25 ms·
Apple employees say the company is cracking down on remote work
- dang 5y agoWe changed the URL from https://appleinsider.com/articles/21/07/15/apple-employees-threaten-to-quit-as-company-takes-hard-line-stance-on-remote-work https://appleinsider.com/articles/21/07/15/apple-employees-t..., which points to this. Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dijit 5y agoI say this as a person who likes Apple products generally. Good. This open office garbage has to end; remote work is one thing but you're asking people to basically give up having a private office with no commute to sit in a visually noisy (if not auditorially noisy) space so that some managers can live the panopticon. People make the flexibility argument about open offices: but Apple is not the company that needs to be flexible. People make the collaboration argument; but studies show people do not interact more in open offices. People make the financial argument; but Apple is the most valuable company in the world. There is no justification for this, it's just politicking and managers wanting to feel power.
- aspaceman 5y ago> There is no justification for this, it's just politicking and managers wanting to feel power. They must want to make the investment in that massive office feel worth it? Like that "we built a new office that emphasizes our company's values" garbage works great on management. I wonder how much is wanting to watch over the employees, and how much is wanting to make good on your fancy new toy. I find it very difficult to justify requiring Apple employees in the office. I obviously don't think highly of Apples' creative and engineering talent... do they still have weight to pull at the company? It seems like a management farm to me now. I hope that doesn't seem harsh.
- grillvogel 5y ago>People make the collaboration argument; but studies show people do not interact more in open offices. i do not buy this at all. in the office i interacted with dozens of people daily that i otherwise have no specific reason to directly send slack message to.
- samatman 5y agoThe argument against open plan offices is different (and stronger) than the argument against having offices at all. Private offices with public congregating areas and meeting rooms are strictly better than open offices, in my opinion. Even cube farms are an improvement over the bullpen open plan, if a company can't afford enough real estate to give everyone their own office. Remote work entails stronger tradeoffs. I've been at it for four years, and would never go back, but it does take a certain sort of personality and working style to make it functional, and the case for offices is strong. The post you're replying to was perhaps conflating the two questions, but was specific about addressing open plan offices.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago>Private offices with public congregating areas and meeting rooms are strictly better than open offices, in my opinion. Even cube farms are an improvement over the bullpen open plan, if a company can't afford enough real estate to give everyone their own office. I can't agree with this enough. Private cubes and offices always felt like I was given the respect I was entitled. You understand that when I clock in and clock out, I am working. I am converting man hours into the task you need done. I am not screwing around doing nothing all day. Managers whom I've had that didn't like those ideas and wanted you in open office environments tended to be power oriented or had nothing else better to do with their time but to spy on employees.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pokstad 5y agoWho said they had open offices?
- dijit 5y agoThere was a large backlash when Apple was forcing employees to move to Apple Park (with open offices). Apples most innovative years were done with mostly private offices. https://daringfireball.net/thetalkshow/2017/08/06/ep-197 https://daringfireball.net/thetalkshow/2017/08/06/ep-197 https://www.inc.com/geoffrey-james/apple-employees-hate-apples-5-billion-open-plan-o.html https://www.inc.com/geoffrey-james/apple-employees-hate-appl...
- saagarjha 5y agoApple Park is full of glass walls and open offices; information on this is not that hard to find.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoIn my experience, people talk less with coworkers while work from home. Not only that, but I don't have to be concerned with my coworkers screwing off while I pick up the slack. It's completely out of sight out of mind. The best part in my opinion, everything is in writing for the most part. "Hey Chuck can you take this ticket? Sandra can you forward that to me?" It forces the lazy people to get smart or get to work. Fortunately for me at my company, they basically said all non-essential IT is permanently work from home. Essential are people who need to maintain hardware. So I kinda lucked out.
