3 ms·
But then you need a different vehicle to refuel the original one. If you're doing that, why not just use that second vehicle for the mission and forget about
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
But then you need a different vehicle to refuel the original one. If you're doing that, why not just use that second vehicle for the mission and forget about reuse?
Reusing second stages in space only really makes sense once you are making your fuel in space.
- rbanffy 5y agoMaking fuel on the Moon or on Mars is more or less the plan for any sustainable development of the solar system. Unless we get sci-fi grade engines, it’s just unfeasible to send fuel from Earth.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThat's a chicken and egg problem. Making fuel off of Earth is going to require so much mass for infrastructure that it won't be feasible until we have fully reusable vehicles.
- Robotbeat 5y agoAn acquaintance of mine who works in the industry (not at SpaceX) called Raptor a “scifi engine.” For a lot of purposes, Starship should make it extremely cheap to send propellant from Earth. $10/kg in LEO. Cheaper than any lunar mining proposal I’ve seen. That said, I hope we do make propellant off-Earth eventually.
- SEJeff 5y agoYeah if I remember correctly, I read that the solar panels required to ISRU make enough methane on Mars for a starship return flight would be two football fields worth and it would take them a few years to do it.
- Robotbeat 5y agoArea is just not a huge problem on Mars or in space in general. It’s not really a relevant figure of merit, unlike mass and pre-deployed volume