3 ms·
Correct. The key idea for this project was it's carrot and stick, all UK providers get adult ID they can use to hook billing (a carrot), and then we block all
by tialaramex 5y ago
Correct.
The key idea for this project was it's carrot and stick, all UK providers get adult ID they can use to hook billing (a carrot), and then we block all access to any non-UK providers who don't get in line (the stick), thus protecting the schmucks who fell into line rather than leaving. They hope this is enough to pressure global companies into doing the same and once it's the status quo they assume it stays that way through inertia.
The white paper says OK, some Britons will use Tor and there's no a lot we can do about that, but most Britons won't know how or won't bother. We can block everything else by beefing up DNS blocks that big UK ISPs already implement, the remaining ISPs can be forced to do the same or we'll lock them up, it'll cause a few protests and so on but we can weather that with our overwhelming public support.
All that's before TLS 1.3 and before DoH let alone ECH, oblivious DoH, and onwards into the foreseeable future. So today the result is that the "stick" part of the plan doesn't work and it will work less every day, their citizens can trivially choose not to accept the limitation and will do so in huge numbers. Without the stick, the carrot doesn't look very juicy after all, the non-UK market doesn't want your censored ID-requiring site, there's a better one without those problems. And of course today that government looks a lot more tired and unpopular than when this was originally floated.
The price for this quixotic moral crusade continues to soar, the eventual purpose of it remains unclear, eventually maybe Boris' replacement will announce (to applause) that the government has abandoned it, after spending all this time and money to no purpose.