2 ms·
Again, it's entirely possible to have big businesses without having billionaires. I just don't see why you are set on tying the two concepts together. You seem
by ModernMech 5y ago
Again, it's entirely possible to have big businesses without having billionaires. I just don't see why you are set on tying the two concepts together. You seem to think there would be no industry if there were no potential at having more money than you could spend in 1000 lifetimes.
I'm sorry, but we're going to have to agree to disagree there, because I'm just not buying that.
> The US is a first world economy and a first world military.
Depends on who you ask. There's a meme going around right now of a split screen "billionaire space race" with a chyron reading "Millions of Americans facing eviction". Tie that to the story today "Full-time minimum wage workers can't afford rent anywhere in the US" and I really have to wonder what "first world economy" really means. I mean, just today the US government started issuing checks to families with children in order to reduce child poverty... how is that even a thing in a first world economy where billionaires are racing to space? Seems broken to me.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Depends on who you ask I've asked people who lived in the former Soviet Bloc. I also know that the USSR build a wall to keep people in, and the US builds a wall to keep people out. People are also trying to swim away from Cuba. I don't think you can wish that away. > it's entirely possible to have big businesses without having billionaires The two have always gone together.
- ModernMech 5y ago> the US builds a wall to keep people out. People are also trying to swim away from Cuba. I mean, as you say the US is the #1 economic and military power in the world, and they have been imposing crippling economic sanctions on Cuba for 60 years. You really can't evaluate the situation fairly without including that relevant bit of information. > The two have always gone together. Under capitalism, yes, because that's how capitalism works. But one is not a necessary condition of the other. I've already given an example to disprove your assertion.
- nickpp 5y agoAn economics teacher, when aggressively asked to prove why capitalism is the better system by his left-leaning students tells them: "At the end of this year I will grade each student individual performance in private but officially you will all receive the same grade, the average of the entire class grades instead, so it is fair for everybody." They loved it. At the end of the year some work got A grades, some B and some F. But on the average they all received a very honorable B+. However, next year, with the exact same algorithm, all students received the same grade: Fail. A society where people are not rewarded each according to his merit is a society where people are not trying their hardest to improve. If you prevent billionaires you also prevent your best performers, your middle class, your millionaires, your small businesses and such. The end result is a uniformly poor society where the most vulnerable hurt the most. Just like communism.
- ModernMech 5y agoThat's a nice little joke, but it bears little resemblance to capitalism vs. communism. This whole thread isn't even really about capitalism vs. communism, but it went that way because that's the way it seems to go anytime the economic order is challenged. "Billionaires are bad" -> "Well communism is worse!" Okay... but that doesn't change anything I said about billionaires and the USA. Anyway, you seem to be under the impression that capitalism is a system that rewards merit, and communism is a system that doesn't. That's just not true. Capitalism is a system that rewards ownership, not merit. You're essentially saying that everyone who is rich deserves what they have, and as I look around at the pantheon of the wealthiest individuals in the world, I'm not seeing a lot of merit. Where are all the Nobel prize winners? Where are all the billionaire scientists? Rewards based on ownership are the opposite of rewards based on merit -- you are required to show zero merit under a capitalist society to reap rewards, just a piece of paper declaring your ownership in an asset, ownership which is enforced by the state through violence. How does this lead to a meritorious society? To me it seems it would lead to a society where people don't strive for merit but for ownership of assets. Look, all I'm arguing for is proportionality. No one is ever going to convince me that the 1% have so much merit that they deserve more wealth than billions of people. > The end result is a uniformly poor society where the most vulnerable hurt the most. Just like communism. The end result of capitalism is a society where 1% of the population own 95% of the wealth. Not uniformly poor, I'll give you that. It's quite lopsided and tilted. But one thing's for sure, the most vulnerable are still hurt the most under our capitalist society. Like I said in another post, the USA is sending out child tax credits to reduce childhood poverty this week. Poor children are some of the most vulnerable people in our society, and they are hurting so bad the government has to step in. Capitalism is doing nothing for them. And anyway, It's not like there aren't plenty of uniformly poor capitalist countries around today. Just look at Haiti for an example how of how bad it can get.