partisan Republican, but I don't think that's true. Creating seats until you gain control also undermines electoral process, and the "For the People Act" pushed DC statehood. That's a naked grab for two more safe Democratic Senate seats, especially when any concerns about the enfranchisement of DC residents could be solved with less of a partisan power-play (like letting Maryland annex most of DC). If you read liberal-leaning comment sections (e.g. like the NYT's), there's a lot more extreme fantasizing about creating new liberal states and abolishing or politically neutering conservative ones. I definitely think the Republicans have been "trying to undermine the electoral process itself" more blatantly, but the Democrats aren't saints either. And frankly, if the Republican threat to democracy is so dire, probably the best thing to save it is for the Democrats to shoot their progressive wing in the head and loudly run to the center, become competitive in conservative states, and focusing on routing the Republican party above other ideological goals.
- hackeraccount 5y agoI think there's a popular form of argument that basically goes "The person I disagree with is wrong but more then being wrong they don't actually believe the wrong thing they're saying rather they believe something so terrible that you the listener would immediately reject them if you knew it." The argument quickly strike at it's opponents in the worst ways as disingenuous liars and damns anyone convinced by it as an easily duped fool. Here's the thing, while it's only marginally effective at convincing someone who disagrees with you to change their mind it's really effective at getting people who already agree with you to show support. I understand the appeal. Actually changing anyone's mind is probably impossible. If you want someone to do something they don't want to do you need to use both empathy and intelligence to show the person why the thing they think they don't want is actually something they do want. It's really hard. The alternative is try and make them feel bad about themselves. To get the people who already agree with you super fired up. To win utterly without compromise. I appreciate the enthusiasm but it's a total pipe dream.