- rantwasp 5y agoit depends a lot of the culture (i don’t think there is a one size fits all). i am spending more time shooting the sh*t with my team mates since the pandemic started. it’s a mix of slack async + “face to face” meetings. we have a social hour each week + a google hangout that stays open 24/7 for people to chat if they feel like it (most of the time nobody is there but i’ve seen 2-3 people “accumulate” at time and 50/50 is not work related)
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoEven shared offices (2-3 people) are infinitely better than an open office or cubicle.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- musicale 5y agoI understand why people would prefer working at home vs. Apple Park's open plan. In addition to reasons such as reducing commute headaches, flexibility in taking care of children, ability to take naps as needed, etc., people may find working at home to be simply more productive than working in the office, perhaps due in part to improved privacy and reduced distraction and interruptions from co-workers and bosses compared with open plan office spaces. Probably employees should start looking at remote work options outside of Apple. One benefit of moving to another company is that you usually get a much larger raise compared to what you would get if you stayed at the same company. And Apple (and other companies) should examine why people don't want to come in to the office in the first place. It might not actually be because employees want to slack off and avoid doing any work. (And bosses seem to conflate butts in chairs with productivity, but it's usually more about being able to monitor employees and having an enjoyable sense of superiority, control and ownership over them.) Since more people want to work at home, Apple might be also be able to modify its office space to provide improved privacy and visual/sound isolation. Ideally they could add more walled offices for rank-and-file employees to provide real privacy and destroy the idea of walled offices as a social status symbol reserved for managers.
- jrs235 5y agoSometimes I think the cracking down on remote companies/edict is because it "helps prove" how wanting a person wishes to work at the company. Knowing an employee's loyalty and willingness to put up with BS makes it easier for other abuses in the future.
- iJohnDoe 5y agoThis is a profound thought. It should be taken more seriously. It’s two-fold. I also think it’s a test how loyal an employee is to the company, especially how Apple thinks. “Those who want to leave can leave.” The problem is that some real talent can be lost with this approach. Second, those who stay might not actually be treated like the loyal employees they are supposed to be treated as, especially not by all tiers of management. They might be treated as those who were desperate to stay to keep their job and treated as such.
- sushid 5y agoThis is already mentioned in the comments section of the article but I find the claim ridiculous. > Apple will apparently make exceptions for people with documented medical conditions, but acquiring that accommodation reportedly requires employees to confirm their status by releasing medical records to the company. The demand made some people uncomfortable, the report said. If you have a medical exemption requiring accommodations to allow for remote work, I think it makes sense that you provide some sort of proof. How is that unfair?
- iaw 5y agoYour employer should not be the arbiter of your health, your doctor should. Your doctor should be able to determine what you are and are not capable of doing and communicate that to your employer who should take that as proof. This whole "let's see your medical history" approach is a very slippery slope and one I hope we don't fall down. Edit: For more context, your doctor could determine in one visit that you have a newly arisen chronic ailment that's debilitating but your employer may set a threshold of a certain # of visits over a period of time in order to qualify for that chronic ailment...
- slownews45 5y agoEmployers have a right to know about the disability and the functional limitations it imposes. In fact, they can even have you to go to an employer selected doctor if you're not giving them good info / good docs - this is someone who will be paid by employer to check into your condition and report back to them.
- saagarjha 5y agoSource? This sounds like a major violation of medical record confidentiality laws.
- slownews45 5y agoStart with EEOC-CVG-2003-1 "May an employer require an individual to go to a health care professional of the employer's (rather than the employee's) choice for purposes of documenting need for accommodation and disability? The ADA does not prevent an employer from requiring an individual to go to an appropriate health professional of the employer's choice if the individual provides insufficient information from his/her treating physician (or other health care professional) to substantiate that s/he has an ADA disability and needs a reasonable accommodation. " Note - I'm not aware of this being common because employees will generally be better off having their own doctor release their own records or respond to employers questions about medical condition. Again, records are limited to the specific issue and need for accommodation / functional issues etc.
- slownews45 5y agoNot knocking working from home but - 1) Will employees demanding work from home / Utah etc be willing to accept Utah pay rates? You could probably just negotiate some deal, 50% of pay and full time work from home. 2) Were people hired based on an expectation of 5 days in office or work from home? 3) A fair bit of buzzword bingo - ADA claims, claims around diversity and inclusion. Are these things Apple is prioritizing or is to going to be what they consider useful for product and business execution? 4) The higher performing employees I know don't tend to go on strike, demand X, etc. They just find another job. 5) When someone says Apple Employees with no qualification - is that all employees - if so you'd think this would be bigger news. Apple is likely at 100K+ employees. Even just a basic 10% attrition rate (avg is 17%) would be 10K+ employees per year. My guess is their turnover rate is lower (maybe 5%?) normally. Our own offices went to high wall cubicles to reduce spread of germs, reduce audio distractions for zoom calls etc - I actually like it a lot. High noise absorbing walls (6') does wonders to overall sound in a space if everyone has them. Even have wrap around on desk edge so it's 3.5 sides.
