4 ms·
Does this mean you're reconsidering your opinion that the idea of "free will" is meaningless in an atheistic context? ;-) Link to a PDF outlining the study, wi
by thaumaturgy 18y ago
Does this mean you're reconsidering your opinion that the idea of "free will" is meaningless in an atheistic context? ;-)
Link to a PDF outlining the study, with graphs and methodology: [http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v11/n5/suppinfo/nn.2112_S1.html http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v11/n5/suppinfo/nn.2112_...]
Regardless, I don't see how this particular experiment threatens the idea of free will. It found that there was a disconnect between the moment that a person made a decision -- subconsciously -- and the moment in which they became aware of their decision, or "decided to make a decision".
Also, the decisions being made required no consideration on the part of the subjects, which I think is an important factor when talking about free will. The test subjects didn't have to consider the consequences of their decisions before making them; they simply pushed a button with either their left or right hand.
- gaika 18y agoYes, "free will" question as in "conscious choice" is the only formulation I found that doesn't involve supernatural. The answer still seems to be "no".
- sysop073 18y agoThis same foolish title confused Digg users a few months ago when this came out. It should really be "Brain Scanners Can See Your Decisions Before You Know You've Made Them"
- Hexstream 18y agoAlso nothing can possibly see a decision before it's made because it doesn't yet exist, by definition.