2 ms·
>> Investments flow to the highest-returning investment. > Which is the most productive. That's just a tautological statement. "It's more productive because i
by triceratops 5y ago
>> Investments flow to the highest-returning investment.
> Which is the most productive.
That's just a tautological statement. "It's more productive because it returns more money. Why does it return more money? Because it's more productive."
And you go on to contradict yourself about 2 sentences later when you say:
>> patent trolls
> are unintended consequences of poorly conceived laws, not free markets.
Which means not every investment that makes money is productive.
In a hypothetical free market where every actor has perfect agency, it might be true that money follows productivity. But just like "true socialism has never been tried" (scoff) there has never been a true "free market". In the market we actually operate in, wealth accumulation can be zero-sum.
> is the process of finding the value of something, which is productive.
Depends on the thing. IMO if the underlying thing (such as crypto or gold) isn't productive in and of itself, speculation on it is also zero sum.
Land may or may not be productive, depending on how it's being used. Poorly conceived laws also make it possible to achieve massive profits through real estate speculation without "producing" any wealth - which is zero-sum.
I reject the reductive view that someone only earns money when they increase productivity. Productivity increases will create new wealth. But wealth accumulation for individual actors is possible without providing any productivity increase whatsoever.
Every market participant is a neural network whose objective is to increase its own wealth. How this is done is rarely part of the equation.
- WalterBright 5y ago> you go on to contradict yourself Not at all. Please read more carefully. > crypto Can be productive. After all, people find many uses for it. But I think I'll check out of this. Seems to me you're just being argumentative. I'll leave you with the last word.