- iaw 5y ago1) Most of the roles can just switch to another FAANG where the largest discount is 85% instead of 50%. 2) Employers have changed the terms of employment at will for decades, I can literally find stories from a hundred years ago. This is a situation where employees are changing the terms (which also happened a hundred years ago in the US) 3) The American Disabilities Act is a law, diversity and inclusion are concepts. There is a large difference between being bad for diversity/inclusion and violating the law. When you violate the ADA you open yourself up to lawsuit (although the loss is a drop in the bucket for a company Apples size) 4) And? Companies need all types. The mid-performers and even the low-performers provide value (otherwise they wouldn't maintain employment). If all you care about are your high performers you'll have a larger churn and pay the price. 5) It's the verge, do you really think they're for high quality rigorous analytics reporting? No, they got a few chat threads and made some inferences. It may be that literally only 10 people at the company care about this (unlikely)
- slownews45 5y ago
- robertwt7 5y agoSo pre-pandemic, they're all hired to go to the office 5 days a week, now after pandemic, they don't even want to go back 3 days a week?
- stunt 5y agoPerhaps they experienced WFH for the first time and they don’t want to lose it.
- hh3k0 5y agoIt is difficult to go back to a worse status quo ante once an improvement in quality of life has been experienced.
- city41 5y agoPost-pandemic, almost all FAANGs adopted a full remote work policy. Apple competes with these companies for talent.
- justaguy88 5y agoWhich ones specifically?
- city41 5y agoThe ones I know of are Facebook, Twitter and Netflix.
- 1270018080 5y agoNetflix's CEO has been vocally anti-WFH since the beginning.
- wumpus 5y agoF, A, N, and G.
- guiltygods 5y agoApple does not need to compete. it is not as if FAANG guys can suddenly absorb 1000s of employees trying to switch. it will create even more selective hiring.
- stephc_int13 5y agoApple is still huge and powerful, benefiting from a massive inertia, but I don’t believe in its future. The new Apple is as boring as IBM. As corporate as it gets, lazy, crazy rich with no vision.
- rajacombinator 5y agoUnfortunately, they have no serious competition.
- stephc_int13 5y agoOn which market?
- samatman 5y agoSure, they haven't released an innovative product that made the entire industry sit up and take notice in like, a whole year now. Losing their touch!
- TheParkShark 5y agoDuring their presentations it seems as if all the speakers are just going through the steps, faking emotions and smiles. Very few show actual passion and I think it’s bleeding over with this working from home issue. Apple simply doesn’t mean much to many of its employees, they view it as only a paycheck and they’re trying to maximize their harvest.
- underseacables 5y agoI wish the media would look at smaller, less known companies and their employees. Apple is a place people the world over would love to work at, and would gladly give up working from home to get a job at. I can totally understand desire to work from home, but those article seems like these employees are just spoiled.
- deregulateMed 5y agoDepends. I refuse to work for military contractors and companies who ban Pro Freedom Apps and give their data to dictators. Some people have ethical standards. Not sure what percentage.
- grillvogel 5y agoand they will be replaced by people who are willing to come in. do employees actually think they are not replaceable?
- dcolkitt 5y agoGo try to hire 100 talented software engineers for non-remote work in this market and tell me how replaceable they are.
- deregulateMed 5y agoLet them quit, unless it's their marketing department. Throw more money at the marketing department to make them comply. Apple users have always dealt with hardware and software issues, the engineers are interchangeable. The brand image is non negotiable.
- smoldesu 5y agoI know you're being sardonic, but that's probably the mentality at the top right now. They can ebb and flow as many employees as they want right now.
- deregulateMed 5y agoMaybe the cynical definition. I've used enough Apple products to wonder "WTF is everyone else thinking."
- guiltygods 5y agoActually engineers are not interchangeable. whilst marketing and sales are. both hardware and software engineers have proprietary knowledge of products, marketing can be picked up by anyone with couple of weeks of orientation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gnicholas 5y agoI imagine part of this is an income effect based on the stock price rise. AAPL is about up 500% from where it was five years ago, which means that employees who have been there a while are likely sitting on a decent pile of equity/cash. If their plan is to work remotely from a low/moderate CoL location, their equity could give them a pretty long runway there. Of course, the well-performing stock is probably part of the reason that Apple is insistent on asking employees to return, because they believe that they'll be able to hire new employees (who will be attracted by equity, among other things) to replace people who leave.
- _Adam 5y agoThe title is accurate, but misleading. "Employees are now discussing how best to respond, whether it be through another letter or legal action. About 10 people plan to resign or know others who will resign due to the hybrid policy, the report said" Ten is more than one, but the article makes it sound like an exodus is impending.
- dcolkitt 5y agoThere’s an old maxim from marketing. If one person is pissed off enough to write your company a letter, than there’s 100 other dissatisfied customers with the same experience that you’re about to lose.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe newly gained experience of widespread working at home could be applied in creative, constructive ways: For example, offices could be changed to provide some of the benefits of home. Napping could become normalized, for example. More child care facilities could be provided. What else? Hours could be adjusted, so parents are home when their kids return from school: Instead of distributing hours in full days at the office or home, how about being at the office 5-6 hours/day and at home the rest? Hours could be more flexible, normalizing people running errands and doing other things during the day. Dress codes? Pajama Fridays? What else? EDIT: This HN thread and many others are filled with arguments for working from home. It's a hot topic and you can find them all elsewhere. Here I'm asking a different question: How can offices be improved based on what we've learned?
- dcolkitt 5y agoNone of this addresses the reasons that I and, I think, most others prefer remote work. I don’t want to miss watching my kids grow up because by the time I drive home they’re already in bed. I want to spend my lunch hour with my family, instead of gossiping with my coworkers about office politics. I want to raise my children in a community of my choosing, surrounded by close friends and family, instead of the SFBA, which I have no connection to and frankly hate. I don’t want to waste literal years of my life commuting, which is consistently shown to be the least happy part of people’s day.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoIt's amazing to me that this many obvious things need to be explained. People really are slaves to their jobs.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhenever I think like that, it usually turns out that it wasn't so obvious because I am the one missing something.
- heavyset_go 5y ago
- runawaybottle 5y agoQuite frankly, Apple is not a company that can be remote. All their stuff can be leaked, the attack vector is too large. I understand the hard line stance here. If you are working on a bumble fuck app, great, work from home. There are websites that are ready to publish any little rumor about a new feature in ‘Find my Mac’ because someone’s wife spied it, and told her friend. Consider this a good problem.
- dcolkitt 5y agoAnd yet Apple Inc had been more than fine after more than a year of full remote work. Their stock price and profits are at record highs, despite being in the middle of a global recession. Clearly nosy spouses peeking into the home office do not pose an existential risk to the company.
- billyhoffman 5y agoIs it not? It’s operated the last 18 months as a remote company. The number of Apple leaks don’t seem any different than any other year. Yes, if you’re working on next gen hardware I can see how that could be challenging. But what about the 2000 employees they have that do App review? (This number was revealed in their ongoing court case with epic) I would wager the majority of jobs at Apple don’t involve things that require physical isolated access
- runawaybottle 5y agoI’d say that is the case because it was a unique year and half. If you extend out the paradigm over ten years, voila, the graph will show itself. The number of leaks will definitely show itself once you adjust the variable of time. Time and human nature is an age old tale.
- lkschubert8 5y agoSo your argument is that if given time data will show your argument is right? I feel like there needs to be a little more support than that.
- neom 5y agoI thought apple had its own internal communications tooling, are all teams at apple using slack?
- saagarjha 5y agoYes, Apple uses Slack internally.
- managerslol 5y agoThe real story here is why are execs and managers desperate to get back in offices. And the answer is that remote has exposed how useless they are. Worse than useless in fact. While before they were more able to Harrison Bergeron their productive employees with useless face time meetings, remote has increased the value gap. So they desperately need to bring these employees down to Earth, before they start getting ideas.
- temikus 5y agoI see a lot of this FAANG "threatening" - walk the talk people! I did and I don't regret it. Until people start to actually take action nothing will change. P.S. Yes I recognize that there may be people in precarious situations who may not afford such actions but majority of FAANG employees are not it.